The economic hardship deferral formula is pretty crappy. However, if you find yourself just under the cut-off, there are ways to still get economic hardship deferral - depending on who you consolidated with. For instance, I consolidated last year with the US Dept of Ed. They told me that if for some reason I didn't make the cut-off in a given year, I could present them with other statements (private loans, mortgage, etc.) that they would then take into account to grant deferral. They seemed pretty flexible about it. You might want to check directly with your consolidator for more info.