Is it possible to get the admission stats for CCLCM separately from that of Case - number of applicants, number interviews, number of offers, etc.? Does CCLCM offer more financial aid compared to Case, particularly since the students have to pay for a fifth year?
There was some comparison between Mayo and CCLCM in last year's threads, could any current students elaborate?
I'm not sure on the admissions stats of CCLCM vs. Mayo- I know that I got waitlisted at Mayo and accepted immediately at CCLCM if that helps
🙂 Seriously, though, I'll try to compare the two. Mayo is a hard school to talk about admissions at because it's so difficult to know what they're looking for. Many people with high scores, high grades and great volunteer experiences get rejected without interviews, while others that seeme more borderline cases get full scholarships. Cleveland Clinic emphasizes research quite a bit, so if you have that in addition to all the things that med schools in general want you're probably doing good, though each year CCLCM is getting more competitive.
Now for financial aid: Mayo's financial aid is merit based- everyone gets at least 1/2 tuition (which varies depending on whether you're in state or out of state) and based on merit some get 3/4 or full tuition scholarships. CCLCM's financial aid is mainly needbased with some merit awards, and it's extremely generous. Everyone receives some sort of grant money, and I know that multiple people (including myself
🙂 are going tuition free. In addition, you are paid a 3,000 stipend for research in your first two summers. You don't have to pay tuition during the fifth year, just a small continuation fee and you get a stipend for living expenses during that year.
Now for a more general comparison:
Mayo and Cleveland are very similar in some ways- small class size, prestigious hospital, enthusiastic faculty, emphasis on professionalism, great financial aid. The big difference in my mind is actually curriculum. Cleveland Clinic is very much a PBL approach, and your learning is very independent. At Mayo, you're still divided into small groups but a teacher is leading you through the material. I would prefer to have the teacher leading me through, but other people thrive in the more independent setting. Also, the emphasis on independent study leaves you with a much more flexible schedule, allowing for research during the school year if you so choose. Either way you have the advantage of a small class size, which as JDW said means that the faculty are going to be making calls for you and writing you much better letters of recc than a school with hundreds of students.
I was nervous about coming to such a new med school, and I'm not sure I like PBL- And yet, I'm extremely happy here, and I feel confident about how our class is going to do in residency placements. I don't think you can go wrong either way- Cleveland Clinic and Mayo are both excellent med schools with enthusiastic and dedicated faculty. At this point my advice is to relax and just wait and see where you get in. If you get into both, then the two main determinants I would use are location and curriculum (Are you an independent learner or do you need teachers and tests to help you along? Do you like rural Minnesota? If not, Cleveland may be looking pretty good...)
Best of luck!