Challenge: What do all humans have in common?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Womb Raider

Full Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2013
Messages
3,499
Reaction score
3,126
What makes us "human"? What is our unique distinguishing characteristic(s) that we all have in common? I have my thoughts, but am anxious to hear yours.

*EDIT*
I'm looking for something that is exclusively a human quality/attribute. E.g. a "heart" is incorrect, since other creatures have hearts.
 
Last edited:
Great avatar, Stifler! lol

Besides anatomical characteristics...it has to be a higher sense of emotion...empathy? Well I guess then it'd be what all humans are capable of, not what they exhibit.
 
Besides anatomical characteristics...it has to be a higher sense of emotion...empathy? Well I guess then it'd be what all humans are capable of, not what they exhibit.

1. What about people born without certain anatomical characteristics. E.g. born with no arms.

2. You may be right, although it's hard to know if other creatures are capable of this type of thought / compassion.
 
Great avatar, Stifler! lol

Besides anatomical characteristics...it has to be a higher sense of emotion...empathy? Well I guess then it'd be what all humans are capable of, not what they exhibit.

I think it's an interesting question because we have to ask - what about pathologies? For example, empathy is a good answer to the original question, but what about sociopaths who feel no remorse or empathy? We might be defined by our anatomy, but then would a paraplegic be "less than human"? Maybe the question is impossible to answer within the given framework - is there actually any unique trait that literally ALL of us have?
 
The ability to consider, interest in, and ascribing importance to the question "what makes us human."
 
I took the question to mean what we all have in common as human not what we all have in common but not with other animals.

I'd say a unique human only characteristic is being able to conceptualize the future, determine if that possibility is desirable or not and make current changes to affect the future.

Knowledge of our own mortality is also a unique human trait
 
Fun fact, the actor who plays Stiffler works out at my gym.

On topic, look up Theory of Mind. It is said that only humans truly possess theory of mind, though Chimps can display a glimpse of it.
 
Babies still have the ability, or in extreme sense capability, to do these things. Whether they do or do not, or if it does or does not ever come to realization is another question. Other organisms do not.
 
But that's not really unique to humans though is it? I'd say the survival instinct makes us alive but not necessarily human.


Babies = not human?

Ooo interesting... Age a determining factor... Maybe I should rephrase the original question to specify adult humans?
Fun fact, the actor who plays Stiffler works out at my gym.

On topic, look up Theory of Mind. It is said that only humans truly possess theory of mind, though Chimps can display a glimpse of it.

However, do mentally ******ed people ponder these questions? (Or any other form of genetic mutation).
 
Computer Technology. does any other species create and use it?
 
I took the question to mean what we all have in common as human not what we all have in common but not with other animals.

I'd say a unique human only characteristic is being able to conceptualize the future, determine if that possibility is desirable or not and make current changes to affect the future.

Knowledge of our own mortality is also a unique human trait

1. What about a dog choosing not to jump into a fire?

2. Possibly, again I'm going to use the mentally ******ed as an exception here?
 
Real life. No bringing hobbits and goblins into this thread.
 
Fun fact, the actor who plays Stiffler works out at my gym.

On topic, look up Theory of Mind. It is said that only humans truly possess theory of mind, though Chimps can display a glimpse of it.

Not all humans possess a theory of mind, or at least a well developed one. You will definitely encounter that in medical school.
 
What makes us "human"? What is our unique distinguishing characteristic(s) that we all have in common? I have my thoughts, but am anxious to hear yours.

That's just a usual existential question that's been extensively answered. A simple search will gove you the answer
 
That's just a usual existential question that's been extensively answered. A simple search will gove you the answer

Which is? Most of the stuff I have found isn't true for all "humans."
 
One thing all human's share is the desire to be accepted as a part of some type of group. group being societal, political, cultural, etc. We are all inherently social creatures.
 
One thing all human's share is the desire to be accepted as a part of some type of group. group being societal, political, cultural, etc. We are all inherently social creatures.
The OP asked for qualities that are unique to humans. In that context, this wouldn't really work, since lots of mammals are social.
 
Great avatar, Stifler! lol

Besides anatomical characteristics...it has to be a higher sense of emotion...empathy? Well I guess then it'd be what all humans are capable of, not what they exhibit.
Fun fact, the actor who plays Stiffler works out at my gym.

On topic, look up Theory of Mind. It is said that only humans truly possess theory of mind, though Chimps can display a glimpse of it.

You can arguably claim that autism spectrum disorders preclude this.
 
Have you read Guns, Germs, and Steel? It might shed light on some factors that only humans seem to utilize, since our capabilities and potentials could be the inherent qualities that you were referring to.

A few of them are: Ability to learn languages as a means to store and extract long-term (not temporary at least, because species like ants can store and communicate through chemicals temporarily) information (even iliterate people can be educated) and trade of information and goods (even diapers are manufactured elsewhere, so sociopaths and those with mental disorders benefit from this trade as beneficiaries, just like everyone else).

However, when we try to include other humans like those in persistent vegetative states or with extremely rare illnesses, the qualities could become something that other animals all share as well. We often perceive ourselves as higher beings than other species, but when we include every single human being in all cases, we might not be too different from other species. If that is the case, sometimes I would think that what makes us human, like empathy, love, faith and seeking a sense of belonging and being loved, can be a part of what it means to live, rather than exclusively what it means to be a human being.
 
A few of them are: Ability to learn languages as a means to store and extract long-term (not temporary at least, because species like ants can store and communicate through chemicals temporarily) information (even iliterate people can be educated) and trade of information and goods (even diapers are manufactured elsewhere, so sociopaths and those with mental disorders benefit from this trade as beneficiaries, just like everyone else).
Parrots can be taught to use language, and chimpanzees can barter. So even excluding people in vegetative states and the like these qualities aren't totally unique. Outside of genetic similarity, I don't know that there is a single characteristic that encompasses ALL humans.
 
Parrots can be taught to use language, and chimpanzees can barter. So even excluding people in vegetative states and the like these qualities aren't totally unique. Outside of genetic similarity, I don't know that there is a single characteristic that encompasses ALL humans.

Very true. I was more referring to writing, reading, and trading in longer distances, but I understand your point.
 
Parrots can be taught to use language, and chimpanzees can barter. So even excluding people in vegetative states and the like these qualities aren't totally unique. Outside of genetic similarity, I don't know that there is a single characteristic that encompasses ALL humans.

Parrots can be taught to mimic speech, but they cannot express or record ideas and events with temporal significance using written/spoken word. Speech is significant insofar as that it allows for communication between humans and is requisite for the development of an oral history. Trained parrots can be taught to ask for specific food items or name objects, but I believe that the consensus is that this is more conditioning than anything else.
 
Parrots can be taught to mimic speech, but they cannot express or record ideas and events with temporal significance using written/spoken word. Speech is significant insofar as that it allows for communication between humans and is requisite for the development of an oral history. Trained parrots can be taught to ask for specific food items or name objects, but I believe that the consensus is that this is more conditioning than anything else.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alex_(parrot)

See the "Accomplishments" section. It's possible that everything there is due to conditioning, but it looks much more like semantic memory to me.
 
We were born from the body of another creature labeled 'human'.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alex_(parrot)

See the "Accomplishments" section. It's possible that everything there is due to conditioning, but it looks much more like semantic memory to me.

Alex understood the turn-taking of communication and often the syntax used in language.[10] He called an apple a "banerry", which Pepperberg thought to be a combination of "banana" and "cherry," two fruits he was more familiar with.

In July 2005, Pepperberg reported that Alex understood the concept of zero.

Those two bits were very interesting actually, but they still lack temporal thinking.
 
Top