Claymore

Yankees Suck
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Sep 25, 2000
383
0
chicago
Visit site
Status
Resident [Any Field]
Ok, so as interview season starts to wrap up, I've found that there are probably a few programs that I'm particularly interested in, much moreso than some others. My question is, roughly what percentage of people match at say, one of their top 3 places? What percentage match below #5? Not sure if there is official info on this, but anecdotes are welcome also.
 

Bob Loblaw

Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Sep 26, 2005
31
0
Status
Medical Student
The New Physician (AMSA's newletter) came out with an article last month about the logistics of the match. Here is a quote: "in a typical year, more than 60 percent of students get their first choices and 85 percent get one of their top three choices, a fact that can be hard for the nonmathematically inclined to fathom."

I consider myself mathematically inclined and I still can't fathom this. I guess that a lot of people don't rank prestigious programs #1.

If I get one of my top 4 choices (all of which are in NYC), I will be thrilled. Is the chance of that greater than 85%?
 

Cardsfan

Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Jan 29, 2005
66
0
Status
Bob Loblaw said:
The New Physician (AMSA's newletter) came out with an article last month about the logistics of the match. Here is a quote: "in a typical year, more than 60 percent of students get their first choices and 85 percent get one of their top three choices, a fact that can be hard for the nonmathematically inclined to fathom."

I consider myself mathematically inclined and I still can't fathom this. I guess that a lot of people don't rank prestigious programs #1.

If I get one of my top 4 choices (all of which are in NYC), I will be thrilled. Is the chance of that greater than 85%?
Well, I think they way it works out is that the top programs only interview X amount of applicants, say 8-10 per position. So if there are 5-10 "top programs" I think it all kinda evens out. If you dont interview at a place, you probably wont be ranking it, so thats why so many people dont rank the top programs number 1. Hope this makes sense
 
About the Ads

doctorlarry

Member
10+ Year Member
Jul 6, 2004
182
5
Status
Attending Physician
I wonder if the data above applies to the Neurology match in particular. In other words, do I have an 85% chance of matching in my top 3 neurology programs? It would be nice to hear from those who matched into Neurology last year.

Also, sometimes I wonder how much an interview actually helps/hinders our standing when some programs interview up to 80 applicants.
 

Methyldopa

Pharmacopoeia
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
May 13, 2004
305
3
Status
doctorlarry said:
I wonder if the data above applies to the Neurology match in particular. In other words, do I have an 85% chance of matching in my top 3 neurology programs? It would be nice to hear from those who matched into Neurology last year.

Also, sometimes I wonder how much an interview actually helps/hinders our standing when some programs interview up to 80 applicants.

From what I hear you more than likely will match in your top 4 choices. By more than likely, I mean a 100%.

Good luck to you! We find out in just about a month :D
 

notjvarma

Chief Wahoo
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
May 17, 2003
43
0
40
Columbus... OH?
Status
Medical Student
http://www.sfmatch.org/general/example.html

This page works through the match algorithm and shows you that students typically get their higher choices while programs do not. NRMP works the same way from what I could tell (they also have an example up, I think it's more complicated though).
 

ectopic_thought

Junior Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Jul 24, 2005
23
0
Status
Claymore said:
Ok, so as interview season starts to wrap up, I've found that there are probably a few programs that I'm particularly interested in, much moreso than some others. My question is, roughly what percentage of people match at say, one of their top 3 places? What percentage match below #5? Not sure if there is official info on this, but anecdotes are welcome also.
I've just had an epiphany. Or maybe I just have never given this thought. OF COURSE there are good percentages for matching in one's top 3, 5, 10, whatever choices...

The major wing-clipping takes place when programs decide whether or not to interview applicants.

I assume one only ranks places that one interviews at; so even though a pre-application "top 3 choices" may include very, very competitive places, by the time the season is over you're ranking places that are much more likely to accept you because after all, they asked you to visit and speak with them.

I think this post is as much talking to myself as it is a reply to the original question...
 

GopherBrain

MARK IT ZERO!!
Moderator Emeritus
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Oct 17, 2003
1,442
20
WFMC
Status
Attending Physician
Yeah, when I was interviewing for med school, the place I went bragged about how many of their grads got their #1 residency choice. It wasn't until I was a 3rd year I realized that this was because most of their grads chose to do primary care residencies in the midwest....
 
About the Ads