I've tried Clonidine and guanfacine. From experience with patients, it seemed to only work well as an augmentation agent though I'm sure there's cases here or there where it could've yielded some benefit as a primary treatment. Oddly, I've had patients who had a great reaction to only one of them and not the other.
I had one case where Clonidine stabilized someone who without it was screaming, yelling, threatening, and would disrobe and expose his unit.
He was IMHO misdiagnosed with bipolar disorder. Indeed, what he had seemed like bipolar disorder when observing his behavior. The two things that got me thinking this was not bipolar disorder was that when interviewed, his thought process was linear though highly irritable, and he has fetal alcohol syndrome.
After reviewing the literature on FAS, I wondered if this was merely ADHD to the worst degree I ever saw it. FAS could cause it, and his mother drank extremely large amounts of alcohol daily. I didn't want to try him on a stimulant because he was on a forensic facility and tried Clonidine first under this idea (I tried Zyprexa, Depakote, Lithium, Haldol, Risperdal, Abilify, Geodon, Thorazine....no success. Thorazine wouldn't even knock him out even when given in mega-doses such as a few hundred mg at a time, and he told me it only made him feel even more agitated).
In hindsight, was this ADHD to the worst extreme? I don't think so now even though the Clonidine worked. From my other ADHD patients, I've noticed Clonidine or guanfacine only seemed to augment to stimulants or Wellbutrin, but in and of itself it hardly did anything.