Coin toss for #1

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
deschutes

deschutes

Thing
Moderator Emeritus
Verified Member
Verified Expert
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2004
Messages
4,703
Reaction score
1
It's 18 days to the ROL deadline and I'm still flip-flopping between my choices for #1.

Similarities:
Both programs are located in cold cities of the same size and have the same number of PGY-1 positions being offered. Both alternate their AP/CP throughout each year. Both have up to 4 rotation sites.

Differences:

Program A
  • more structured
  • only 2 months of electives in total
  • free interhospital shuttle!
  • bigger name (at least on this forum)
  • only 100+ cases/year in the field I am thinking of entering, plus one rather eccentric and extremely academically-oriented overseer (I am honestly afraid I might piss said attending off quite by accident and screw my chances for a fellowship)
  • Somewhat smaller stipend and book fund
  • Chances of owning house/car at end of 4 years: close to 0%

Program B
  • 12 months of electives
  • 700+ cases per year in the field I am thinking of entering, and 3 clinically-oriented attendings
  • Larger stipend and book fund
  • More outdoorsy potential
  • Chances of owning house/car at end of 4 years: close to 100%

Halp! I've woken up every day this week thinking the other was going to be #1.

Heck, maybe I'll end up with my #7 and all this being deliberate ++ was for nothing.
Members don't see this ad.
 
Let me get this right, Program B offers better training (in terms of cases), better money, better focus on subspecialization (meaning you can do away rotations with electives), and a better lifestyle (own your home?)... and you still wondering what program? Okay go with Program A then :D
 
1. don't worry about pissing off attendings during your interviews. seriously, the place where i got the "ranked to match" phone call and letter, i got into a pretty heated argument over why i was pursuing AP only and not considering too heavily doing AP/CP. he yelled at me during that interview and told me that my way of thinking was "absolutely wrong." i almost shat my pants and left that interview crying. seriously, whatever happened at the interview happened AT the interview. that's it. if you went there, i doubt that attending would hold anything against you.

2. how important is it that you have a house/car where you go? if the academic caliber of the two programs are similar, then perhaps subtle lifestyle issues like this may sway your preference a bit.

3. i think the point about training in your desired fellowship field is very important. are you dead set on that field? or are you weighing other options?

4. 12 electives vs. 2 electives?!?!? wow! if you have varied interests then maybe go with the program with more electives. pathology is changing and it seems like more electives are good to get well-rounded exposure to various aspects of pathology.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Program A for sure - they have the interhospital shuttle!!!!

Seriously. Program B is screaming your name. Who cares if it is a "smaller name" on these forums.
 
cytoborg said:
Program A for sure - they have the interhospital shuttle!!!!

Seriously. Program B is screaming your name. Who cares if it is a "smaller name" on these forums.
Click to expand...

that's right! i agree with the man in the wheelchair.

seriously, the way you worded things, i think you REALLY REALLY want to go to program B.

and who cares what the forums say! never take what's said on here as gospel! i said that once, i say it again!
 
Keep in mind that these are PGY-1 salary figures and they all hover about 40k. Larger/smaller stipend is therefore relative.

I forgot to mention I felt the residents at Program A better knew what they were doing. The facilities at A are excellent and brand spanking new - the best I'd seen on my interview trail (again this is relative!)

When I go for B I feel I am choosing the city above the program - I don't know the program all that well, and I think it shows in my original post. Which is why in my heart of hearts I wonder if I don't really know if I will get along with the people at Program B, apart from the numbers and letters.

As for the interhospital shuttle ;) ... transport without a car is what many people (staff and residents) do at A - that is all I was trying to say.

[addendum]I didn't piss anyone off - I was a darling :p I simply noted that the potential to piss was there. The thing about this particular academic attending is that he is such a big name that a phonecall from him could quite likely get me anywhere.
 
Have you tried the fantasy technique? Ya know, the moment of opening the envelope, reading the name, how do you feel about it...

Program B just sounds like a better overall package. Better quality of life in terms of location, being able to own a house, and having activities you enjoy nearby. They are also stronger in the field you are interested in, which is HUGE. Facilities are nice, but not everything. Name is nice, but ultimately you need the connections to the fellowship/job you want.
 
There are TONS to do in either of these cities. Also, the shopping in both is stellar :D

by the way I added an addendum to the previous post re: connections.
 
The only thing I suggest is do not pick a program based on someone else's "rankings" or reputation. Go to the place where you think the training is most appropriate for you, and where you will enjoy living, because it will be your life for the next few years. Elective time and all that sounds important, but a lot of programs are similar. If there is something you really want to focus on, there will be opportunities. You can always do away rotations.
 
yaah said:
The only thing I suggest is do not pick a program based on someone else's "rankings" or reputation. Go to the place where you think the training is most appropriate for you, and where you will enjoy living, because it will be your life for the next few years. Elective time and all that sounds important, but a lot of programs are similar. If there is something you really want to focus on, there will be opportunities. You can always do away rotations.
Click to expand...
Absolutely!
:thumbup:
you better listen to yaah. he's wise beyond his years.
 
yaah said:
The only thing I suggest is do not pick a program based on someone else's "rankings" or reputation. Go to the place where you think the training is most appropriate for you, and where you will enjoy living, because it will be your life for the next few years.
Click to expand...
Thanks. But since that is where I am coming from, that helped not one jot :p

The only way rank or reputation comes in is that I went to program A and I finally figured out why people were nuts about it. Before my visit I wasn't even considering it all that heavily.
 
You sound like you're talking yourself into A. Maybe in your heart of hearts you'd rather go there? I urge you to use the Match Day visualization technique.
 
Earlier in the week, I was trying to talk myself out of A.

I don't know real estate prices well at all, but both these places are in the Midwest and neither are LA/NYC-type expensive.

I did the send-myself-an-email thing a few days ago. Didn't help. I'm honest-to-goodness split right down the middle. That's it. I'm doomed.

But thanks everyone for your help! I have one last consult left to make.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
deschutes said:
Earlier in the week, I was trying to talk myself out of A.

I don't know real estate prices well at all, but both these places are in the Midwest and neither are LA/NYC-type expensive.

I did the send-myself-an-email thing a few days ago. Didn't help. I'm honest-to-goodness split right down the middle. That's it. I'm doomed.

But thanks everyone for your help! I have one last consult left to make.
Click to expand...

good luck and godspeed.
 
Deschutes,

It seems to me like you want permission to go to Program B. You didn't give a very good argument for Program A, at all.

Questions:
~Where would you be happier?
~Which would give you the best quality of life?
~Which would further your career the most?
~If both had equal reputations, which would you choose?
~Do you feel like you SHOULD go to Program A?
~Do you feel like people might look down on you if you choose Program B?
~Which city/program has the cutest boys? (ok, you can skip that one)

Certify your rank order list with Program B as #1, then leave it for a couple days. If you feel unsettled, change it to Program A for a couple days and see how you feel.
 
Well?? What did you decide? Still strugging with the decision?
 
deschutes said:
Relax! It's just 12 days to Feb 23 ;)
Click to expand...

I can't relax til everyone's ROL is finalized and certified!
 
And WTF! Why the hell do we have to wait THAT long to get the frickin' results? A computer can do the match algorithm in seconds (ok maybe minutes).
 
AndyMilonakis said:
And WTF! Why the hell do we have to wait THAT long to get the frickin' results? A computer can do the match algorithm in seconds (ok maybe minutes).
Click to expand...

No kidding, and it's not like the match doesn't get messed up anyway.
 
3 weeks is mighty suspicious. the cynical side of me thinks there is some manipulation goin' on. PD's "trading" candidates after they are unhappy w/ the preliminary results (and of course us not knowing about it). ;)
 
scootad. said:
3 weeks is mighty suspicious. the cynical side of me thinks there is some manipulation goin' on. PD's "trading" candidates after they are unhappy w/ the preliminary results (and of course us not knowing about it). ;)
Click to expand...

If we're getting traded like baseball players, then we should have our own playing cards.
 
Apparently they run the match algorithm many times to ensure that the results are valid. The last thing they want is to release flawed match results, as utter chaos would ensue. Would be interesting to observe as an outsider, though. :smuggrin:
 
still, 3 weeks?? come on. how many times are they running the freakin' algorithm? i cant imagine running it 20 times would require more than a week.
 
elkchaser said:
Yaah, you mean like this: http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=175816
Click to expand...

Indeed. I heard about that and am still not sure how it happened. I can only imagine the chaos if that happened in the regular match. What would they do, rerun it? That wouldn't really be fair to people who were told they matched at a top choice, only to be told it wasn't valid because the "better candidates" lost out. Yikes.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Next unread thread

Similar threads

P
Cuts, coinsurance threaten laboratory services
Replies
1
Views
2K
pathresident2
P
Top