College major question - does it really not matter?

RyanJFA

New Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 20, 2010
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
NOTE: Accidentally posted this in Exam HQ due to a posting error. Can somebody please delete that? Thanks!

Hey,

First things first, I apologize for asking this question. I can see that it's been asked a few times before, although I'm still going to continue posting, as I'd also like a little information on my choice(s) of a major.

Anyway, I've heard from a number of people that "college major doesn't matter to medical schools, so long as you keep your GPA high". While this may be true to an extent, I have heard from other (reputable) sources that your major can have a good or bad effect on your chance of admission, depending on what it is. For example, I had initially been considering majoring in psychology, given the interest I've had in the field for such a long time. However, I was discouraged from taking this path by friends, who told me that psychology is typically taken by slackers, thus, my majoring in that could look bad on medical school applications.

So lately, I've been trying to decide between doing a major in Astrophysics (which I find to be compelling, I just don't know whether or not I'll be able to wrap my head around the advanced math) or doing a double-major combination of International Relations and Russian. I'm relatively confident that I'd be able to do well in those two areas, as I've always had a penchant for both politics and language. I'd probably enjoy that combination, too, while not having to worry about getting buried under anything other than the required math courses I'd have to take as a prospective medical student.

Now I have to ask - if I pursue the latter option, might it come back to haunt to me? I've seen several people on this forum state that they are majors in, or are going to major in subjects such as philosophy or political science. This gives me "hope", though I'd appreciate additional feedback from people who know more about the medical school process than myself. Honestly, I have no clue whether or not IR and RUS are common majors.

I guess it's also worth noting that I'm probably going to have to be a community college loser for a year, after which I'll be transferring to Michigan State University (I'd try for UChicago or somewhere similar, but I'm an ice dancer, and, given that male ice dancers are rare, I get extremely high-quality lessons for free in Detroit). I'm one of those *****s who had been in "gifted" and "advanced" classes since first or second grade, but ended up flunking a boatload of courses junior year due to lack of caring. I've since turned things around (all A's last trimester without trying, even though I only have a normal schedule. Still, I did perfectly fine on the AP tests last year, regardless of my grades in the classes themselves. I'm not worried about not being able to do college-level work). My ACT scores, while not extremely exceptional, were good enough to merit me a boatload of mail from prestigious universities, while most of my friends got stuck with exclusive invitations from ITT-Tech.

I'm planning to retake the ACT (took it in the midst of my junior year crash. Still got >99th percentile scores in English and Reading, but I know I could have done much better in math and science) later this year, so I can have something else to throw in when I submit my transfer application.

Don't know if any of that was relevant. It'd be nice if people could give me some feedback on my planned majors, as well as offer any study tips that work for them. I've always been the kid who passed without trying due to natural interest in some fields, but I know that isn't liable to cut it in college.

Anything helpful is appreciated.
 
I don't think psychology majors are slackers, and I don't think those who want to major in psychology are slackers 🙂 I think you've heard this before but major in something that you love and want to learn more about. You would be far better off going down this path and apply to medical school 👍 rather than majoring in something that will be ideal for medical school. Also distinguishing yourself by majoring in something unique or uncommon in medical school application is fine, but getting a high MCAT score, publishing your research in distinguished journals, etc. are way better to make yourself stand out 🙂
 
I certainly wasn't intending to major in something especially difficult sounding for the sake of getting into medical school. It's just, medicine (right now) is the only career path I find to be even the least bit interesting. I've been volunteering in the ER at the same place for a couple of years now, even though that hospital generally doesn't let people stay for much longer than the length of a semester.

A lot of the college kids I know are always going crazy with advice about majors, so that's why I'm asking. One of my friends talked for an hour straight about how I should do physiology, because the school I'm going to go to has a "really hard course" that "guarantees admission if you pass" or something.
 
Ok, let me help clear a few things.

1. A good GPA (>3.5) is CRUCIAL for having a good chance of getting in somewhere. No amount of difficult majors can make up for a bad GPA. You can major in astrophysics at Caltech and have a 2.0 and you will NOT get in anywhere. So choose a major that is interesting to you and will not kill your GPA.

2. MCATs are important and for the most part all schools will teach you the basics in physics, bio, chem, ochem, etc. Furthermore, you're going to have to self study anyway so your college choice doesn't matter in that sense. Speaking of college choice...

3. To some extent your college choice may/may not increase your chances of getting in but some colleges definitely can DECREASE your chances, University of Chicago being one of them (as an alum I would definitely suggest you steer clear of places like that unless you enjoy being immersed in "intellectualism" 24-7-365). What do I mean by this? Some colleges like research heavy schools may butter up your resume by having a lot of faculty and research opportunities. However some schools, UofC included, are renown GPA deflators and that's bad considering point #1 above.

4. Med school adcoms love UNIQUENESS. You should definitely maintain your ice dancing stuff as you continue in your path. Also continue shadowing/volunteering at a hospital.

5. People who's advice you should ignore and/or take with a grain of salt: your premed advisor and other idiot premeds who're just talking out of their ass. SDN info on preallo forum tends to be good if you're willing to sift through some muck.

Hope this helps.
 
I certainly wasn't intending to major in something especially difficult sounding for the sake of getting into medical school. It's just, medicine (right now) is the only career path I find to be even the least bit interesting. I've been volunteering in the ER at the same place for a couple of years now, even though that hospital generally doesn't let people stay for much longer than the length of a semester.

A lot of the college kids I know are always going crazy with advice about majors, so that's why I'm asking. One of my friends talked for an hour straight about how I should do physiology, because the school I'm going to go to has a "really hard course" that "guarantees admission if you pass" or something.

I think your friend is mistaken.

But yeah, almost everyone here is going to tell you the same thing: major in what you find most interesting. Don't suffer through years of some random thing or another because you think it looks good on paper even though you don't give a **** about it. And besides, if it's interesting, chances are you'll do better with it.

My class has people with degrees in everything from chemistry/biochemistry/biology to psychology to music, and just about everything in between. Surely there's a closeted underwater basketweaving major in there somewhere.

We're fortunate in that we don't need a hard science degree to pursue an MD/DO, much of which is based in hard sciences. You just need the prerequisites, like organic chemistry and all the rest. After that, it's up to you. You could argue that a hard science major would better prepare you for the MCAT, but lots of "soft science" people did just fine on that test. It's all about how you want to go about it.
 
No, it really doesn't matter. The only benefit might be you're more well-versed in the sciences, which may or may not help with the MCAT and the first year of medical school. I don't think those are good reasons to suffer through a science major if that you're not interested in.
 
Major in what you love to do. You won't have one of those semesters chocked full of hard classes that you resent taking if you take courses you enjoy. Personally, I enjoyed studying psychology, did my research in biopsychology, and ended up taking graduate courses as an undergraduate. Many MD/PhD programs found this to be an interesting specialization for research and did not look down on me for having this as one of my majors (also took a lot in philosophy and the natural sciences--no one I've met has even had close to that combination). Do what you enjoy doing, do it well, and have fun while you're doing it 🙂
 
i was looking at a thread of intended majors for pre-med students, but never once did i see anyone wanting to do linguistics... it's something i REALLY want to study. i'd like to study both languages themselves as well as the cognitive science involved in learning language, so there will be a good amount of science involved. do any of you know of someone who has majored in linguistics and gone to med school? i can't find anyone who has, but i am just trying to do what i'm passionate about...😍
 
stop asking the same question of "is ______ major okay?!?". it has been well established on these forums that it doesn't matter what you major in
 
any major requires effort to make >3.5 in for the most part, and medical schools know this. just taking gen ed courses and making consistent A's and B's requires a decent amount of effort. if by chance this isn't the case at your school and you don't have to work hard, your mcat will show this. worry less about your major and more about your grades and what you're learning; major in something that you will enjoy.
 
ok ok, i understand that it doesn't matter what you major in and that you should do what you like, but i was just asking if anyone is or knows someone who is majoring in linguistics and going to med school... i just don't want to feel like i'm the only one studying this!
 
ok ok, i understand that it doesn't matter what you major in and that you should do what you like, but i was just asking if anyone is or knows someone who is majoring in linguistics and going to med school... i just don't want to feel like i'm the only one studying this!

for your sake, the answer is "yes." i'm sure most adcoms have seen someone from every major at least once.
 
i was looking at a thread of intended majors for pre-med students, but never once did i see anyone wanting to do linguistics... it's something i REALLY want to study. i'd like to study both languages themselves as well as the cognitive science involved in learning language, so there will be a good amount of science involved. do any of you know of someone who has majored in linguistics and gone to med school? i can't find anyone who has, but i am just trying to do what i'm passionate about...😍

I personally don't, but I also enjoy linguistics and think it would have been cool as hell to major in it.

Also: doesn't matter if anyone else has. 👍
 
It ALL matters.
GPA matters
EC matters
College matters but to a certain extent
 
Speaking from my own personal experience, I haven't seen any advantage in being a biology major. If I could do it again I would probably have done pysch or even philospohy, since I generally enjoy both of them and hate Biology. I ended up working twice as hard for the same GPA, and can't imagine that my Gen Bio degree had any influence on my acceptance to med school.
 
I do know a few English/foreign language majors who are currently attending medical school. They're some of the students in our class who are able to read and analyze a lot of material (great skill for medical school) and, from my experience, some of the students with the highest verbal reasoning and critical writing MCAT scores in our class. I'm not sure that my class is typical of medical school classes, though... We tend to attract some of the more academic doctors and more older students who majored in humanities, did service work or research abroad...
 
It's true that major is basically irrelevant. There are some exceptions for super-tough study programs (e.g., aerospace engineering at MIT or something), but the GPA hit you'll take is never anywhere near the boost you'll get from having braved the storm. Do the easiest major you enjoy so you can pad your GPA.
 
Top