geezz...take it easy on the md2b. he/she seems to have some fair knowledge on the topic (even if a lot of it is hearsay...but then again so is most else on this board.
my .2:
agreed, most importantly, it depends on the individual...class rank, boards, extracurrics.
now in terms of training for gp, Buffalo is a better school both in clinic and didactic. patients seen and treated are aplenty.
i must say however that on my interview trails (omfs and ortho which were in the nyc and philly area), there were more columbia interviewees.. now that doesn't necessarily reflect on the school itself (there could've been more applicants, stronger applicants). maybe the best from buffalo didn't apply. but i did notice a higher proportion of students from columbia, michigan, mcgill, upenn. and harvard of course.
by the way, there was this girl in my dent school who did a bachelor's, and is also a speech therapist/pathologist (i think it only took 1 extra year after bachelors). she could basically choose where she wanted to go. i think in terms of planning on specializing, start something unique before dental school.