Columbia> weird! What's going on?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

AlwaysImproving

Full Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2008
Messages
308
Reaction score
1
So I applied to Columbia and never heard from them. On AADSAS, they say they never received DAT scores and I just got an email about not having paid the $75 (even though it was sent to them in certified mail and they cashed it lol). Anywho, since we can only call on Wednesdays, I have been calling them but I can't get any info at all from them.

This is really weird, this is the only school I didn't get an interview from. I want to hear something, even a rejection so that I know at least they looked at my application. I feel like something is weird here. I have been hearing other ppl had same problems with Columbia. If you are one of them, can you please share your story?
 
I just got the same email from them but I never sent my fee because I decided not to apply there after I sent everything else in.
 
i got that email but they cashed my check and I've already interviewed there...
 
Got the same e-mail, still no word from them.
 
So I applied to Columbia and never heard from them. On AADSAS, they say they never received DAT scores and I just got an email about not having paid the $75 (even though it was sent to them in certified mail and they cashed it lol). Anywho, since we can only call on Wednesdays, I have been calling them but I can't get any info at all from them.

This is really weird, this is the only school I didn't get an interview from. I want to hear something, even a rejection so that I know at least they looked at my application. I feel like something is weird here. I have been hearing other ppl had same problems with Columbia. If you are one of them, can you please share your story?

Yeah I am in the same boat they are the only school that I didn't hear anything from and I just got the email about not paying the fee when that's not the case cause I have records from online banking that show them cashing my check. I also would like to hear back from them.
 
So I applied to Columbia and never heard from them. On AADSAS, they say they never received DAT scores and I just got an email about not having paid the $75 (even though it was sent to them in certified mail and they cashed it lol). Anywho, since we can only call on Wednesdays, I have been calling them but I can't get any info at all from them.

This is really weird, this is the only school I didn't get an interview from. I want to hear something, even a rejection so that I know at least they looked at my application. I feel like something is weird here. I have been hearing other ppl had same problems with Columbia. If you are one of them, can you please share your story?

Omg I just got the same email😱( i paid the fee back in october) I called them 15 min ago and I was like HI I just got the email...? and she said oh the fee email and I was goin to say yes and boom my cell got disconnected🙁( Now is going on the vc machine and I left message
 
Hey! I think we may be going to UF together 🙂 Anywho, I am in a similar situation. I was a little surprised to not get an interview with them at all! I mean it's fine if they don't want me for whatever reason, but it is a little annoying not to hear a peep from them all cycle! Several months ago I e-mailed them about my application status, and all the lady who e-mailed me back said was "it is still under review". I just now received an e-mail saying I did not pay the application fee, but it was paid in August! In fact, my bank even shows me a convenient photocopy of the check showing it was definitely cashed as soon as they got it. If this was the reason I never heard anything, I'll be pretty annoyed! 😡
 
I received the email as well. It says in the email "If the fee has already been paid, please disregard this notice." They cashed my check back in October as well and I already interviewed. Just email Diana and try to call her again on Wednesday if you are worried about the fee not being processed.
 
I got the same email as well, but they cashed my check in July already.
 
Just received the message as well. My check was cashed back on August 12 or 13. I have heard absolutely nothing from them except for my AADSAS showing that I am under review/application complete. In my email it says that I should pay the overdue fee in order to avoid FURTHER delays on the review of my application. It makes me wonder whether or not they have even looked at my application or if it has just been sitting in some corner because they thought I never paid. With so many student files to deal with, I wonder how many applications they, or any school for that matter, have accidently misplaced or put in the wrong pile and by the time they realize it, it is too late.
This is been a rather bad cycle for me so far. I applied to West Virginia and nothing had been and still is not showing up on my AADSAS. So I called them around Christmas break and when I talked to someone in the office I was told that I had not had my DAT scores submitted to them! I immediately looked at my receipt and it turned out that I did. I called her back about 25 minutes later and she had told me that once she got off the phone she realized that for some reason the score, which I guess automatically updates onto her computer, hadn't uploaded on her machine all of this time. So there my app sat, not even looked at for over 3 months! I was about ready to pay another 25.00 to have it delivered (which I told her I was going to do) and she did not even take the time to call me back to let me know that she had found the scores.
This is my first time applying to dental schools and I guess that I did not want to feel as though I was bugging the schools by calling. One lesson that I have learned is you cannot leave your fate rest in what can sometimes be inept office staff. To all of you that are planning on applying, be sure to stay in constant contact with the schools you are applying to so that nothing like this happens. Like I mentioned above, who knows how many of the thousands of applications that schools process get shuffled into the wrong stack, or scores that do not get uploaded, or letters/checks that do not get received. I am sure you all know this but I obviously could have used a reminder lol.
 
ha, i got the email today too... strange thing is that they cashed it, i have interviewed, and was accepted in december...
 
Yea i got the same email and my check was cashed months ago i guess i will call to find out whats going on?!?!
 
I got the same email. Applied in August and so far this is the only communication I have received from them. I'd be curious whether anyone was able to actually speak with them today and find out what this is all about!...
 
HAHAHAHA!!!

I got the same e-mail ..... AND I'VE ALREADY BEEN ACCEPTED!!!!!!!!

W/E i'm sure it's a computer problem. They had a computer problem back in September when they were sending out their first round of interviews.... i'm sure it's nothing to freak out about
 
I just got that too! Maybe someone accidentally hit the wrong button on a mass email or something? What is going on...😕
 
I talked to Diana this afternoon and she was extremely blunt and made it seem like I made some mistake. Extremely, and I mean extremely, short with me. I asked her if my file was being reviewed or if it was held up because of this payment problem..she said it is being looked at and "that is absolutely all I can tell you" lol
 
I got the email too. My check was cashed already. Is this some kind of an error since the emails went to those who got accepted as well? Now I'm wondering if they ever went through my application as I haven't heard anything back from them.😕
 
i got the email, replied saying they cashed my check back in july 08. makes me wonder if they even looked at my application........shady:laugh:
 
Prob a means of getting additional funding before mass rejections are sent out
 
just curious..would this email be any indication for the pre-interviewers if they are still interested in any of us...is there any one who applied to columbia and hasnt received the mail?
 
Just received the message as well. My check was cashed back on August 12 or 13. I have heard absolutely nothing from them except for my AADSAS showing that I am under review/application complete. In my email it says that I should pay the overdue fee in order to avoid FURTHER delays on the review of my application. It makes me wonder whether or not they have even looked at my application or if it has just been sitting in some corner because they thought I never paid. With so many student files to deal with, I wonder how many applications they, or any school for that matter, have accidently misplaced or put in the wrong pile and by the time they realize it, it is too late.
This is been a rather bad cycle for me so far. I applied to West Virginia and nothing had been and still is not showing up on my AADSAS. So I called them around Christmas break and when I talked to someone in the office I was told that I had not had my DAT scores submitted to them! I immediately looked at my receipt and it turned out that I did. I called her back about 25 minutes later and she had told me that once she got off the phone she realized that for some reason the score, which I guess automatically updates onto her computer, hadn't uploaded on her machine all of this time. So there my app sat, not even looked at for over 3 months! I was about ready to pay another 25.00 to have it delivered (which I told her I was going to do) and she did not even take the time to call me back to let me know that she had found the scores.
This is my first time applying to dental schools and I guess that I did not want to feel as though I was bugging the schools by calling. One lesson that I have learned is you cannot leave your fate rest in what can sometimes be inept office staff. To all of you that are planning on applying, be sure to stay in constant contact with the schools you are applying to so that nothing like this happens. Like I mentioned above, who knows how many of the thousands of applications that schools process get shuffled into the wrong stack, or scores that do not get uploaded, or letters/checks that do not get received. I am sure you all know this but I obviously could have used a reminder lol.

Btw, I am really sorry about what happened to you, I hope everything turns out for the best.
 
Last edited:
The email says
"If the fee has already been paid, please disregard this notice." By checking with them, you are basically telling them that you can not follow directions.

stfu. Can we not inquire about why we are receiving these emails at the end of february when applications and fees were submitted in the summer?
 
o yea, for those of you who didn't get an interview invite yet, i heard next friday is their last interview for the cycle.
 
i paid my fee way back in the summer and then got the same email today. i was like whaaat??? it's almost the end of february!!!

this kind of looks a little bit like fraud....
 
So I applied to Columbia and never heard from them. On AADSAS, they say they never received DAT scores and I just got an email about not having paid the $75 (even though it was sent to them in certified mail and they cashed it lol). Anywho, since we can only call on Wednesdays, I have been calling them but I can't get any info at all from them.

This is really weird, this is the only school I didn't get an interview from. I want to hear something, even a rejection so that I know at least they looked at my application. I feel like something is weird here. I have been hearing other ppl had same problems with Columbia. If you are one of them, can you please share your story?
same email, no interview, cashed check back in august, withdrew a few weeks ago anyway

it's very wierd
 
I talked to Diana this afternoon and she was extremely blunt and made it seem like I made some mistake. Extremely, and I mean extremely, short with me. I asked her if my file was being reviewed or if it was held up because of this payment problem..she said it is being looked at and "that is absolutely all I can tell you" lol


She has always been like that, and when people complained it over the sdn regarding her attitude last year, she became kind for a few weeks. After that, back to normal.

I don't know why a prestigious school like Columbia can't afford a better admission staff.
 
So I applied to Columbia and never heard from them. On AADSAS, they say they never received DAT scores and I just got an email about not having paid the $75 (even though it was sent to them in certified mail and they cashed it lol). Anywho, since we can only call on Wednesdays, I have been calling them but I can't get any info at all from them.

This is really weird, this is the only school I didn't get an interview from. I want to hear something, even a rejection so that I know at least they looked at my application. I feel like something is weird here. I have been hearing other ppl had same problems with Columbia. If you are one of them, can you please share your story?

I had the same exact story! I also received an email today stating that they haven't received the supplemental payment, even though it was cashed eons ago. I also tried to get a hold of them on Wednesdays, but nobody ever answered.
 
Applied to 10.
Invitation from 9.
Going to Harvard.
Single school that didn't invite me- Columbia University
and now asking for money which was cashed back in august.
I got one thing to tell them- :wtf::bullcrap:
 
She has always been like that, and when people complained it over the sdn regarding her attitude last year, she became kind for a few weeks. After that, back to normal.

I don't know why a prestigious school like Columbia can't afford a better admission staff.
Totally agree with you on this one. I think we should start emailing Dr McManus or Dr Davis to let them know about this. She's just a secretary, not a dean of admission. And when you talk to the dean of admission, he is very kind and very respect us. We are working hard students, not lazy stupid students. Please give some respects.
 
Totally agree with you on this one. I think we should start emailing Dr McManus or Dr Davis to let them know about this. She's just a secretary, not a dean of admission. And when you talk to the dean of admission, he is very kind and very respect us. We are working hard students, not lazy stupid students. Please give some respects.
good idea. email will be sent today
 
good idea. email will be sent today


Let us know what response you guys are getting back from them.
I think that Dr. Davis and Dr. McManus are great folks, and the lady from the financial aid office is awesome too. The only problem with Columbia is the secretary of the admissions.
 
Dang I'm soooo glad there's a thread about this I completely flipped out last night haha. Columbia's been up at my top choice for a while but I resigned a long time ago the fact that I'm not getting an interview. However -- they didn't even cash my check (that I sent them in JUNE) and I'm positive I addressed it correctly...

What does everyone's AADSAS say? Mine's been at "received / under review" for a long time now. Do you think the fact that my check was never cashed means that my app was never looked at??!! God...
 
i feel sorry for ppl with awesome stats who maybe only applied to columbia because they had awesome stats and then got this email from them. seriouslly...that is so messed up. the application process is SO expensive and for them to lose stuff, its just wrong. what if a person only applied to one school that lost their application? then they are out of sorts for an entire year, have lost a years worth of income from having a practice (if you think about the future), have the added stress of having to apply again and strengthen application and pay for the app process all over again, etc.
 
I just ignored the email but I guess I wasn't the only one who got the email... I'm just wondering why it's taking them more than 2 months to withdraw my application!?!?!?!?!?
 
I never had any problems with Ms. Lugo. She was really nice and helpful whenever I would call.
 
I never had any problems with Ms. Lugo. She was really nice and helpful whenever I would call.
are u Diana Lugo? or someone who knew her. If this thread keeps going for a month, Im sure she will learn her lession.
 
I never had any problems with Ms. Lugo. She was really nice and helpful whenever I would call.


Sure that could be true in your case. I doubt even a very horrible secretary gets complaints from 100% of the applicants.
 
I got the same email as everyone else did, but I found out that my check hasn't been cashed out yet. I sent the check in late May so I assumed that it was cashed out. Should I even bother resending the check now? I mean, I haven't heard anything from them yet and I believe there wouldn't be more interview invite since their last interview will be held this Friday. My friend also told me that Columbia sends out rejection letters in early March. Any thoughts?
 
I got the same email as everyone else did, but I found out that my check hasn't been cashed out yet. I sent the check in late May so I assumed that it was cashed out. Should I even bother resending the check now? I mean, I haven't heard anything from them yet and I believe there wouldn't be more interview invite since their last interview will be held this Friday. My friend also told me that Columbia sends out rejection letters in early March. Any thoughts?
That makes me have a big concern here. Is it possible that because they didnt cash our checks, or somehow lost our checks without telling us to replace the check and we dont get the interview invitation. I got interview with columbia, but it's irritating me when they cash the check and didnt send an email like other schools saying that your check is recieved.
 
That makes me have a big concern here. Is it possible that because they didnt cash our checks, or somehow lost our checks without telling us to replace the check and we dont get the interview invitation. I got interview with columbia, but it's irritating me when they cash the check and didnt send an email like other schools saying that your check is recieved.
Is that secretary's jobs to send out that email? I mean because I try to be polite and nice with all admission staffs, so I really didnt say anything to them when they did somethings wrong or rude to me. But when I get accepted somewhere, I will call or email them to let them know that. Columnia's suck.
 
So I applied to Columbia and never heard from them. On AADSAS, they say they never received DAT scores and I just got an email about not having paid the $75 (even though it was sent to them in certified mail and they cashed it lol). Anywho, since we can only call on Wednesdays, I have been calling them but I can't get any info at all from them.

This is really weird, this is the only school I didn't get an interview from. I want to hear something, even a rejection so that I know at least they looked at my application. I feel like something is weird here. I have been hearing other ppl had same problems with Columbia. If you are one of them, can you please share your story?

I dont know about the whole situation with this one. I mean I had a friend last year who recevied similar e-mail from one of the school he applied to. They called him and aked him for the deposit. He sent it, and got a rejection letter in the mail couple days later it. After the school cashed his check. So yes, I am not gonna waste money and send in my check to Columbia. I mean come on, I am an out of state student who's got a 3.34 and a 20 on a DAT. Why would Columbia want me??
 
I dont know about the whole situation with this one. I mean I had a friend last year who recevied similar e-mail from one of the school he applied to. They called him and aked him for the deposit. He sent it, and got a rejection letter in the mail couple days later it. After the school cashed his check. So yes, I am not gonna waste money and send in my check to Columbia. I mean come on, I am an out of state student who's got a 3.34 and a 20 on a DAT. Why would Columbia want me??

I am not saying you will not get into Columbia, because no one knows. But i have similar DAT as yours but have not heard from them yet. So if you have any other acceptance and Columbia isnt your top choice then just screw it.
 
heyy, look who was right. ''In my previous email it clearly states that, “if the fee has been paid please disregard the request. “ Although the email was sent to you, it was addressed to the entire applicant pool but intended for those who have not submitted their fee."

I am kind of shocked at that correction email.

For the record: I did not call or email

But normally when you get a bill it will say "if you already paid disregard this"... it generally means, if you sent in the check and they are still processing it or whatever... not if you sent it in June. So I see where confusion could happen.
 
heyy, look who was right. ''In my previous email it clearly states that, “if the fee has been paid please disregard the request. “ Although the email was sent to you, it was addressed to the entire applicant pool but intended for those who have not submitted their fee."
Man, this is rediculous. when u apply for a career that maybe change your life from now on, you wanna make sure everything is going right. Even I sent my check and they cashed it, I still wanna call to make sure that they had it. You never know when and where they make a mistake. If this is just another bills I have to pay, then it's not a problem. But it is my LIFE. However, the second email Lugo sent out sounded like she was very pissed. All the highlights and underlines emphasize her invoice in angry.

She just a secretary and happen to be one of the admission staffs. she is nobody.
 
Top