it took me forever to decide between the two!!! here is what i concluded
1) i looked at laptop reviews for 2010, lenovo x200 was ALWAYS rated #1
2) lenovo tablets have been around for a lot longer, i guess they bought it from IBM a while ago (somethign like that lol im not a comp person) but i feel like they have had longer time to "grow" with their design
3) yes, the HP reviews are good. however, i did read the 1 star reviiews to see why....one comment that i kind of agreed with said "do not buy because they still need more time out for reviews" they said it was too new and still needed some upgrades and time to see how they run long term.
4) i wanted the most durable, stable tablet available, especially because i will be biking and i just dont want something that will be super fragile. from what i read, the lenovo always had the best ratings and compliments about durability
5) i know more people who have the x200 and they all love it. not one person said they wouldnt recommend it. i know no one with the HP tablet
6) i wonder how much of the HP tablet is for "show" the outside is very "fashionable" and it was hard to tell if they tried to play the looks up more so people would think it is cool. at least i know that the x200 doesnt need to look showy for people to like it. IMO the x200 is ugly hahaha but at least i know that it is a good computer without looks overshadowing the true quality
7) this was after i bought it, but i just received my extra pen i ordered. this, i can actually compare between the two because I saw the HP tablet in person. the HP pen is just a solid piece of plastic. it is light and doesnt feel like a real pen. The lenovo pen has a bit of weight to it, not super heavy, but it feels like a real pen. it also have a separate tip, like a real pen. and they gave me extra tips. There is also an eraser on the back. i LOVE it. i know it sounds stupid since i only got the pen lol but i really think it is at least worth the cost. i dont knoow how much the HP pens are, but i assume they still like to make profit on them. id be so made if i spent a lot on a stupid piece of plastic.
hopefully my opinions arent too biased, i really had no clue which one i wanted and this is just how i made my decision. i know the HP did get good ratings so im sure it would still be fine. i just figured, if im going to spend a lot of money, i want to know what i am getting and know that it will last for 4 years without problems (hopefully)
edit: here is the site i used to read a TON of reviews and also they rank the tablets each month.
http://www.tabletpcreview.com/default.asp?newsID=1374&news=Top+Tablet+PC+Models