Computer/Laptop for Residency + Fellowships

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

ThisIsTheWhey

New Member
2+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2020
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Current M4 heading to residency next year (I hope) and I need some advice - my laptop just died on me and I am getting a new one. Here are my options below:
1. UHD 15.6 inch touch screen with 16 GB RAM 1TB SSD + 32 GB Optane
2. HD 17.3 inch touch screen with 16 GB RAM 512 GB SSD
3. Switch to a desktop and forget about the laptop

I guess my ultimate question is if 512 GB SSD is enough for a 3 year residency + years of fellowship. I like bigger screen as 99.9% of my studying is on my computer and I am not sure if a 15.6 inch screen would be too small for the long run.

Thanks!

Members don't see this ad.
 
Get a solid laptop with a docking station and 1-2 additional monitors if you have the room for it. Then, you have the best of both worlds. External hard drives can be a good supplement at a fairly cheap price if you feel as though you're running out of storage space.
 
Few notes:
1. HD (I assume 1080p) is the highest you reasonable need to go for a monitor under 20 inches.
2. Get some sort of cloud storage and 512 GB should be plenty for everything else.
3. @Real McCoy had a great idea. Multiple monitors are great for Netflix... I mean productivity. Having a portable laptop that you can expand into more of a desktop feel at home is a great option. Having a larger monitor at homes means you can have an easier to transport 15.6" laptop and still have enough screen real estate.
4. Make sure whatever laptop you get has USB C support. That will do wonders, especially if you want to make an ready docking station at home.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
It's interesting to me that you have #3 as an option. If the portability and mobility of a laptop is not a significant factor for you, then a desktop would easily be the way to go from a hardware and customizability standpoint. Desktop hardware is significantly more powerful (read: faster) than laptops for cheaper. Personally, I almost exclusively use my iPad and desktop and only use my laptop when travelling and do not have access to my desktop. Building my first desktop as an undergrad seriously altered my workflow because of how nice the experience is sitting at my workstation. So, first, you need to make the distinction between a laptop and a desktop. I do have quite a bit of knowledge regarding hardware and processes if you want to PM me questions.

Regarding the storage, only you can make the distinction. For most people, 512 GB is way more than enough. However, if you download a lot of media or games or other files that take up a lot of space then it may not be. If you get a desktop, it will always be very simple to add more storage. If you get a laptop then upgrades and modularity will heavily depend on the model and it becomes a more important consideration prior to the purchase.
 
Get a solid laptop with a docking station and 1-2 additional monitors if you have the room for it. Then, you have the best of both worlds. External hard drives can be a good supplement at a fairly cheap price if you feel as though you're running out of storage space.

+1

Just an MS1 but I got a MBP and 34" 4k external to use for studying, and easily one of the best decisions I made for school. When I'm studying at home I always have 4 large windows open (usually lecture slides, anki new card panel, anki browse panel, and a safari window/or textbook PDF for looking stuff up). If I'm feeling spicy I can even split the screen into 6 windows that are all still easily legible. Then if I ever need to bring the laptop to campus I just pop off the single USB-C which connects it to the docking hub. Would happily recommend a similar setup for anyone in school/residency.
 
Regardless what you choose, wait for Black Friday.
Be careful tho, Black Friday computers tend to be made from inferior materials/metals.

Ive has both a 17.3” and 15.5” screen, and the 17.3 was massively heavy to carry around. I hated it and didn’t think the large screen was worth it.
 
I'm a computer fanatic and have a couple recommendations for models that I actually own.

I love macOS, so a 16" MacBook Pro is a solid recommendation. It's extremely heavy (read: not portable) and pricey, but the build quality is solid, Apple has corrected their horrible keyboard switch that they were using for the last several years, and being able to do things like text, Facetime, etc. is nice. Apple results in some very divisive opinions, but if you're a fan of macOS and have other Apple devices, the interoperability of their devices is excellent. I've got a gaming desktop and I still prefer macOS for "actual work" because I prefer my macOS workflow. Until I built my gaming desktop, I used my current MBP to drive 3 external monitors which made working a pleasure, and going somewhere else to work was as simple as undocking. Assuming you take care of your device and spec it appropriately, a MacBook really will last years. I bought a 15" MBP at the start of MS3 in 2013 that I still have and is still usable as a backup device.

If you're looking for a Windows alternative, check out the Lenovo Yoga C940. It's a 2-in-1 which may or may not be useful to you, but the build construction is solid, the trackpad is reasonable if not a bit small, battery life is excellent, and the 2-in-1 can be an occasionally useful feature, depending on what you use your computer for and how willing you are to try out the 2-in-1 form factor. The Dell XPS 15 is another good choice: solid build quality, excellent display, and huge trackpad. Both of these models are a bit expensive, but IMO you get what you pay for, and I would be leery of buying the cheapest thing possible on Amazon as random manufacturers that you've never heard of and/or budget models are likely to cut corners somewhere. I would make sure to pay attention to the trackpad unless you're planning on carrying a mouse with you everywhere - a huge trackpad that performs well can be a complete game changer when working on-the-go. The LG Gram is a nice, lightweight alternative available in up to a 17" display. I don't own one myself but all the reviews for it that I've seen have been positive.

512GB would likely be enough storage if all you're using it for is work-related stuff (e.g., not installing games at 20+ GB each... though with a laptop I assume you won't be doing any hardcore gaming on your machine). Cloud storage is cheap enough at this point that you could easily pay for a buttload of storage on Google, Box, Dropbox, etc. to solve your issues there. I'd recommend trying to get 32GB of RAM - it adds a bit to the price but will make sure your machine continues to perform for some time. Make sure you get a powerful CPU for the same reason. I'm a big screen guy myself, but just keep in mind that the bigger the screen the less portable it becomes, both from a weight perspective but also in terms of fitting the damn thing in a bag.

Godspeed.
 
Last edited:
Top