Step I Crazy score estimates...check this out

Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

sebsvenmdc

Full Member
15+ Year Member
So, an instructor for a review program (think DIT) says that:
you need to be scoring >72% on UW to score >230 and >75% on Kaplan to score >230.

I think this is kind of an underestimate. I'm definitely not trying to be overconfident or unrealistic or overly hopeful, but from what I've seen on this forum, people scoring in the 60s on UW, routinely make scores in the 230s! I think UW is much harder than Kaplan...more so than a 3% higher average. It was kind of scary to hear these statements because it's not congruent with the statistics on many websites.

Thoughts?
 
So, an instructor for a review program (think DIT) says that:
you need to be scoring >72% on UW to score >230 and >75% on Kaplan to score >230.

I think this is kind of an underestimate. I'm definitely not trying to be overconfident or unrealistic or overly hopeful, but from what I've seen on this forum, people scoring in the 60s on UW, routinely make scores in the 230s! I think UW is much harder than Kaplan...more so than a 3% higher average. It was kind of scary to hear these statements because it's not congruent with the statistics on many websites.

Thoughts?

Did S/he mean cumulative score, or most recent scores?
 
Did S/he mean cumulative score, or most recent scores?

He phrased it as: "If you're wanting to score above 230, you need to be scoring at least 72% on UW."

I would assume that that means current scoring. Geez, a 72% average is amazing if you started off low. I started UW in January when I was clueless and getting in the 50s. My average is close to 70 now, but it's taken a ton of time to get up.
 
Ugh, I'm going to stop thinking about scores and trying to predict stuff. His comments just kind of rattled me a bit because I was under the impression that 70% on UW was more like 240ish.

If anyone wants direct access to his quote, it's within the first few minutes of the Day 5, Lecture 1 of the DIT. Obviously, only kids taking the DIT online will be able to hear this.
 
If it makes you guys feel any better, I was getting mid-60's on UWorld and low-70's on Kaplan towards the end of my studies and I scored 235/98 on the real thing.

Try not to get caught up with the percentages. It'll just add to your anxiety and you really want to walk into the exam with as positive/optimistic a mindset as possible.

Keep your focus on your studies. Ignore the rest.
 
If it makes you guys feel any better, I was getting mid-60's on UWorld and low-70's on Kaplan towards the end of my studies and I scored 235/98 on the real thing.

Try not to get caught up with the percentages. It'll just add to your anxiety and you really want to walk into the exam with as positive/optimistic a mindset as possible.

Keep your focus on your studies. Ignore the rest.

Thanks for the advice! I'll apply it!
 
What they usually mean is:

IF YOU TAKE THE WHOLE QBank in TIMED MODE AND SCORE A 72%, then you're at the 230 level.

If you do it in a haphazard or tutor mode fashion, then the 62% is not a true reflection of what you learned by going through all of your mistakes.
 
What they usually mean is:

IF YOU TAKE THE WHOLE QBank in TIMED MODE AND SCORE A 72%, then you're at the 230 level.

If you do it in a haphazard or tutor mode fashion, then the 62% is not a true reflection of what you learned by going through all of your mistakes.

how would they be comfortable predicting that? There's no way on god's green earth someone has done the entire uworld without checking answers.
 
If it makes you guys feel any better, I was getting mid-60's on UWorld and low-70's on Kaplan towards the end of my studies and I scored 235/98 on the real thing.

Try not to get caught up with the percentages. It'll just add to your anxiety and you really want to walk into the exam with as positive/optimistic a mindset as possible.

Keep your focus on your studies. Ignore the rest.

Do you remember what your average was though? And did you do any NBMEs that correlate with what you got on your actual exam?

I've been doing 48Q, mixed, timed blocks ever day and my best score so far is 29 points higher than where I started (so my cumulative average is obv lower than what I'm getting now). I've still only done about a quarter of USMLE world though, so I'm hoping that the score continues to improve. I'm guessing that the greatest increases won't come until I'm closer to being done going through everything (~in a little over 2 weeks). When have you all seen the largest increases in your scores? I have yet to crack open a physio, path or pharm book - I've only done the basics (biochem, molec/cell, micro, immuno, anatom/embryo, etc) so far...
 
how would they be comfortable predicting that? There's no way on god's green earth someone has done the entire uworld without checking answers.

I should have been clearer. I mean to say that UW used over several months and use it as a study guide, then it is not a true % of your knowledge.

If you go through it in blocks and then review answers after (without repeating used questions) then that is a true predictor.
 
I should have been clearer. I mean to say that UW used over several months and use it as a study guide, then it is not a true % of your knowledge.

If you go through it in blocks and then review answers after (without repeating used questions) then that is a true predictor.

Yeah, I've always done random questions in a timed mode. Although, recently I've switched from blocks of 25 to 48 questions. Still, I think 72% on UW does not equate with a 230. Most of the low 70s I've seen correspond to 240+.
 
Yeah, I've always done random questions in a timed mode. Although, recently I've switched from blocks of 25 to 48 questions. Still, I think 72% on UW does not equate with a 230. Most of the low 70s I've seen correspond to 240+.

Brian Jenkins is wrong imo.
 
Also, I think Brian Jenkins is wrong about the numbers. He could be right though.

I would like to voice that I like the Doctors in Training program, and I think he does a great job teaching FA. So, I'm definitely not out to bash him or DIT...in fact, I highly recommend him and the program.
 
I'm pretty sure he just meant that towards the end you should be scoring around those ranges on randomly generated tests. To get those percentages as an average you'd have to know a ton already right from the first day which is pretty unlikely.
 
Pardon my ignorance, but the DIT instructor also said that getting approximately 55% of your questions correct on Step correlates to a 185. Is this true?

I'm not bashing him or the course because I think it's excellent, but I've just never heard that approximation before.
 
Pardon my ignorance, but the DIT instructor also said that getting approximately 55% of your questions correct on Step correlates to a 185. Is this true?

I'm not bashing him or the course because I think it's excellent, but I've just never heard that approximation before.

I'm not sure. I think 70% on UW is pretty solid though...not just as an average, but for sets of 48 questions even at the end. UW is much harder than Kaplan in my opinion. Much more than 3%. I would say, more like 7-10%. My reasoning is...just look at the averages. The UW average is routinely in the 50s...I've never seen it in the 60s. Kaplan's can be in the 60s quite often. I doubt there are differences in abilities of UW and Kaplan users to account for this.
 
I'm not sure. I think 70% on UW is pretty solid though...not just as an average, but for sets of 48 questions even at the end. UW is much harder than Kaplan in my opinion. Much more than 3%. I would say, more like 7-10%. My reasoning is...just look at the averages. The UW average is routinely in the 50s...I've never seen it in the 60s. Kaplan's can be in the 60s quite often. I doubt there are differences in abilities of UW and Kaplan users to account for this.
Oh yeah, I definitely think it's closer to 7-10%!

Since I'm so tired perhaps I misunderstood him, but I thought he said in addition to all of the Kaplan and UW estimations, that getting 55% correct on the actual Step 1 test = ~185.
 
Pardon my ignorance, but the DIT instructor also said that getting approximately 55% of your questions correct on Step correlates to a 185. Is this true?

I'm not bashing him or the course because I think it's excellent, but I've just never heard that approximation before.

Uhhh... I hope not. Because that's about what I'm getting on random timed. I think that when people tell you these things they really need to tell you how most people are using UWorld-- are most students using it on tutor mode right after they have just studied a subject? In that case, then you should be getting far more than 50% of the questions correct. If you're doing UWorld always on random timed and including all the subjects that you haven't even covered, then you're score is going to be a lot lower.

It just seems that the best idea is to use UWorld as a learning tool and to use the NBME's as an assessment as to where you stand.
 
Oh yeah, I definitely think it's closer to 7-10%!

Since I'm so tired perhaps I misunderstood him, but I thought he said in addition to all of the Kaplan and UW estimations, that getting 55% correct on the actual Step 1 test = ~185.

Geesh, now I'm thinking that the difference is more like 10%. The last two sets of questions that I have done:

UW: two 48q test-taker average (not my scores) = 56% and 51%
Kaplan: two 25q test-taker average (not my scores) = 65% and 65%

Seriously, Kaplan's average is like 10% higher than UW.
 
Geesh, now I'm thinking that the difference is more like 10%. The last two sets of questions that I have done:

UW: two 48q test-taker average (not my scores) = 56% and 51%
Kaplan: two 25q test-taker average (not my scores) = 65% and 65%

Seriously, Kaplan's average is like 10% higher than UW.

I've had two sets on UW with test-taker averages of 48% and 49%
 
That clinical review calculator gives a ridiculous estimate of my possible score..over the last 350qs or so on random I have been hitting about 74% which they say is a 262..haha sign me up for that.
I'm wondering if anyone else is in the same boat as me, I've been doing solidly on the questions but I don't feel like I have any mastery over the material aside from some Goljan and what I retained through the coursework. If I flip to a random page in First Aid chances are I can't regurgitate it. I'm more ruling out what answers can't be right than definitively knowing things. Does this kind of thing translate to the real deal or is it relying on a crapshoot?
 
That clinical review calculator gives a ridiculous estimate of my possible score..over the last 350qs or so on random I have been hitting about 74% which they say is a 262..haha sign me up for that.
I'm wondering if anyone else is in the same boat as me, I've been doing solidly on the questions but I don't feel like I have any mastery over the material aside from some Goljan and what I retained through the coursework. If I flip to a random page in First Aid chances are I can't regurgitate it. I'm more ruling out what answers can't be right than definitively knowing things. Does this kind of thing translate to the real deal or is it relying on a crapshoot?

I'm in the same boat in that I feel the same way. I'm averaging lower though when I do blocks of random questions (60-65% usually). If I have more pharm then I do considerably worse...I find these much harder to rule out answers if there is no principle other than rote memorization involved 🙁

Fortunately, if it's anything but memorization, ruling out can be just as important as ruling in (especially for distractors). I can't imagine it would be that much different on the real thing either.

What I do is after all my annotating and whatnot, I skim through the questions I did for the day and try to recall the few concepts leading to the answer and compare my answers to the summary. If I can't recall anything, I then mark it. I plan to review all these marked questions once I finish.

But to get back to what you were talking about, I think the other choices, aka "distractors," are items that would be high on a differential dx, and if you can answer why others are wrong as well as support the answer you choose, I think that's stronger than just knowing the right answer.