current dental students- whats your opinion: UoP vs UCSF?!

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

meant2be10

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
May 29, 2010
Messages
56
Reaction score
0
For any current/recent students at either UCSF or UoP dental: I just got into both of these schools and am having a really hard time deciding. I am a California resident, and I know they are both great schools with different pros/cons.

If any of you have any inside help that would be useful in deciding I would really appreciate it!
 
I'm done with dental school but if I were you I would go to UOP simply due to the fact that it's 3 years. Saving a year is invaluable, not to mention I hear tons of great things about UOP.
 
UoP in my opinion. The difference in the financial aspect between these two schools is rapidly collapsing, and obviously you graduate a year earlier through UoP. Clinically, at UCSF you're referring lots of patients to grad prosth, endo, perio, etc... Everything you see at UoP you get to treat with your own two hands, which gives you a great experience with complex prosth, molar endo, perio surgery, the list goes on.

Also, this may be personal preference but I'd rather live in Pacific Heights over the Sunset.
 
It's getting kinda annoying the procedures we can't do.

1) Grad endo takes most the molar endo cases (with exception that the 4th year Endo clerks gets to do molars). Molar endo's aren't hard, and curved canals are easy to get a file in without ledging. A great many of us have done them successfully on extracted teeth. And UoP gets to do them, so molars aren't exactly untouchable.

2) I'd kinda like to be able to do flap surgery. It's not exactly hard, but it's not something we're allowed to do. UoP gets to do them.

3) We can't get Invisalign training, because Ortho feels only orthodontists should do braces. Nevermind that even orthodontists have no control over results with Invisalign, so their entire argument is without merit.

4) Grad Pros can take whatever case they want from me. I don't want them. I'm trying to convince them to take my current dentures patient from me, but they say no. 🙂

The biggest perk we have over UoP is that we're not burned out nearly as much. We have a life outside school, and the D1's at UoP are now cutting sim lab to hang with us every once in a while.

The cases we can't take aren't exactly hard. We can learn them ourselves, but it'd be nice to be able to do them.

And I'd rather live in Pac Heights too. The Sunset's a snooze.
 
Thanks for the feedback!

Armorshell: you truly think that getting out earlier really makes close to a "wash" of the tuition differences? I will be 100% financial aid, so I'm so worried about taking out all the loans. But at the same time I feel I may be happier at UoP because of the supporting environment etc. (and being in Pac Heights 🙂 ).

Also, I want to specialize, I know it's possible to specialize from UoP but from what you've seen, do you think I will have to sacrifice all social life to do that? Since the program is so much more intense.

UCSF2012: are there advantages to UCSF like being on more of a medical campus with med/pharm students etc? are there social activities set up with students outside of dental? also, how hard is it to get the letters of commadation? i'm concerned with p/f grades plus p/f boards there is going to be so little to be evaluated by for specialty programs, other than GRE I suppose. I've taken the GRE and I feel it really doesn't test "how smart you are".
 
Thanks for the feedback!

Armorshell: you truly think that getting out earlier really makes close to a "wash" of the tuition differences? I will be 100% financial aid, so I'm so worried about taking out all the loans. But at the same time I feel I may be happier at UoP because of the supporting environment etc. (and being in Pac Heights 🙂 ).

Also, I want to specialize, I know it's possible to specialize from UoP but from what you've seen, do you think I will have to sacrifice all social life to do that? Since the program is so much more intense.

I never said it would make it a wash. I remember when I was a pre-dent, the difference between UoP and UCSF in total cost of attendance was less than $50,000, and many people felt that it was financially worth taking on that additional loan burden to finish a year earlier. I don't precisely know what the difference in COA is now but try to figure out if an extra year is worth the difference to you.

Working toward specialization did not significantly affect my social life in dental school, and several of my classmates managed to specialize who had significant time commitments to their social lives during all 3 years of dental school.
 
Thanks for the feedback!

Armorshell: you truly think that getting out earlier really makes close to a "wash" of the tuition differences? I will be 100% financial aid, so I'm so worried about taking out all the loans. But at the same time I feel I may be happier at UoP because of the supporting environment etc. (and being in Pac Heights 🙂 ).

Also, I want to specialize, I know it's possible to specialize from UoP but from what you've seen, do you think I will have to sacrifice all social life to do that? Since the program is so much more intense.

UCSF2012: are there advantages to UCSF like being on more of a medical campus with med/pharm students etc? are there social activities set up with students outside of dental? also, how hard is it to get the letters of commadation? i'm concerned with p/f grades plus p/f boards there is going to be so little to be evaluated by for specialty programs, other than GRE I suppose. I've taken the GRE and I feel it really doesn't test "how smart you are".

Every once in a while, we mingle with other programs. The school added a new interprofessional class where students just discuss implications of certain clinical scenarios, analyzing how it may impact other health professions. (or something like that. They added it after my class, so I havn't done it.) And a great many of us hang out with other programs like physical therapy, nursing, med, pharm, etc. We go to their parties, and they occasionally come to ours. But it's your responsibility to seek out the opportunities. On the flipside, a great many of us also only hang out with dental.

Letters of commendation don't mean anything. Residencies don't rely on them, because they still can't guage students from each other. These letters are the single cause of stress within the program and should be eliminated. Getting them affords no perks, but because they exist, some students in the class are gungho.

Don't worry about p/f and residencies. A great many residencies aren't hard to get into, because they never really cared about board scores to begin with. Endo, perio, pros, pedo, and select omfs programs never really, really cared about super high board scores to begin with. It's more about whether you want to go into that field. For example, it's virtually unianimous that we hate pros. We don't care how well prosthodontists do, we're not becoming one ourselves.

UCSF and UoP are polar opposites in terms of [required] time commitment. UoP being the most consuming in the country, and UCSF being somewhere near the bottom, if not at the very bottom. There comes a point where we just have too much free time on our hands. Sometimes, our schedule just works out such that we have a 4 day weekend. At least, it feels like it.
 
Thanks for all the input!
UCSF2012- I'll be 27 when I start school and am not really in a point in my life where I care about have 4 day weekends or summers off, I'd rather just work hard and finish sooner...As far as the financial aspect is concerned would you worry about the extra debt from UoP? If you had the choice would you still pick UCSF?
 
Thanks for all the input!
UCSF2012- I'll be 27 when I start school and am not really in a point in my life where I care about have 4 day weekends or summers off, I'd rather just work hard and finish sooner...As far as the financial aspect is concerned would you worry about the extra debt from UoP? If you had the choice would you still pick UCSF?

You say that now, but just wait till dental school starts...trust me
 
You say that now, but just wait till dental school starts...trust me

Dental school isn't time consuming enough to warrant needing regular 4 day weekends, even at UoP.

Also remember, despite UoP having a ridiculously busy schedule, something like 97% of the class graduates on time every year and UoP has one of the most financially generous alumni associations out there.

Show me another place where you can get beat down that hard and still love it enough to want to give back financially and I'll shave my head and eat all the hair.
 
Thanks for all the input!
UCSF2012- I'll be 27 when I start school and am not really in a point in my life where I care about have 4 day weekends or summers off, I'd rather just work hard and finish sooner...As far as the financial aspect is concerned would you worry about the extra debt from UoP? If you had the choice would you still pick UCSF?

I was 27 when I started dental school. By that time, I realized there was more to life than school, and UCSF allowed me to have a life outside of school. That's not to say that I neglected schoolwork. There are moments when things are rough, rushed, and intense (mostly in first year); but mostly we have time to wind down and enjoy the process. Many people push aside their youth in hopes that maybe they'll enjoy their life later. I think this is a fantasy. People who push things til later have a hard time stopping pushing things back. In the last years, I've had time to have friends outside the field, go to socials, have hobbies, and just enjoy myself.

My UCSF acceptance continues to be one of the very best things in my life. We have balance in our lives. I challenge you to find another school in America where their students confirm that statement year after year. (Of course, we usually have one student per year come on SDN and explode)

And 4 day weekends are rare. I exaggerated. They exist every once in a while, but usually that includes a national holiday like MLK day as the 3rd day. We have a good bit of half days off thou.

It really depends on what your values are. It's easy to tell what I personally value, but I have no clue what you guys want. UoP presents a different set of perks.
 
Last edited:
did you/do you go to UoP?

No. I go to MWU. I have many friends at both schools, and have personally been to visit both schools. I think they are both great schools, but I think UOP is better place to go. Outside of the obvious 3 years vs 4 years, I thought that the faculty, staff, and students at UOP all seemed happier to be there as a whole. I hated the hospital environment of UCSF and I think they tend to be a little blow hard about their research. Again, UCSF is great school and my opinion is just a reflection of my personal experiences at both schools and through conversations with friends from both schools.
 
No. I go to MWU. I have many friends at both schools, and have personally been to visit both schools. I think they are both great schools, but I think UOP is better place to go. Outside of the obvious 3 years vs 4 years, I thought that the faculty, staff, and students at UOP all seemed happier to be there as a whole. I hated the hospital environment of UCSF and I think they tend to be a little blow hard about their research. Again, UCSF is great school and my opinion is just a reflection of my personal experiences at both schools and through conversations with friends from both schools.

And what about this school gave you the impression that we're blow hard about our research? In the last 2.5 years, I was never pressured to do research of any sort. Not one mention of it.

Come to our campus with a certain mindset, and you'll perceive that as a reality, regardless of whether it's true.

UCSF hospital is several buildings from UCSF dental. CPMC medical center is across the street from UoP dental. I think you came to both schools with preconceived notions and that discolored your experience. I don't think you have an accurate representation of either school.
 
Last edited:
No. I go to MWU. I have many friends at both schools, and have personally been to visit both schools. I think they are both great schools, but I think UOP is better place to go. Outside of the obvious 3 years vs 4 years, I thought that the faculty, staff, and students at UOP all seemed happier to be there as a whole. I hated the hospital environment of UCSF and I think they tend to be a little blow hard about their research. Again, UCSF is great school and my opinion is just a reflection of my personal experiences at both schools and through conversations with friends from both schools.

Thats weird I am attending UCSF this year and I know someone very well that is a first year at UOP and I got the complete opposite feeling. I would definitely would not want to be at UOP. Everything in one building, no real library, no gym. It was a great area but for how often you would get to hang out in that area it is not worth it.
 
Thats weird I am attending UCSF this year and I know someone very well that is a first year at UOP and I got the complete opposite feeling. I would definitely would not want to be at UOP. Everything in one building, no real library, no gym. It was a great area but for how often you would get to hang out in that area it is not worth it.
A lot of dental schools are in one building. No "real" library, no gym? Those are more important than a year of your life?
 
A lot of dental schools are in one building. No "real" library, no gym? Those are more important than a year of your life?


How about your piece of mind? We are one of the least consuming schools in the US.

A year in your life is nothing.
 
A lot of dental schools are in one building. No "real" library, no gym? Those are more important than a year of your life?
Well let's see one more year of school and be much more stressed out and worried about that next quiz and test everyday just so that I can practice one year earlier or maintain a balance and get out a year later? Well if god allows me to practice for 30 or so years 1 year extra in school is nothing in the long run.
If I were older with a family then I might consider that extra year advantage.
Dental school is hard but I am actually enjoying my time here and am very stoked to be at UCSF
 
UoP does have a llibrary, it's right across the street. It's equally as real as UCSFs... As far as gyms, there's a YMCA a 10 minute walk from the front door of UoP and it's like $20 a month or something.

Also, Pacific Heights is great and I don't know what you mean by "How often you get to hang out there." My classmates and I hung out in Pac heights all the time.
 
My UCSF acceptance continues to be one of the very best things in my life. We have balance in our lives. I challenge you to find another school in America where their students confirm that statement year after year. (Of course, we usually have one student per year come on SDN and explode)

Oh yea?
 
UoP does have a llibrary, it's right across the street. It's equally as real as UCSFs...

I certainly hope your library is real. If you had a fake library, it'd be...

...actually, it'd be kinda cool to have a fake library.
 
It's getting kinda annoying the procedures we can't do.

1) Grad endo takes most the molar endo cases (with exception that the 4th year Endo clerks gets to do molars). Molar endo's aren't hard, and curved canals are easy to get a file in without ledging. A great many of us have done them successfully on extracted teeth. And UoP gets to do them, so molars aren't exactly untouchable.

2) I'd kinda like to be able to do flap surgery. It's not exactly hard, but it's not something we're allowed to do. UoP gets to do them.

3) We can't get Invisalign training, because Ortho feels only orthodontists should do braces. Nevermind that even orthodontists have no control over results with Invisalign, so their entire argument is without merit.

4) Grad Pros can take whatever case they want from me. I don't want them. I'm trying to convince them to take my current dentures patient from me, but they say no. 🙂

The biggest perk we have over UoP is that we're not burned out nearly as much. We have a life outside school, and the D1's at UoP are now cutting sim lab to hang with us every once in a while.

The cases we can't take aren't exactly hard. We can learn them ourselves, but it'd be nice to be able to do them.

And I'd rather live in Pac Heights too. The Sunset's a snooze.


Wow! After reading this, I'm not sure if I want to go UCSF anymore. I got accepted to UIC and UCSF and UCSF is my first choice. It sucks to see that. 🙁
 
It's getting kinda annoying the procedures we can't do.

1) Grad endo takes most the molar endo cases (with exception that the 4th year Endo clerks gets to do molars). Molar endo's aren't hard, and curved canals are easy to get a file in without ledging. A great many of us have done them successfully on extracted teeth. And UoP gets to do them, so molars aren't exactly untouchable.

2) I'd kinda like to be able to do flap surgery. It's not exactly hard, but it's not something we're allowed to do. UoP gets to do them.

3) We can't get Invisalign training, because Ortho feels only orthodontists should do braces. Nevermind that even orthodontists have no control over results with Invisalign, so their entire argument is without merit.

4) Grad Pros can take whatever case they want from me. I don't want them. I'm trying to convince them to take my current dentures patient from me, but they say no. 🙂

The biggest perk we have over UoP is that we're not burned out nearly as much. We have a life outside school, and the D1's at UoP are now cutting sim lab to hang with us every once in a while.

The cases we can't take aren't exactly hard. We can learn them ourselves, but it'd be nice to be able to do them.

And I'd rather live in Pac Heights too. The Sunset's a snooze.


Wow! After reading this, I'm not sure if I want to go UCSF anymore. I got accepted to UIC and UCSF and UCSF is my first choice. It sucks to see that. 🙁 Anything else we should know?
 
The financial issues are no laughing matter for the UC system either. You know it's bad when you're at an OMFS residency meeting and you're told by the chair of the program to be wary of UCSF because they have serious financial issues and it's not clear what the result will be...
 
seriously this is such bullcrap...the UC system is now allowing the MASSIVE DROVES of illegals to pay in-state...this is so unfair to all of us who are here legally and whose parents did things the right way and actually paid taxes...does anyone know whether UOP gives any scholarships...i would love to go to UOP but ill go to UCSF if its cheaper...i cant afford UOP
 
seriously this is such bullcrap...the UC system is now allowing the MASSIVE DROVES of illegals to pay in-state...this is so unfair to all of us who are here legally and whose parents did things the right way and actually paid taxes...does anyone know whether UOP gives any scholarships...i would love to go to UOP but ill go to UCSF if its cheaper...i cant afford UOP

I know, it's completely ridiculous. They give illegal immigrants (whose parents do not pay the ridiculously high CA tax which supports the UC system) in-state tution and continue to increase tuition prices by 8% each year for those of us who actually come from families that pay into this system.

Yes, UoP does have scholarships, although I do not know how hard it is to get them or what basis they are given on. As far as I know, I did not get a UoP scholarship. I did get a UCSF scholarship which will essentially make the upcoming tuition increases a wash.

I'm really worried about all the UC budget cuts and tuition increases, although coming out with $330k in debt is equally as scary...
 
seriously this is such bullcrap...the UC system is now allowing the MASSIVE DROVES of illegals to pay in-state...this is so unfair to all of us who are here legally and whose parents did things the right way and actually paid taxes...does anyone know whether UOP gives any scholarships...i would love to go to UOP but ill go to UCSF if its cheaper...i cant afford UOP


If that is accurate, that seems pretty unfair to me. Just add it to the list of reasons why the "DREAM ACT" will never pass!
 
Could a UCSF D3, D4, or recent graduate reflect on their experiences in the clinic and their exposure to various different procedures? I am very interested in attending UCSF but I am worried that with all of the post graduate specialties offered, there may be a great amount of referring out instead of having the opportunity to learn those procedures. Also, what is your opinion on attending UCSF for general dentistry without entering a specialty program afterwards?


Thanks for your feedback.
 
UCSF! More to offer than just becoming a GP as fast as possible (research powerhouse). It's much more student-friendly as well.
 
Amazing thread.

Do current students/recent alumni believe anything has changed?

My biggest concerns are:

UCSF:
-will budget cuts affect anything?
-minor: no molar endos, flap surgery, invisalign certification (as mentioned above)
-minor: it rains all the time

UOP:
-Grades. I know the graduation rate for 3 years is high, but will it be a challenge just to get a 3.0? Is everyone graduating with a 2.0? I get all I need to do is pass, but I would be embarrassed with that. Also I personally know someone that's been held back by the UOP dental system so this stuff happens.
 
Also for those that are unable to graduate from UOP in 3 years: is this because they failed one test, one class, or several classes? As in if I fail a test, will they let me retake it to stay on track?
 
Top