I see where your coming from with AA/URM preference but your analogy is weak. The NBA requires a set of "genetic gifts" coupled with ALOT of hard work. The reason URM are sought after isnt because they're genetically lacking intelligence (as your analogy might suggest) it's because they, in many cases, are not given the same educational opportunities. Even still, I agree. Grad school is too late to start leveling the playing field.
I think it's out of everyone's speculation to definitely say intelligence is not genetically related. I feel that it really is genetic gift as well, coupled with a lot of hard work like you say.
I already expressed myself in terms of the opportunities. Yes, URM's may not have same educational opportunity, I already acknowledged that, but same thing, a child from Asian family will not likely have parents who support him of becoming an NBA star, nor have parents who may play balls with them when they are young. So there you go, lack of opportunities there as well. Development of these motor functions while you are young is crucial in athletics as you already know probably.
I think it's wrong to assume that URM's always have little opportunities. Not all non-URM's are well off. And not all URM's are poor. Why give unfair advantages to well off URM's and disadvantages to not well off others?
Do you think Vietnamese nail salons, Korean laundromats, Chinese shops owners are rich? No. They aren't well off, but they are working harder and trying harder to increase their business than just giving up and work at low wage retail store which requires no thinking or opportunities, and crying later that they can't afford college for their kids. Come on. Why didn't you try harder to become successful?
It's just all comes from laziness. Really. Lack of English proficiency is present in Asian Americans also. But they work hard to get over that.
You can't just give disadvantage to ORMs because they have been successful after putting in so much effort, when the URMs may be where they are because they aren't putting in as much effort.
America babies their students more than any other country with scholarships and financial aid. If you have will, there's a way. Everyone out of dental school will have a huge debt, if they are URM or not.
Okay, sorry, last post. I'm done, sorry I will not post again on the thread!