deleted for privacy

[rodneyzwm]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

deleted for privacy

 

[Princeton Medical Student]

As long as you own it, this shouldn’t be a big deal.

 

[SpoiledMilk]

Individually isolated, each incident is not to concerning. In totality, I see a 3 year continuous pattern of transgressions that speaks to immaturity. I can see someone on an adcom making the argument that we have other high metrics applicants who have managed to keep their noses clean while in college, or even those with less stellar metrics who have never gotten in trouble, and that you have not yet shown that you can stay out of trouble. The concern would be whether the faculty can trust you to stay out of trouble as a medstudent at their school.

Therefore, the adcom would want to see that you have grown up and broken from the pattern of misbehavior. This can be shown through taking 1 or 2 gap years where you find a job and keep a job without getting fired for example. Promising on the app questions or interview questions that you can and will stay in out of trouble just won't cut it.

 

[rodneyzwm]

Individually isolated, each incident is not to concerning. In totality, I see a 3 year continuous pattern of transgressions that speaks to immaturity. I can see someone on an adcom making the argument that we have other high metrics applicants who have managed to keep their noses clean while in college, or even those with less stellar metrics who have never gotten in trouble, and that you have not yet shown that you can stay out of trouble. The concern would be whether the faculty can trust you to stay out of trouble as a medstudent at their school.

Therefore, the adcom would want to see that you have grown up and broken from the pattern of misbehavior. This can be shown through taking 1 or 2 gap years where you find a job and keep a job without getting fired for example. Promising on the app questions or interview questions that you can and will stay in out of trouble just won't cut it.

I have been employed in a clinical job as a CNA for about a year now, and this will be 1.5 years by time of application. My manager and I are on great terms and so would a reference letter from them be good to address the concern you brought up?

 

[SpoiledMilk]

Yes, the more LORs that speaks to your character, responsibility, and reliability the better. If you can, have those writers stress these points. What prevents you from getting an offer won't be your metrics, but unanswered concerns about your maturity...

 

[LizzyM]

A letter from your manager would not be necessary, particularly if you are still in school. A bunch of "character references" are not necessary helpful from the adcom point of view.

You will be required to sign a FERPA release of your records so this stuff will be "out". Own it and move on. Schools are likely to take it into account but also note that such experiences can contribute to growth.

 

[rodneyzwm]

A letter from your manager would not be necessary, particularly if you are still in school. A bunch of "character references" are not necessary helpful from the adcom point of view.

You will be required to sign a FERPA release of your records so this stuff will be "out". Own it and move on. Schools are likely to take it into account but also note that such experiences can contribute to growth.

So report both of the notification letters as IAs and then the formal warnings as well? I am comfortable explaining my growth from these situations but saw elsewhere that you dont recommend dragging on about an alcohol IA and its effect on yourself-- should I be writing a little more to address a "continued pattern of transgressions" as DV-T states?

thank you all for your input. Also, is this quantity of IAs basically a slammed door shut for most t20s?

 

[SpoiledMilk]

Lizzy's da bomb.

As an aside. I have personally noticed that students are harder on other students. The only school I didn't get an offer from was one that I had a 4th year interviewer. 😂

 

[voxveritatisetlucis]

I’m somewhat surprised by the responses here. I feel like 4 recent conduct violations would be a red flag for most admissions committees. Couple it with the fact that one involves a covid violation (pretty important for healthcare workers to follow guidelines related to infectious disease) and it probably requires some more time to show sustained maturity. I’m not saying your app will be DOA, but I think that the conduct violations are a higher hurdle than some are suggesting.

Keep in mind, that at most schools a group of 10+ will vote/rank you. If even 2 or 3 members of that group are particularly sensitive to covid violations (quite possible or even likely in this climate), it could prevent an A.

By all means apply, just apply very broadly and work from day 1 of submitting to prepare for a possible reapp

 

[rodneyzwm]

I’m somewhat surprised by the responses here. I feel like 4 recent conduct violations would be a red flag for most admissions committees. Couple it with the fact that one involves a covid violation (pretty important for healthcare workers to follow guidelines related to infectious disease) and it probably requires some more time to show sustained maturity. I’m not saying your app will be DOA, but I think that the conduct violations are a higher hurdle than some are suggesting.

Keep in mind, that at most schools a group of 10+ will vote/rank you. If even 2 or 3 members of that group are particularly sensitive to covid violations (quite possible or even likely in this climate), it could prevent an A.

By all means apply, just apply very broadly and work from day 1 of submitting to prepare for a possible reapp

thank you-- this is a gloomy outlook but if this will be the case then i should be prepared.

 

[Goro]

I am a current senior applying for 2023 EY. I have four things on file with the conduct office at my institution, and the conduct office has told me that these four things are "not considered reportable offenses" and would only be released with FERPA authorization. The four IAs are all non-academic and detailed below

frosh yr:
fall 2018- noise complaint in freshman dorms leading to letter of notification
spring 2019- formal warning issued after me and two friends were found doing shots after midnight in the freshman dorms. we hid the bottle in the ceiling and it dropped out when the RA walked in, leading us to be written up. along with a formal warning had to do an alcohol mindfulness module

soph yr:
fall 2019: RA did a room inspection and found empty bottles in our sophomore dorm-- the RA acknowledged that all of us probably werent drinking, and gave a letter of notification (one step below formal warning)

junior yr:
spring 2021: missed a covid test and our school had a policy of 3x weekly testing at the time. received a formal warning.

my question is whether or not 4 IAs, although each single one could be minor, in combination will effectively sink my application. or give off an impression that I cannot stay out of trouble. Im pretty disheartened because the conduct office had ensured me as an underclassman at time of the incident that 3/4 of these warnings were "nothing permanent" and that the letters of notification were more for their internal bookkeeping--but these are all on some sort of internal record that I unearthed as I started the app process now.

of note: it is my intention to report what is necessary on the amcas and take responsibility for whatever actions I put down. but I am confused and am not sure whether letters of notification count as IAs, or whether the school telling me directly that these are not reportable offenses means I should not disclose on amcas. Im applying with 52x MCAT and 3.9x GPA with solid ECs and LORs. obviously, this conduct record changes things a lot. I would like to know if I should redefine my school list to brace for broad rejection, or more grimly, scrap medical applications altogether. please advise

My my, some one certainly didn't learn their lessons.

At my school, you might very well get an interview, but I foresee a LONG discussion about whether to admit or waitlist. And as to the latter, how far down it would be.

The problem you're facing is that you're competing with tons of applicants who don't have four IAs.

Just for clarification, when did these IAs occur in your academic career? FR, SO, etc?

 

[rodneyzwm]

My my, some one certainly didn't learn their lessons.

At my school, you might very well get an interview, but I foresee a LONG discussion about whether to admit or waitlist. And as to the latter, how far down it would be.

The problem you're facing is that you're competing with tons of applicants who don't have four IAs.

Just for clarification, when did these IAs occur in your academic career? FR, SO, etc?

the conduct IAs were frosh and sophomore year, and I have since cooled down and had nothing related to alcohol since then.

the covid testing IA was junior spring-- I got tested twice instead of three times that week and this caused a warning of noncompliance.

I know at this point that the quantity of IAs will negatively affect me in the cycle. im just not sure by how much, and if I should be having a conversation with family about potentially getting universally rejected.

 

[LizzyM]

Freshman year:
Noise complaint
Under-age drinking, caught when hidden bottle falls from its hiding place above a ceiling tile (frankly, this is hilarious and will lift the mood of the committee)

Sophomore year
Warning from RA for empty (booze) bottles in dorm room.

Junior year
warning for missing one of 3 Covid tests required each week (that's a lot of appointments -- about 45 tests over a semester)

I really don't see this as an impediment to interviews, even at T20s as long as the rest of the application is up to snuff.

 

[voxveritatisetlucis]

thank you-- this is a gloomy outlook but if this will be the case then i should be prepared.

Disclaimer, I’m not an adcom member so take my opinion with a grain of salt. LizzyM and goro will give advice that is based on what they have seen in practice.

I would however advise that you keep an eye out on your drinking. Perhaps just give it up completely. Alcohol can cause problems throughout a medical career (patient safety, licensing, etc.)

 

[gyngyn]

So report both of the notification letters as IAs and then the formal warnings as well?

Yes, you need to report them all:
Institutional Action: Medical schools need to know if you were ever the recipient of any institutional action resulting from unacceptable academic performance or a conduct violation, even if such action did not interrupt your enrollment, require you to withdraw, or does not appear on your official transcripts due to institutional policy or personal petition.

Sections 1-3 of the AMCAS® Application: Your Background Information

Guide for sections 1-3 of the AAMC's American Medical College Application Service® (AMCAS®) in which applicants will provide their background information.

students-residents.aamc.org

 

[jhmmd]

Freshman year:
Noise complaint
Under-age drinking, caught when hidden bottle falls from its hiding place above a ceiling tile (frankly, this is hilarious and will lift the mood of the committee)

Sophomore year
Warning from RA for empty (booze) bottles in dorm room.

Junior year
warning for missing one of 3 Covid tests required each week (that's a lot of appointments -- about 45 tests over a semester)

I really don't see this as an impediment to interviews, even at T20s as long as the rest of the application is up to snuff.

Empty bottles of booze...hmmm...RA was probably mad that she wasn't invited to the party!