Try to get more clinical experience. I am surprised you got 280 hours of just ortho shadowing. Could any of this be counted as clinical experience or was it all observing/following the surgeon?
Applicants often make the mistake of thinking that applying to more schools increases their chances. It does not. Usually they are adding schools that would not consider their app or the secondary essay quality drops even with pre-writing.
You are a FL resident, that is all that matters. Attending a masters program in the state is good too. The NY ties are strong, the NJ ones are not.
I suggest:
All FL schools
All 4 SUNYs
Hofstra
Rochester
Einstein
NYU
Mount Sinai
Dartmouth
UVA
Case Western
Ohio State
Cincinnati
Emory
Northwestern
University of Chicago
Vermont
Jefferson
Tufts
University of Iowa
Wake
WUSTL
Saint Louis
Hackensack
Vanderbilt
Colorado