I figure this should generate some discussion
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-dumping23mar23,0,6340897.story?coll=la-home-headlines
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-dumping23mar23,0,6340897.story?coll=la-home-headlines
ERMudPhud said:I figure this should generate some discussion
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-dumping23mar23,0,6340897.story?coll=la-home-headlines
GeneralVeers said:King got in big trouble for allegedly "dumping" our indigent patients back on skid row.
The actual fact, is that the patients are given cab vouchers and can call a taxi for almost anywhere they want to go.
Many of the homeless shelters for L.A. are near downtown AKA "skid row". Coincidentally that's where all the crack dealers and prostitutes hang out, which is why our patients ask to be taken there.
I'm a doctor, and I have a responsibility to treat the MEDICAL complaints of my patient. I'm not a social worker, and I'm not a soup kitchen worker. I'm not going to give you free food, shelter, or clothes unless you have a medical necessity that requires admission to the hospital.
Side of the politicians? It is allways beneficial for them and their next campaigns to pick an issue and then legislate something that they can then spin as a solution. In this case since the homeless were in the hospitals care and then discharged to the street it is easy for the politicians to blame the hospitals.nocallaochicas said:I guess this is a bit of a bump...but I don't think that is much of a problem given it also works as a post pad:
I am hoping someone who can articulately (without too much idignation or emotion) argue the other side of this will post. That is, above is the view from the hospital, but I am interested in the side of the politicians. Thank you, no more callao chicas
colforbinMD said:Side of the politicians? It is allways beneficial for them and their next campaigns to pick an issue and then legislate something that they can then spin as a solution. In this case since the homeless were in the hospitals care and then discharged to the street it is easy for the politicians to blame the hospitals.
nocallaochicas said:do the politicians offer suggestions? alternatives?
GeneralVeers said:It's gotten insane here in L.A. In that article they mention that the Sheriff's office has set up cameras outside missions to prevent "dumping". The hospitals continually get chastised for this practice, but I have never heard anyone make any suggestion as to what we should do differently. The inner city hospitals in L.A. are inundated with homeless people. Probably 30-40% of my patients in an average shift are homeless. If I had to do "discharge planning" on all of them, I'd only see 3-4 people per shift, which would reduce the quality of care for the others who go unseen.
Most of our indigent are crack-addicted, non-compliant, and belligerent. Where should we send them? They use crack, get in fights, and get kicked out of shelter after shelter. We can't keep them in the hospital, as we never have any beds for sick patients, must less social admissions.
Most of the hospitals give out taxi vouchers, and the patients choose where they want to go. Most of our patients will complain about anything if questioned. If you ask them who sent them to the homeless shelter, of course they will blame the hospital if there is a perceived benefit to doing so.
Very frustrating situation, and the L.A. Times has done nothing but further destabilize the situation.
Apollyon said:In all honesty, where are you from? Are you American? Have you ever paid ANY attention to anything political in the US - ever?
Ok, OK. Obviously, little is expected or can be expected from politicians. And by asking I was not so much looking for someone to ID a great political leader among us, but rather just wondering if anyone was offering other options...anyone including SDNers or, yes, politicians.
But thanks for the brief, erudite, but pedantic and egostistic/pretentious review of the recent history of American's disillusionment with politicans.
nocallaochicas said:But thanks for the brief, erudite, but pedantic and egostistic/pretentious review of the recent history of American's disillusionment with politicans.
NinerNiner999 said:We do not and will not ever truthfully know where our discharged homeless population takes the buses and taxis we give them for free. All we can do is continually discharge our patients based on good faith that they will go where they say they are going. If someone is discharged to "home" and ends up in a back alley buying heroin, that cannot be our responsibility.
NinerNiner999 said:We do not and will not ever truthfully know where our discharged homeless population takes the buses and taxis we give them for free. All we can do is continually discharge our patients based on good faith that they will go where they say they are going. If someone is discharged to "home" and ends up in a back alley buying heroin, that cannot be our responsibility.
GeneralVeers said:Wrong. The nanny-state and quasi-communistic society of LA County says that we should feed, clothe, shelter, and pay everyone from cradle to grave, regardless of their drug addictions, immigration status, criminal behavior, or lack of ability to even accept help when given.
basementbeastie said:niner ---> heroin...alleys...baltimore....COME ON YOU SURELY JEST!!!
Sessamoid said:p.s. I wrote this after two Sierra Nevadas on an almost empty stomach.
docB said:You guys just aren't trying unorthodox solutions. Just last night I was confronted with a homeless guy who wanted to room in for a few days. So I said to him "Young man, there's no need to feel down."
I said, "Young man, pick yourself off the ground."
I said, "Young man, 'cause you're in a new town
There's no need to be unhappy."
"Young man, there's a place you can go."
I said, "Young man, when you're short on your dough.
You can stay there, and I'm sure you will find
Many ways to have a good time."
"It's fun to stay at the Y-M-C-A.
It's fun to stay at the Y-M-C-A."
"They have everything for you men to enjoy,
You can hang out with all the boys."
"It's fun to stay at the Y-M-C-A.
It's fun to stay at the Y-M-C-A."
"You can get yourself cleaned, you can have a good meal,
You can do whatever you feel."
And if not the YMCA then it sounds like Kaiser will put you up indefinitely right now.
Sessamoid said:I work at a Kaiser ER in LA currently (not for much longer thankfully). We're really under the microscope on this issue now. It takes practically an act of God to discharge a homeless patient now, regardless of how bogus the complaint is. We've got them clogging up hall and patient beds that paying customers need.
beyond all hope said:I address all of the medical problems of patients, self-inflicted or not. I must admit I don't spend as much time on the CHFer in HTN emergency from snorting coke, or an alcoholic with an UGIB as I do with a less-sick patient who didn't actually cause their own disease.
I do not usually address the social situation of a patient unless it involves access to necessary medical care (oxygen, followup appts, etc) or danger (abuse, etc). I can't fix their homelessness, drug addiction, etc. If they don't have a PMD I give them the number for free health care. If they are on something I recommend AA or NA.
That isn't to say I don't want to help. I am unable to help. Occasionally I can get SW involved, but most of the patients who need help don't have the mental resources or the ambition to follow through.
If they actually look like they're going to try to help themselves, I go whole hog. That includes social admissions, calling primaries and specialists to make their appointments, etc.
Be nice, be polite, do what you can...discharge. Next patient.
la gringa said:what's even worse if when you have an attending who thinks he/she can solve all of those problems... of course i'm talking about a medicine ward attending (yay prelim year, uhhhhh). lotsa pain there.
la gringa said:what's even worse if when you have an attending who thinks he/she can solve all of those problems... of course i'm talking about a medicine ward attending (yay prelim year, uhhhhh). lotsa pain there.
Panda Bear said:Yeah. I wince when I hear my 28-year-old third year resident who went straight from the bosom of her family to college to medical school to Duke offering lifestyle advice to some hoary old drug addict who has been shooting heroin since the late sixties, has had more partners than Amway, and was admitted for PCP pneumonia, cocaine-induced chest pain, and looks twice his stated age.
As if he's going to slap his head, exclaim "Eureka!" and sheepishly apologize for the hash he's made of his life.
Why patronize the guy?
Panda Bear said:The disappointment of many of our patients when they are discharged is palapable. I believe many of them believe that all of their medical, social, and psychiatric problems can be solved at the hospital. Surely we have a magic bullet.
But theres just not that much you can do with a homeless HIV patient with PCP pneumonia except admit him, treat his presenting complaint, offer him some desulatory drug-rehab opportunity or another and send him on his way. I think modern hospitals are so big that many patients are stunned that we ask them to leave before every problem in their life is solved. Surely their is room in a place that big.
Panda Bear said:Yeah. I wince when I hear my 28-year-old third year resident who went straight from the bosom of her family to college to medical school to Duke offering lifestyle advice to some hoary old drug addict who has been shooting heroin since the late sixties, has had more partners than Amway, and was admitted for PCP pneumonia, cocaine-induced chest pain, and looks twice his stated age.
As if he's going to slap his head, exclaim "Eureka!" and sheepishly apologize for the hash he's made of his life.
Why patronize the guy?
When I was a senior resident I once saw a guy for some minor work related injury. After a few minutes I realized he was one of our most notorious homeless drunks who had disappeared several months earlier. We all assumed he was dead since he was usually almost a daily visitor to the ED Somehow he had gotten himself straightened out and now had a home and a job. I looked back at the old records and discovered that on his last drunk homeless visit one of my colleagues had written "Please stop drinking or you will die" on his discharge instructions. I guess every so often it works because I tell every drunk/drug abuser I see the same thing now figuring that even if it only works once every 5-10 years that it is still worth it. (I have a secret feeling the "Please" part might be important)Panda Bear said:Yeah. I wince when I hear my 28-year-old third year resident who went straight from the bosom of her family to college to medical school to Duke offering lifestyle advice to some hoary old drug addict who has been shooting heroin since the late sixties, has had more partners than Amway, and was admitted for PCP pneumonia, cocaine-induced chest pain, and looks twice his stated age.
As if he's going to slap his head, exclaim "Eureka!" and sheepishly apologize for the hash he's made of his life.
Why patronize the guy?
ERMudPhud said:When I was a senior resident I once saw a guy for some minor work related injury. After a few minutes I realized he was one of our most notorious homeless drunks who had disappeared several months earlier. We all assumed he was dead since he was usually almost a daily visitor to the ED Somehow he had gotten himself straightened out and now had a home and a job. I looked back at the old records and discovered that on his last drunk homeless visit one of my colleagues had written "Please stop drinking or you will die" on his discharge instructions. I guess every so often it works because I tell every drunk/drug abuser I see the same thing now figuring that even if it only works once every 5-10 years that it is still worth it. (I have a secret feeling the "Please" part might be important)
docB said:But that's what people think, that society should get them from door to ER and back.
docB said:So I had another similar situation today. A guy came in from some other little town out in the desert by ambulance the workup was brief:
Patient: "My wife threw me out of the house for sleeping with this waitress. Can I stay in the hospital for a few days?"
GeneralVeers said:Good story. I had a 60 year old homeless guy call the ambulance for quote: "No food in my stomach for 3 days". I promptly discharged him (after his courtesy CXR and EKG) without feeding him. He also took a dump on the floor on the way out.
GeneralVeers said:Good story. I had a 60 year old homeless guy call the ambulance for quote: "No food in my stomach for 3 days". I promptly discharged him (after his courtesy CXR and EKG) without feeding him. He also took a dump on the floor on the way out.
mikecwru said:uhhhh... what did you do a CXR and EKG for?
mike
GeneralVeers said:Some of my attendings demand "courtesy" labs or X-rays. One of our least competent attendings told one of my colleagues that no one gets discharged without "courtesy labs". They're not actually looking for anything, they just like it to appear that we've done something for the patient.
When he's on, I want to shoot myself in the head repeatedly. I have no choice but to order the BS labs. Every time I argue with him I get the lecture: "In the REAL world you'll be ordering these labs all the time to screen for things that will get you sued. You want to keep your license don't you?"
BKN said:Our tax dollars at work in La-La land
But general sir. . .you don't argue with attendings!
GeneralVeers said:Good story. I had a 60 year old homeless guy call the ambulance for quote: "No food in my stomach for 3 days". I promptly discharged him (after his courtesy CXR and EKG) without feeding him. He also took a dump on the floor on the way out.
I still have no good way to measure or evaluate this, but I'm convinced that the dispossessed and those who are shafted by one part of "the system" (welfare, unemployment, maybe even parking tickets for all I know) feel an enhanced sense of entitlement. They feel they have some recompense coming, and so they treat the ED as a part of the system they can -- honorably, justifiably, to their way of thinking -- exploit.docB said:There's a town called Pahrump about 60 miles west of Vegas... They have no hospital there so when they get sick they just call 911 for a ride to the clinic... I mean ER....
... (The patient) really wanted to know why the ambulance couldn't just come and get her and she also opined loudly that they should have waited on her. But that's what people think, that society should get them from door to ER and back.