DO and Neurology

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
D

drthedude

Full Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2018
Messages
2,218
Reaction score
2,258
Hello everyone! I have been grateful to have been accepted into a DO school and was wondering how DO friendly Neurology is and whether or not how worried I should be as a DO matching into Neuro. Ty in advance!
Members don't see this ad.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
I matched last cycle, and I only had a 425 Level 1 and 435 Level 2 (pass is 400 for both). I actually failed Level 2 on my first attempt with a 384. Only had Step 1 of 204 (pass is 196) and not Step 2. So I'd say very friendly at the moment. Of course, some people with similar stats or even slightly better probably didn't match as well, but I mean, it's very doable as long you don't flunk anything. I anticipate it will get slightly more competitive every year though.
 
DrStephenStrange said:
I matched last cycle, and I only had a 425 Level 1 and 435 Level 2 (pass is 400 for both). I actually failed Level 2 on my first attempt with a 384. Only had Step 1 of 204 (pass is 196) and not Step 2. So I'd say very friendly at the moment. Of course, some people with similar stats or even slightly better probably didn't match as well, but I mean, it's very doable as long you don't flunk anything. I anticipate it will get slightly more competitive every year though.
Click to expand...
would you say step 1 is necessary for neuro? or only COMLEX
 
drthedude said:
would you say step 1 is necessary for neuro? or only COMLEX
Click to expand...
Not necessary, but it would help a tone if you have both step 1 and 2. I sincerely believe that I got at least half of my interviews because I had a Step 1.

See my original thread below that cycle. I had interviews at some pretty impressive places despite my low stats. And I match at very good program.
forums.studentdoctor.net

What are my chances applying neurology this year?

So I am at one of the newer DO schools and also URM/black (if that makes a difference) applying Neuro this year. Step 1 and Level 1 didn't turn out great with a 204 and 425 (on first attempt). Still working on Step 2 and Level 2, and my scores won't come out until 2 weeks into the cycle...
forums.studentdoctor.net forums.studentdoctor.net
 
DrStephenStrange said:
Not necessary, but it would help a tone if you have both step 1 and 2. I sincerely believe that I got at least half of my interviews because I had a Step 1.

See my original thread below that cycle. I had interviews at some pretty impressive places despite my low stats. And I match at very good program.
forums.studentdoctor.net

What are my chances applying neurology this year?

So I am at one of the newer DO schools and also URM/black (if that makes a difference) applying Neuro this year. Step 1 and Level 1 didn't turn out great with a 204 and 425 (on first attempt). Still working on Step 2 and Level 2, and my scores won't come out until 2 weeks into the cycle...
forums.studentdoctor.net forums.studentdoctor.net
Click to expand...
appreciate your help, congrats on your match again!!
 
DrStephenStrange said:
I matched last cycle, and I only had a 425 Level 1 and 435 Level 2 (pass is 400 for both). I actually failed Level 2 on my first attempt with a 384. Only had Step 1 of 204 (pass is 196) and not Step 2. So I'd say very friendly at the moment. Of course, some people with similar stats or even slightly better probably didn't match as well, but I mean, it's very doable as long you don't flunk anything. I anticipate it will get slightly more competitive every year though.
Click to expand...

This is probably another example of why every DO should take at least USMLE Step 1. It seems passing it has benefited you greatly, and programs don't really GAF about COMLEX scores.
 
DoctoOcto said:
This is probably another example of why every DO should take at least USMLE Step 1. It seems passing it has benefited you greatly, and programs don't really GAF about COMLEX scores.
Click to expand...
Seems like maybe not step 2 however?
 
Ibn Alnafis MD said:
The field does feel terrible at times but when you apply for jobs and realize that everyone is begging you to choose them, you realize how fortunate you are for choosing this specialty.
Click to expand...

Can you comment on what aspects feel terrible at times?
 
Members don't see this ad :)
currently, very friendly but with rapid school expansion, it’s impossible to predict. Look at radiology. Used to be very easy for DOs to match..now will have a DO match rate lower than surgery
 
voxveritatisetlucis said:
currently, very friendly but with rapid school expansion, it’s impossible to predict. Look at radiology. Used to be very easy for DOs to match..now will have a DO match rate lower than surgery
Click to expand...
Please, you're an M1. Let's focus on the facts that Neurology has always been a DO-friendly specialty.
 
Like mentioned above, poorly differentiated consults makes me feel that neurology is a dumping ground.

Any loss of consciousness (including due to having a plasma EtOH level of 400)? consult neurology
Generalized weakness (including chronic deconditioning and failing to thrive)? consult neurology
Woke up in the morning feeling "strange"? consult neurology

At times, I feel that my job is to basically an accurate history.

The above is compounded by a great deal of unease among other physicians when confronted with anything brain related. Suddenly, everything becomes a STAT/ASAP. Understandable and I would probably act the same way if I didn't do a neurology training, but it still takes toll on us.

Also don't get me started on the psychogenic presentations...
 
DrStephenStrange said:
Lazy consults, functional patients you can do nothing about, stroke alerts for things that aren't strokes, very long hours in residency. Just to name a few.
Click to expand...
Ibn Alnafis MD said:
Like mentioned above, poorly differentiated consults makes me feel that neurology is a dumping ground.

Any loss of consciousness (including due to having a plasma EtOH level of 400)? consult neurology
Generalized weakness (including chronic deconditioning and failing to thrive)? consult neurology
Woke up in the morning feeling "strange"? consult neurology

At times, I feel that my job is to basically an accurate history.

The above is compounded by a great deal of unease among other physicians when confronted with anything brain related. Suddenly, everything becomes a STAT/ASAP. Understandable and I would probably act the same way if I didn't do a neurology training, but it still takes toll on us.

Also don't get me started on the psychogenic presentations...
Click to expand...

Outside of the job market, what are some things that make you glad you picked the specialty? I am strongly interested in the specialty simply based on the fact that I really enjoyed neuroscience at a premed level, and I'm curious how much of that translates to appreciating neurology as a medical specialty.
 
DoctoOcto said:
Outside of the job market, what are some things that make you glad you picked the specialty? I am strongly interested in the specialty simply based on the fact that I really enjoyed neuroscience at a premed level, and I'm curious how much of that translates to appreciating neurology as a medical specialty.
Click to expand...
+1 but I was a neuroscience major
 
Goro said:
Please, you're an M1. Let's focus on the facts that Neurology has always been a DO-friendly specialty.
Click to expand...
It’s happening to gas and rads (two specialties that have been DO friendly for about a decade). Why assume it couldn’t happen in neurology as well. It would almost certainly happen if neurologists begin to make a significant premium over hospitalists
 
drthedude said:
+1 but I was a neuroscience major
Click to expand...
0% of it translates. The day-to-day of Neurology in 2022 is closer to being a Social Worker than it is to being a Neuroscience PhD. I'd venture that 5% of my fellow Neurologists (or less) can explain the Hodgkin-Huxley model. However, I am certain that 100% of my fellow Neurologists have a go-to list of exam tasks to detect conversion disorder.
 
voxveritatisetlucis said:
It’s happening to gas and rads (two specialties that have been DO friendly for about a decade). Why assume it couldn’t happen in neurology as well. It would almost certainly happen if neurologists begin to make a significant premium over hospitalists
Click to expand...

Yes but GAS and Rads don’t experience nearly the same level of burnout that Neurology does. Not to mention the hot job market for IM and several DO friendly IM subspecialties. There’s also still a high number of IMGs going into neuro, those will probably get replaced by DOs.

All specialties are getting more competitive, but neuro is not getting more competitive than others.
 
voxveritatisetlucis said:
It’s happening to gas and rads (two specialties that have been DO friendly for about a decade). Why assume it couldn’t happen in neurology as well. It would almost certainly happen if neurologists begin to make a significant premium over hospitalists
Click to expand...

Nobody goes into neurology to escape medicine the way (some) go into gas or rads to escape it.

If the compensation changes, that’s a different story.
 
DoctoOcto said:
Can you comment on what aspects feel terrible at times?
Click to expand...

Just to re-emphasize what others said: to paraphrase one of the Dr. Glaucomflecken videos, a large percentage of your neurology referrals/consults will be placed by people who didn't pay attention to neuroscience in preclinicals, didn't have a neurology rotation in clinicals, and view the nervous system as a scary black box, to which any symptom may be attributed and which cannot be probed by anyone other than an experienced neurologist. There is no symptom which is exempt from a referral to a neurologist for the question "is this either MS, a stroke, or a neuromuscular condition?" On the inpatient side, you will see plenty of consults for patients who "feel strange" or "feel tired" or are "confused." If you walk into an ED and tell them you have a headache without giving any other details, you will likely see a neurologist. Etc. You gotta pick your poison. If you like the inpatient workup of autoimmune encephalitis, for example, you also need to be ready to explain to a hospitalist that the decompensated cirrhotic in renal failure whose BUN and ammonia numbers are both higher than their serum sodium probably doesn't need an autoimmune encephalitis workup. Depending on where you work, the consult "I don't feel like I can confidently do a neuro exam on this patient, will you do one for me?" may not be uncommon. There are some hospitals where consults are relatively rare and complex because the hospitalist already did a reasonable workup, and there are others where your day is full of mostly very brief, very simple consults.

Also, functional patients. Also, you get one brain, and unlike almost any other major organ in the body, if you wreck it you can't get another one from a cadaver. You will have to explain that to crying family members more times than you can count.

voxveritatisetlucis said:
It would almost certainly happen if neurologists begin to make a significant premium over hospitalists
Click to expand...
Neurologists have done an excellent job of keeping their compensation to themselves. Neurohospitalists already make a significant premium over medicine hospitalists. That hasn't been enough to tip the needle sufficiently.
 
So what are the good parts? You guys regret choosing neuro?
 
Dantes said:
So what are the good parts? You guys regret choosing neuro?
Click to expand...
Regret choosing it over Opthalmology or Dermatology? Sure, but then I didn’t have the drive to put in the work to match these fields

Some of the good parts of neurology for me are:
- being a very cerebral (pun) field. I enjoy thinking about stuff rather than reflexively jump to conclusions
- the complexity of the nervous system and how knowing your Neuro anatomy helps pinpoint (for the most part) the lesion.
- the various clinical manifestations of brain disease (cognitive vs weakness vs convulsive, rigidity vs coma etc)
- the various manifestations you get from an identical injury.
 
Prehealth1011 said:
Anesthesia and Rads are more competitive because 1) they uniformly start at 400-450k 2) they let you escape medicine for the most part

Neuro does neither, usually has a brutal residency and salary isn’t so far off of general IM that people will debate IM+fellowship vs neurology. I doubt it’ll become like Rads/anesthesia anytime soon
Click to expand...
That last part is not true. The salary difference between IM and Neurology grads fresh off residency with no fellowship is actually pretty significant. Like 100K or more difference.
 
Last edited:
Ibn Alnafis MD said:
The field does feel terrible at times but when you apply for jobs and realize that everyone is begging you to choose them, you realize how fortunate you are for choosing this specialty.
Click to expand...
Then as a 4th year applying to neuro, can I infer that most residencies will train us to be a competent neurology with good job prospects? I ask this as someone who is looking into community programs and just to be a decent general neurologist with maybe a fellowship in vascular.
 
Catsfordays said:
Then as a 4th year applying to neuro, can I infer that most residencies will train us to be a competent neurology with good job prospects? I ask this as someone who is looking into community programs and just to be a decent general neurologist with maybe a fellowship in vascular.
Click to expand...
Yes, most programs should provide you with the bread and better training to handle 90% of general neuro stuff as well as neurologic emergencies
 
What do competitive neuro programs really care for? Is it research, boards, or audition performance - or will I just have to become a triple threat?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

whatsupdoc28
Neurology as a DO
Replies
19
Views
3K
DrStephenStrange
DrStephenStrange
A
How DO-friendly is neurology
Replies
15
Views
3K
Postictal Raiden
Postictal Raiden
M
  • Locked
Child Neurology?
Replies
0
Views
828
MahoganySmoothC
M
C
Pslf and idr repealed????
Replies
1
Views
630
Mr.Smile12
Mr.Smile12
Melo00
DO taking Step 2 only
Replies
6
Views
834
Ho0v-man
Ho0v-man
Top