Do Publishers Neglect DO Students?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Scott_L

Senior Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2001
Messages
115
Reaction score
0
Hi,

I was wondering if there were enough basic and clinical science titles on the market for DO students. Is there a need for any course or COMLEX review material?

Feel free to post here or e-mail me directly. I work for Lippincott Williams & Wilkins and would like to hear from you.

[email protected]

Regards,

Scott Lavine
Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
 
I think there should be some more online resources for osteopathic manipulation techniques.
 
DrMaryC said:
I think there should be some more online resources for osteopathic manipulation techniques.

If there were more DOs who actually practiced OMT, then there probably would be more resources.
 
Scott_L said:
Hi,

I was wondering if there were enough basic and clinical science titles on the market for DO students. Is there a need for any course or COMLEX review material?

Feel free to post here or e-mail me directly. I work for Lippincott Williams & Wilkins and would like to hear from you.

[email protected]

Regards,

Scott Lavine
Lippincott Williams & Wilkins


First Aid, Step Up, BRS, High Yeild, and Savareese work wonderfully. However if you build it they shall come.
 
I read in the latest issue of The New Physician (AMSA magazine) that two DO students were going to publish a COMLEX board review book to rival those for the USMLE. I think that's great.

As far as basic sciences, the books are the same for MD or DO so there's no problem there. There's no such thing as "osteopathic pharmacology" or "osteopathic microbiology."

I do believe there's a shortage of DO authors out there, and I hope that changes in the future.
 
Not much of a market, only 3000 potential customers a year. I'm sure if they thought there was money to be made, they would.
 
Shinken said:
I read in the latest issue of The New Physician (AMSA magazine) that two DO students were going to publish a COMLEX board review book to rival those for the USMLE. I think that's great.

http://www.indusbusinessjournal.com....Publishing.Deal.For.Exam.Review-687736.shtml

Medical students ink publishing deal for exam review
By Rimin Dutt
Published: Tuesday, June 1, 2004

NEW YORK - When students Rupen Modi and Naishadh Shah struggled to find helpful review books to prepare for their medicine-licensing exam, they decided to write their own.

Within a year they landed a book contract with Blackwell Publishing.

Modi and Shah's book, a review guide written to help students prepare for the Comprehensive Osteopathic Medical Licensing Exam, will be published in the spring of 2005.

Osteopathy students must pass three levels of the licensing exam, an equivalent of the United States Medical Licensing Exam. Osteopathic medicine focuses on the whole person rather than on symptoms, diseases and medical conditions. Its approach to health care requires attention to the body-mind connection, touch and physical manipulation and to the circumstances in which a patient lives and works.

Modi and Shah are currently fourth year osteopathic medical students at the New York College Of Osteopathic Medicine. They are part of a combined program at their school, through which, they will receive a bachelor's of science degree and doctoral degree in osteopathic medicine. They will graduate in 2005.

During their own preparation for the licensing exam in 2002, Modi and Shah found few review books on the market.

"We would joke about the subject for about six to seven months and then in March of 2003, we wrote a proposal to see what publishers had to say about it," said Modi.

"After studying for our (Comprehensive Osteopathic Medical Licensing Exam) Level 1 exam, we also noticed a need for 'our type of book' in the market," added Shah. "Because we both enjoy teaching and take pride in our profession, we decided to contribute further by officially writing a book," said Shah.

They landed a book deal with Blackwell Publishing by the end of 2003.

"We did not consider what publisher we would get, we were only concerned with putting out a quality product that would help students prepare for major board exams and rotations," said Modi.

The young authors believe that writing a book for students is a difficult task, which is why very few students of medicine attempt to do so.

"It's a tough thing to sell to publishers," said Shah.

According to him their teaching experience helped them come up with a convincing proposal.

Both Shah and Modi were selected as undergraduate teaching fellows, a merit-based scholarship in their second year at the medical school. Under the fellowship program, they invest an extra year teaching their respective subjects to the first, second and third year students.

"One of the greatest benefits of the fellowships is the opportunity to teach... this has taught us how to express our thoughts and ideas in a clear and informative manner," added Shah. "Using our background knowledge, teaching experience, and enthusiasm to contribute to medical literature ... the process became a lot easier."

"Writing a book requires a little vision, some planning and a lot of time," said Modi. "We had a tremendous vision, good planning, but we are always short on time. Between the workload from (New York College of Medicine), working on our MBAs, and all the other extracurricular activities we are involved in, time management was important."

According to them, the format of their book is its best selling point. Topics are explained with a question and answer format for effective learning as opposed to prose and paragraphs, said Modi.

"There are many good resources out there for these same topics, but our book has many unique advantages including its format, size, and high-yield review," said Shah. "This book primarily revolves around making sure students are better prepared for their board exams and rotations."

Shah and Modi received tremendous support from their teachers at their school in preparing the book.

"Our professors and advisors offered their personal library for our use," said Modi.

Both Modi and Shah are also enrolled in the School of Management at the New York Institute of Technology, and are anticipating completion of their master's degrees in business administration this year.

Modi was born and raised in Pennsylvania. Shah was born in Gujurat, India, but grew up in Queens, N.Y, and East Brunswick, N.J.
 
bigmuny said:
Not much of a market, only 3000 potential customers a year. I'm sure if they thought there was money to be made, they would.

A classmate of mine and I had this idea and began work on it, but the problems are:

1) very difficult to make money on it when no more than 3000 people would buy it.

2) someone brought back news that one of the schools had decided to do a free review guide as a school project.

My thoughts are: anyone can buy the usual review books and add Savarese and do well...the COMLEX just required different levels of critical thinking (often lower levels) than the USMLE.

I think a great resource would be if there were more study questions out there that were representative.
 
PublicHealth said:
If there were more DOs who actually practiced OMT, then there probably would be more resources.

Good point, but I think the opposite is also true. Whereas you can google just about every medical term, there is not as of yet an online resource to reference OMT.

Maybe more DO's would practice OMT if they could quickly access an online reference of treatments that might be indicated for a patient. Instead of blowing off the use of the OMT or having to go look in a book.
 
The other thing to consider is that the format of the COMLEX is going to change to the computer. This may effect how the content is presented. It also seems like the COMLEX is different every year whereas the USMLE doesn't change drastically. There are only a few areas that you know are going to emphasized on the COMLEX. I don't know how much a COMLEX review book will add because the test is so bad. Case in point...I believe they went from one book with black and white pictures, to one book with color pictures, to two books with color pictures. It also seemed like this year the test started out with fairly short, recall questions but then the last book had more lengthy clinical vinettes. And did anyone else recall there were like 10 questions on Strep. pneumo? So what do you say in your COMLEX review book...be prepared for anything? Thanks.

As a side note, Kaplan has what they call a COMLEX review course. Basically what they did was take their USMLE review materials, change the cover, and throw in some viscerosomatic reflexes here and there. The materials are good, don't get me wrong, but they certainly aren't specifically preparing you for the COMLEX.
 
the two guys that are writing the book from NYCOM are super bright. one is an anatomy fellow, the other an OMM fellow. They are both very smart and excellent teachers. i am looking forward to their book.
 
Top