D
deleted202457
Anyone think it is possible to be as diagnostically brilliant as Dr. House?
You should rephrase this as: "Anyone think it is possible to be as brilliant an actor as Hugh Laurie?"Anyone think it is possible to be as diagnostically brilliant as Dr. House?
Half saving? More like 10 seconds.He doesn't strike me as that brilliant. He spends half of the episode killing the patient and the other half saving them.
The "cases" presented in the show are exaggerated examples of medical anomalies and/or coincidences that might occur once in the career of your average physician. Even if one was "diagnostically brilliant" (whatever that means), it would be hard to establish such a reputation when difficult cases are so few and usually managed by a team of specialists. Modern medicine is so specialized that no one is an expert on everything, which apparently is what House is supposed to be. So no.
If I were able to write my own dialogue and plot, having the story arc conform to my already established "disease of the week", sure, I could do it, too.
House isn't real medicine.
but Dr. Cox on the other hand...😉
Anyone think it is possible to be as diagnostically brilliant as Dr. House?
Great character drama, and I've love Hugh Laurie since his days role on Black Adder. That said, revist House after M3 year... their brilliant sounding discussions of differential diagnoses will make you squirm in your seat.
Great character drama, and I've love Hugh Laurie since his days role on Black Adder. That said, revist House after M3 year... their brilliant sounding discussions of differential diagnoses will make you squirm in your seat.
Agreed, if you are not a better doctor than House, you certainly ought to get your money back from your medical school and hand in your medical license.
Please note: There was an episode in which a patient died from staph aureus septicemia from a sore on the back b/c they were too incompetent to do a complete physical exam. That alone should strike you as a shocking dereliction of duty on the part of the physicians.
Haven't you ever seen this?
That in short summarizes what I think of House
Great character drama, and I've love Hugh Laurie since his days role on Black Adder. That said, revist House after M3 year... their brilliant sounding discussions of differential diagnoses will make you squirm in your seat.
Anyone think it is possible to be as diagnostically brilliant as Dr. House?
I just wondered if it was actually possible to be able to recall the off the wall medical knowledge off the top of your head that he does. I know he is a crappy doctor but I wondered if doctors actually are able to diagnose those diseases that occur once every thirty years or whatever.
Uh...anyone who has passed Step 1 is as diagnostically brilliant as House.
Because, sweet Jeebus, "Dr." House is a friggin' *****. The fellows that he has working with him are even stupider.
Is it possible? Not really - it takes a lot of research to dig up some of these diagnoses. You still need to go back and read Harrison's every now and then, even as an attending.
The problem isn't that House can't remember the more esoteric diseases. The problem is that he (and his fellows) seem incapable of remembering the basic fundamental details that even med students ought to know.
how do you know about his college days? Is it told in the show?
i know he is not real. I just wondered if it was actually possible to be able to recall the off the wall medical knowledge off the top of your head that he does. I know he is a crappy doctor but I wondered if doctors actually are able to diagnose those diseases that occur once every thirty years or whatever.