C would be better than W or a D. What about the tuition that you'll lose on this?
A C is not a big deal. People get into med school with a D on their transcripts.
I think any of the above scenarios is going to look equally fishy. I guess it's up to you whether you'd rather start all over in the course or bust your butt and move on.
I strongly disagree with this. A grade of a C calculates into your GPA, while a W does not. If you have one or two W's, that's not going to kill your application.
After seeing how the admission process works, I can tell you that most admission committee members aren't going to run through your application with a fine tooth comb, like some pre-meds think. They have thousands of applications to get through. Your course history by AMCAS is just one huge long laundry list of classes and nobody is really going to notice/care if you took 3 classes instead of 4 one semester. I know a lot of people that just skim through applications and just look at the bottom line; ie, GPA and MCAT. A 4.0 is a 4.0. If you have 2 or 3 W's, nobody is going to care too much.
Things that stick out like a sore thumb are what you should worry about. If you have straight A's and one C or D, that sticks out. If you have 10 W's, ya, that sticks out. If you took a semester off and didn't explain why, that will probably stick out.
Personally, before I interview, I take about 1 minute and look at BCPM GPA. Then I'll run through their science classes and see if there's any red flags. I don't take the time to see what the course load was each individual semester, or that they took organic chem with molecular biology and physics. So don't be a martyr and take a C, thinking that it is more impressive that you stuck it out. It's not.