I want to know what programs are out there, that are similar to MSP, that don't have active students teaching the MCAT classes. I doubt there are very many if any at all. Meaning, no matter where you go there is always going to be a mediocre effort on the part of the advanced student teaching the MCAT class because he or she are more concerned about their current classes then to give a 100% effort trying to convey concepts during the MCAT class. Thats the plain old truth right there. If there is a program that hires outside teachers, that don't do anything else except teach for the MCAT, then that program would be better...but that also costs a lot more money then some programs might be willing to part with. It's easier for them to pay successful past students and keep it "in house".
The MCAT classes are weak, in my opinion, simply because the IMS students are too busy studying for their medical courses and trying to match the avg of the 1st years at DUCOM.
The "reputation" includes the MSP program because the MSP and IMS programs are linked (granted that you have a 3.0 GPA and a 27 or higher on your MCAT at the conclusion of the MSP year). This gives the motivated student multiple opportunities to prove his or her self to medical school admissions.