E1 reaction question--> methide shift?

[Madnesor]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Hi, I have a question about the E1 reaction for 3- pentanol. When I tried to write out the mechanism, I included a 1,2 methide shift to stabilize the carbocation intermediate from a secondary--> tertiary carbocation. The answer does not include this step, thus the final product is different. Whey would no methide shift occur?

 

[kmp0410]

I don't follow?

The carbocation is formed on carbon 3, which is a secondary carbocation.

Is a C1->C2 shift even possible here? If you did a C2 -> C3 methyl shift, you would actually make a primary carbocation.

The H+ on C-2 simply gets removed and the electrons form a C2-C3 double bond.

 

[Madnesor]

Oh woops that was dumb of me. Thanks 🙂