I've been saying this $hit for years.....
http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2016/07/youll-surprised-ers-meeting-metrics.html
http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2016/07/youll-surprised-ers-meeting-metrics.html
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
I've been saying this $hit for years.....
http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2016/07/youll-surprised-ers-meeting-metrics.html
This is the big failure of our profession in general and our specialty specifically. On the one hand, we complain about having to answer to metrics that we believe are not in the interests of our patients and don't correlate to quality of care. And yet we fail to provide an alternate, better way of measuring quality of care. "Trust me, I'm the doctor" isn't going to work anymore. We have to either come up with our own KPIs, or stop complaining that the MBA/MHAs are doing it for us.
I don't know. Perhaps the issue is so complex that it is difficult to quantify quality, which is exactly why it's called "quality of care" and not "quantity of care." It's very hard to measure quality with any metric.
We've lost on this. Period.
The big issue is not quality. We can propose all we like alternative "quality" measurements that we'd like to see. They will fall on deaf ears. This is all about government non-payment of medical costs, nothing else.
This is exactly why government should not be involved in healthcare. Those of you voting for Hillary are essentially voting for more government control, and more of these insane metrics.
Acknowledging that we've lost, means that cynically I will continue to do unethical things, and things I find ridiculous (code sepsis for example) in exchange for maintaining my livelihood. The only options are to go into another field outside of medicine, or move to another country.
Agreed, its a very complex issue. But it seems exactly the sort of thing some high powered academic department could tackle. I would like to see a set of "Harvard metrics" or "Stanford metrics" or some other alternative to the typical Patient Satisfaction/Door-to-Doc/LWOBS/etc combination.
That's a good idea. Could change the tide if a big project like that was undertaken by a powerhouse university.
How would practicing good medicine allow CMS to reduce reimbursement?
Saving money in reducing unnecessary tests?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Saving money in reducing unnecessary tests?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Everything that the government has done including code sepsis, metrics, ... has led to increased costs. Order more tests, use less clinical judgement, hit those time metrics among others. CMS and the govt in general has their bureaucrats working in a bubble and do not foresee the consequences of their actions. They are looking at decreasing reimbursements but fail to see that they are pressuring doctors and hospitals to increase spending so that their reimbursements aren't touched. They are tripping over dollars to pick up pennies.
The government always makes us do more unnecessary testing. This is getting worse with "quality measures" and "patient satisfaction" that make us do tons of medically irrelevant, but expensive testing.
This is the big failure of our profession in general and our specialty specifically. On the one hand, we complain about having to answer to metrics that we believe are not in the interests of our patients and don't correlate to quality of care. And yet we fail to provide an alternate, better way of measuring quality of care. "Trust me, I'm the doctor" isn't going to work anymore. We have to either come up with our own KPIs, or stop complaining that the MBA/MHAs are doing it for us.
Though I am not at Harvard or Stanford this has been an academic area of focus for me for the last 5 years. I started on this, because, like you, I feel that we need to either put up or shut up.
I'm here to say that creating a meaningful metric is quite a lot of work. However, we managed to create some fair metrics that appeared to actually improve patient care without penalizing good docs (I'm working on the manuscript this summer, which is why I'll ask you to just take my word for this, rather than divulging all the details here). It was so successful that the university's health system administration took notice and wanted to use it as an example for other departments. So, I had several meetings with them, explained the importance of having secondary reviews, monitoring for exclusion criteria, being able to provide case-specific feedback, etc.
The administration took it over from me and in their infinite wisdom decided to fully automate it.
I'm sure you'll all be shocked to learn that they then completely f*cked it up.
In my experience, for such metrics to work requires oversight by a physician who understands the work environment being measured. Measuring LA-County with a metric that worked for Berkshire Health System but has not been modified will not give you meaningful results. In order to do this well requires a significant amount of physician-hours, which are costly.
Fortunately, for CMS's purposes, it's really quite easy to create a binary blunt bludgeon that 95% of practitioners will fail. Just don't expect there to be any consistency from one quarter to the next in terms of who your top performers are. This variability has the nice side effect of creating learned helplessness in those being measured, which turns recalcitrant physicians into malleable "providers".
I'm not in EM but am in a similar boat. My group got tired of being asked to fulfill "quality metrics" that had nothing to do with our specialty or practice location and so we agreed to propose, implement and study what we considered to be relevant quality metrics. We did so well that not only is our manuscript in preparation but 2 of the 4 largest area private insurers have asked us to write a case study (from the business, not medicine side of things) that they intend to present to the regional Medicare admin company to help get more things paid for.Though I am not at Harvard or Stanford this has been an academic area of focus for me for the last 5 years. I started on this, because, like you, I feel that we need to either put up or shut up.
I'm here to say that creating a meaningful metric is quite a lot of work. However, we managed to create some fair metrics that appeared to actually improve patient care without penalizing good docs (I'm working on the manuscript this summer, which is why I'll ask you to just take my word for this, rather than divulging all the details here). It was so successful that the university's health system administration took notice and wanted to use it as an example for other departments. So, I had several meetings with them, explained the importance of having secondary reviews, monitoring for exclusion criteria, being able to provide case-specific feedback, etc.
This hasn't happened yet to us. But the C-suite just got word of our results a few weeks ago. I suspect the goat rodeo is headed our way as well.The administration took it over from me and in their infinite wisdom decided to fully automate it.
I'm sure you'll all be shocked to learn that they then completely f*cked it up.
You guys can spend all the effort you like. Academic institutions can throw millions of dollars and hundreds of associate professors at the problem. It's not going to matter.
As I've stated before the government has no interest in "quality". It's all about non-payment and they want to control those metrics. Too many docs/hospitals hitting the "quality" metrics? They will move the bar as they see fit in order to reduce payments.
The only out that doctors have is to not take medicare/medicaid or private insurance, and to close EDs so that EMTALA doesn't apply.
If the CMS turned around tomorrow and said, 'Fine GeneralVeers, you win. We will switch to whatever quality metrics you propose. What will it be?" you wouldn't even have a real answer to give them.
Yes, the government may only care about costs, but right now we don't even have a solid argument against that except 'We don't like it!'. If we had good measures of quality, it would be at least possible (although far from guaranteed) that we could mount a lobbying campaign to pressure the government into tracking the good metrics rather than the bad. At least it would be a possibility to get something that we want. Right now, we don't even have an 'ask'. If the CMS turned around tomorrow and said, 'Fine GeneralVeers, you win. We will switch to whatever quality metrics you propose. What will it be?" you wouldn't even have a real answer to give them.
ACEP has initiated the CEDR which purports to be the "first Emergency Medicine specialty-wide registry at a national level, designed to measure and report healthcare quality and outcomes". [https://www.acep.org/cedr/]
I agree with most of the above measures (with exception of tobacco cessation needing to be done by the doctor). I think most of these measures are things all of us do all the time. Pregnancy test on female with abdominal pain? 100%. EKG on everyone with non-traumatic pain? 100% here.
The problem with all of these is that they are good medicine and we do them all pretty close to 100% of the time. How is government going to move the bar in order to cut reimbursement if we hit all of these? It might get to a ridiculous level, that if you don't do one EKG in a year on one non-traumatic chest pain patient then you fall out, and lose money.
You (and your source) are leaving out the fact that Dr. A's hospital doesn't want a lower admission rate. If they could, they would have you admit everyone that meets the minimum criteria. Because they get paid. Same as MRIs and CTs. It's never the hospital that complains, it's radiology because they have to work harder, etc.But what if Dr. A’s CT/MRI scan utilization, length of stay times, consultation rates, and admission rates are all lower, and yet her return visit rate is half that of Dr. B? Patient outcomes are hard to come by, but on paper this all points to Dr. A providing better and faster care than Dr. B. At face value, Dr. B appears to be slow, insecure, and possibly unsafe. But what if Dr. B is the one who “cleans up” after the other physicians? What if he routinely attends to the elderly and complex patients to provide exemplary and patient-centred care, instead of picking up the young and “easier to treat” patients, as Dr. A does? Which physician would you want taking care of your elderly mother?
Our mission is to provide students with free, unbiased information, resources, and advising for careers in the health professions. We believe every student deserves access to trustworthy guidance, regardless of background or ability to pay.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.