My thing with this is that there seems to be a big push to say that there is a big distinction between your run of the mill agitated meth head and these "Excited Delirium" patients. I don't think that there is. I think they're just degrees of severity on a spectrum.
I didn't vote above, because I think the answer is both Yes and No.
To docB's point - yes, this does fall on a spectrum of severe sympathomimesis from stimulant agents. From a clinical standpoint, the manifestations are consistent with what one would expect from intoxication by these drugs. So, in this regard, I believe that you're correct in asserting "No."
However, to Wilco's point - what defines ExDS is the specific physiological changes that are occurring in these patients. Their risk of death due to their underlying intoxication, especially when looked at through the lens of what is required to protect them from themselves (e.g. immobilization), is much higher than that of your run-of-the-mill meth head. I mean, think of it this way - if they're already hyperstimulated, then why don't benzos work well? We give ketamine for ExDS - as a structural analog of PCP, it should be stimulating in its own right, but (with limited data) seems to work out well.
There was a presentation on this by the Regions Tox Group at the most recent NACCT in Atlanta a few weeks ago, and their data seemed to suggest better outcomes with ketamine instead of other pharmacologic agents.
One analogy (albeit not great, but it's the first thing that comes to mind) is Sudden Sniffing Death Syndrome - VF induced by inhalants and a sudden catecholamine surge (usually when mom or dad catches you huffing). It falls within the spectrum of VF, true; but due to the specific underlying pathophysiology instead of standard ACLS you want to give these patients beta-blockers in lieu of epi/amio/etc. While the VF will certainly kill the patient, it's a question of *what* is inducing VF... similar to the question of "super-high" vs. ExDS.
All this being said, I agree that more research needs to be done on this to tease out your exact question.
Cheers!
-d