Externships

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

avishkar1984

Full Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Sep 14, 2007
Messages
28
Reaction score
0
Points
0
  1. Medical Student
ppl i need sm help regarding externships
it would be gr8 if sm1 could clarify the following doubts

can one apply for an externship as an undergrad??

do externships count as USCE??

where all can one apply for externships (NOT OBSERVERSHIPS)???

i have got an elective at cornell for the month of feb but thats abt it till now
i am just hoping i get electives at harvard
which if i dont i will be left with just one month of USCE
so i am thinking of playing it safe and applying for externships if they count as USCE

thnx
 
some one must be having sm idea

ppl please i need help

pls do post watever u know

thnx
 
ppl i need sm help regarding externships
it would be gr8 if sm1 could clarify the following doubts

can one apply for an externship as an undergrad??

do externships count as USCE??

where all can one apply for externships (NOT OBSERVERSHIPS)???

i have got an elective at cornell for the month of feb but thats abt it till now
i am just hoping i get electives at harvard
which if i dont i will be left with just one month of USCE
so i am thinking of playing it safe and applying for externships if they count as USCE

thnx
Why do you want to apply to externship instead of clerkship if you're not graduated?
 
i hv already applied
i am waiting for a reply from harvard and i hv an elective at cornell
but i will be graduating in a fw months and so i need to hv the requisite info before i take the next step
 
Maybe you should have this moved from the step 1 forum.
 
ppl i need sm help regarding externships
it would be gr8 if sm1 could clarify the following doubts

can one apply for an externship as an undergrad??

do externships count as USCE??

where all can one apply for externships (NOT OBSERVERSHIPS)???

i have got an elective at cornell for the month of feb but thats abt it till now
i am just hoping i get electives at harvard
which if i dont i will be left with just one month of USCE
so i am thinking of playing it safe and applying for externships if they count as USCE

thnx

Externships do count as USCE
 
To apply to a certain medical school, visit their website looking for "Visitinf students" or "Electives" and check the requirements, deadlines, weather they accept international students or not...etc. Apply and good luck 🙂
 
FWIW:

Please do not assume you have to do an externship/USCE at a place like Harvard to get a good LOR.

Harvard is a great place, I'm sure but when they (and other places) charge $3,000 USD and up for a 1 month rotation, I'm not sure their reputation is worth it.

The point of USCE is just that...to get clinical experience in a US hospital and to get a letter of recommendation. A good letter from Harvard doesn't make your application any better than a good letter from University Hospital X and I'll let you in on a secret:

<shhhh>

Harvard is not likely to rank an IMG/FMG for residency. University Hospital X might very well do so. You are better off, IMHO, doing an externship someplace else where you may not be charged at all, will get a good LOR and have a decent chance of matching or signing a pre-match contract.

Do not be sucked into the common belief that you have to rotate at some internationally well known place. There are thousands of hospitals in the US who accept FMGs for electives and you will be much more likely to shine there.
 
I have been quite concerned about this point in particular. I heard there are some big names that may offer an international visiting student a future interview, namely Mayo, Cleveland and Henry Ford. So I'm myself considering applying to these places based on what I heard!

I'd like to know if you guys have any idea about this point specifically.(Again, their should be no rules about these issues but at least someone might have an idea)
 
There are thousands of hospitals in the US who accept FMGs for electives and you will be much more likely to shine there.

Well, I would not be that optimistic about the number of hospitals accepting international visiting students. According to my search through the hospitals listed in AMC's website I came up with these results:

Hospitals accept international students + Malpractice is not required = 8-10

Hospitals accept international students + Malpractice is not required + Step 1 is not required = 2-4

This is of course not to mention the tution and TOEFL.

I'd be happy to learn about hospitals other than those listed on the AMC's website.
 
Well, I would not be that optimistic about the number of hospitals accepting international visiting students. According to my search through the hospitals listed in AMC's website I came up with these results:

Hospitals accept international students + Malpractice is not required = 8-10

Hospitals accept international students + Malpractice is not required + Step 1 is not required = 2-4

This is of course not to mention the tution and TOEFL.

I'd be happy to learn about hospitals other than those listed on the AMC's website.

Obviously I exaggerated for effect but there are many more hospitals that accept FMGs than just those listed on the AAMC web site.

If you do not have malpractice insurance good in the US, then yes, that is a problem. Almost every one will require Step 1...since you are rotating as a final year medical student, it is expected that you will have taken it just as the American students have. I do not see this as an additional requirement. ECFMG does not require the TOEFL anymore...are you seeing programs individually requiring it? Most hospitals do not charge or only charge a nominal fee for an elective.

I rotated at:

Baylor Houston (the only one to charge me, and it was around $150)
University of Louisville
University of Virginia
UCSF
Hopkins

My point is that there are other hospitals than just those listed on the AAMC site and that contacting the program directly, especially a faculty member rather than an administrative person, might get you a spot. Of course, I don't think it unreasonable that the program requires you to have malpractice insurance or to pay for it while there or to have passed Step 1. It can be difficult but given that I've seen many other students also do rotations elsewhere without difficulty, I'd venture its more than 2-4 programs that are available. The AAMC site is not a comprehensive list of all programs or hospitals in the US with ACGME or AOA residencies (which are where you really want to do your rotations). And I'm not sure its even correct. For example, UVA technically doesn't allow internationals to rotate there except with faculty sponsorship (which I get easily just by asking). Perhaps that has changed but I wouldn't necessarily take it that the AAMC database is correct.
 
Almost every one will require Step 1...since you are rotating as a final year medical student, it is expected that you will have taken it just as the American students have. I do not see this as an additional requirement.

Where I come from, very limited minority take Step 1 before graduation. So Step 1 makes a huge obstacle. I think this is the case also in all parts of the world.

ECFMG does not require the TOEFL anymore...are you seeing programs individually requiring it?

Mayo, Cleveland and Feinberg require TOEFL(How ironic since ECFMG doesn't require it!)

My point is that there are other hospitals than just those listed on the AAMC site and that contacting the program directly, especially a faculty member rather than an administrative person, might get you a spot.

The thing about AAMC is that they list the university hospitals only, *I think*. So when you check these hospitals they tell you that all contacts should be with the office of registrar and not with the course director or faculty member.

Many of the university hospitals hold the electives at other affiliated community hospitals. Now, I don't know if these community hospitals offer electives outside the university hospital arrangement, *perhaps they don't*. So basically one would be limited with the university hospitals list which technically includes other non-uni hospitals that aren't listed on the AAMC's list. I don't know how valid my understanding is.

Baylor charges now around 1000$/month for internationals. Hopkins doesn't accept internationals. Just for the record 😀

BTW, I am NOT complaining about the requirements and I think if someone is really interested in a US residency he/she should be up to these requirements.

Just curious...Dr Cox, Did you buy a malpractice insurance when you were a student?
 
Where I come from, very limited minority take Step 1 before graduation. So Step 1 makes a huge obstacle. I think this is the case also in all parts of the world.

I understand that. But since presumably, for the vast majority of students wishing to do an elective in the US, the ultimate goal is a US residency, they will have to take Step 1 at some point in time. Therefore, my point being that it behooves them to know the expectations and start working on the exam before final year anyway.

Mayo, Cleveland and Feinberg require TOEFL(How ironic since ECFMG doesn't require it!)

A bit strange yes, but I can imagine they've had trouble before.

The thing about AAMC is that they list the university hospitals only, *I think*. So when you check these hospitals they tell you that all contacts should be with the office of registrar and not with the course director or faculty member.

Why do you need the permission of an administrative person to contact someone? And you are right, the AAMC only lists rotations at programs with medical schools. However, there are MANY ACGME (ie "Green Book") programs not affiliated with AAMC schools, which are not on the list. Thus, it is not by any means a comprehensive list.

Many of the university hospitals hold the electives at other affiliated community hospitals. Now, I don't know if these community hospitals offer electives outside the university hospital arrangement, *perhaps they don't*. So basically one would be limited with the university hospitals list which technically includes other non-uni hospitals that aren't listed on the AAMC's list. I don't know how valid my understanding is.

Again, the AAMC only lists programs affiliated with a US allopathic medical school. It does not list any affiliated with an osteopathic school (which may or may not be an option for international allopathic students) or hospitals which have residencies but not medical schools. The goal is to do rotations at hospitals which have ACGME residencies; while many also have medical schools, many, especially community programs, do not.

Baylor charges now around 1000$/month for internationals.
Well, that's gone up a bit in the last 7 years, hasn't it?

Hopkins doesn't accept internationals. Just for the record 😀

They never have. UCSF doesn't either. My point is that just because the web site says they don't accept internationals doesn't mean that they rigorous apply that, or that its even true. I will admit that as a former UCSF student and employee I probably had some pull there, but at Hopkins it was a matter of just asking. Same with UVA...I contacted faculty and asked them to sponsor me for an elective. U of Louisville takes internationals, lots of them...we had German students there for 6 months at a time.

Just curious...Dr Cox, Did you buy a malpractice insurance when you were a student?

No. My school's policy covered me in North America (we basically made them get that because they sold us the program with a lot of promises about helping us get back to the US, including doing electives there, which then required med mal good in the US.) Only Baylor made me purchase their policy and health insurance which beyond the $150 app fee, made the total I paid them around $300 or so.
 
Thank you Dr Cox for your thorough reply. It has certainlly opend my eyes to new aspects about the "electives game". After all, my info is based on web surfing and not real experience.

I feel that the requirements all around the states are getting more and more strict, may be due to the continuously increasing number of applicants.

There's still one point I'd like to ask about, how many electives preferably should one do?
 
Thank you Dr Cox for your thorough reply. It has certainlly opend my eyes to new aspects about the "electives game". After all, my info is based on web surfing and not real experience.

I feel that the requirements all around the states are getting more and more strict, may be due to the continuously increasing number of applicants.

You are probably right that there are seemingly more pre-requisites and less opportunities than there used to be. I'm not sure why, hopefully its not based on some misguided xenophobia.

There's still one point I'd like to ask about, how many electives preferably should one do?


I think that's really up to you and your school. I did quite a few because I could and I wanted to and could afford it.

The minimum is probably two and any more is gravy. Since the goal again, is to learn about the US medical system and to get LORs, you'll probably want at least two LORs from US faculty and a couple from your own faculty.
 
I see. Thanks for the info 🙂
 
Top Bottom