MD & DO Extra 1-2 Postbacc Years Worth It?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

repentantslacker

New Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2015
Messages
7
Reaction score
1
So I’m just finishing up my first year of an informal postbacc, with a 3.7. If I continue with my current course plan (for a total of 38 credits) and maintain the same average, next year, that will bring my sGPA to 3.38, and total college GPA to 3.47.

However, taking into account the AACOMAS retake policy, my sGPA would be 3.68, and my new college GPA would be…I’m not sure, but it would be in the 3.5 range at least.

That means, after 2 years I will (assuming a good MCAT score) be competitive for DO schools at least numbers-wise. But not so much for MD programs. I like to think that a strong upward trend, 5 years out from college, would be good, but I doubt it’s good enough.



I could increase my course load and get more credits in next year, but I wouldn’t want to risk the 3.7 I’ve been able to attain, especially with Orgo on the horizon. So the alternative would be a third year. If I took a third year postbacc, this time squeezing in 12 credits/semester because Orgo is behind me, and maintaining the same 3.7, I would have about a 3.48 sGPA under AMCAS, and an overall GPA I would estimate somewhere in the 3.5 range. A 4th year taking at least 10 credits and maintaining a 3.7 would bring my sGPA up into 3.5 range. And at that point I’ve basically done undergrad twice 🙁



An extra year or two to be a borderline MD candidate at best, unless there are MD schools that are willing to overlook 10 year old ****ty freshman college grades because of my strong postbacc performance-and if that is a possibility please let me know.



To make this less abstract: based on my shadowing, I found the work neurologists and ENTs do fascinating (no, I did not mean neurosurgeon, I know neurologists don’t do surgery). I know it’s theoretically possible for a DO to match into anything, but are they so difficult for a DO to get that I should spend an extra year or two on top of my thus far 2 year minimum postbacc to shoot for MD? For family reasons, I would strongly prefer to stay somewhere in the Northeast as well.
 
Not to bump my own post, but it just occurred to me that you should take the MCAT after completing your prereqs. So instead of studying for the MCAT with no classes, I can take a modest course load-that's the third year. And take another load during that so-called glide year to sort of hedge my bets. I either solved my own problem or I'm very confused.
 
Does your current post-bac include the adequate MCAT pre-reqs? If so then just continue that and then take the MCAT shortly after. Don't start studying for the MCAT without finishing all of your pre-reqs first.
 
Does your current post-bac include the adequate MCAT pre-reqs? If so then just continue that and then take the MCAT shortly after. Don't start studying for the MCAT without finishing all of your pre-reqs first.

By the end of my second year it'll have been: Gen Chem, Bio, Physics, Orgo, and Biochem.

I saw psych and soc on the list, but I'm not terribly concerned about that since it was pretty much my wheelhouse in undergrad. Not terribly concerned about Verbal reasoning since I did very well on the LSAT-although I will still take it seriously of course.
 
I would still recommend taking Psych/Soc, as it would save you a lot of headache to have that knowledge fresh in your head than to learn it again during MCAT prep. My biggest advice would be to just ace all of your remaining pre-reqs, and keep notecards and notes handy to study throughout the term so that you can minimize the amount of stuff that you'll be re-learning once you study for the MCAT. Also biochem is huge on the new test.
 
I guess the real question I have can be boiled down to this:

Assuming a very good postbacc GPA (upward trend!), and about a 3.5 overall college GPA (which I know is a little below average for MD), how killer would a science GPA (from both undergrad and postbacc) a hair under or above 3.4 be?

I'm just not sure which is the most important. Recent performance/upward trend? Overall College GPA? Overall sGPA (undergrad + postbacc)? Or can you not really say?
 
I would still recommend taking Psych/Soc, as it would save you a lot of headache to have that knowledge fresh in your head than to learn it again during MCAT prep. My biggest advice would be to just ace all of your remaining pre-reqs, and keep notecards and notes handy to study throughout the term so that you can minimize the amount of stuff that you'll be re-learning once you study for the MCAT. Also biochem is huge on the new test.

Is it recommended that postbaccs not take classes while studying for the MCAT? Because if so it seems like a lot of wasted time. I don't have an advisor to ask so I'm sorry for ****ting up the forums with possibly dumb questions.
 
Those are all universally considered to be much equivalent in terms of importance. The last piece of the pie you're missing (literally, the AMCAS has a little diagram with the three major factors for medical school admissions) is MCAT. Check back in when you have your score.
 
Is it recommended that postbaccs not take classes while studying for the MCAT? Because if so it seems like a lot of wasted time. I don't have an advisor to ask so I'm sorry for ****ting up the forums with possibly dumb questions.

Depends on your situation, whether or not you're working full time, etc. A lot of people take it at the end of the summer, but that's hard to do with a post bac so you might have to do both.
 
There is no chance discussion without an MCAT score. But in your case I don't think it is worth taking another year of your life just to raise your GPA .5-.1 when the reason it is low to begin with is because of non science classes from 10 years ago.

Like I said take the MCAT. 85th+ percentile equivalent and good pre-req grades and you can be competitive for an MD acceptance.
 
There is no chance discussion without an MCAT score. But in your case I don't think it is worth taking another year of your life just to raise your GPA .5-.1 when the reason it is low to begin with is because of non science classes from 10 years ago.

Like I said take the MCAT. 85th+ percentile equivalent and good pre-req grades and you can be competitive for an MD acceptance.

Thanks guys (or gals)
 
Top