Finished Step 1 yesterday, some advice.

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Jattdoc

SDN Angel
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2000
Messages
67
Reaction score
0
Well I just took the test yesterday and here is how I prepared. I want to thank everyone who has posted on this board, which I checked compulsively during the past few years, and good luck.

First of all I clipped all the advice from this forum regarding Step I preparation over the last two years and asked for help from some well known posters on this board (Dr. Cuts, Geek Medic and others, who were really helpful, so listen to them when they say something)

So I got all the review books from day one of medical school and used them in my class as study tools. As for hardcore studying, I studied for about 4 to 5 weeks, using a stop watch for 6-8 hours a day. I'm a big time slacker so this was a major challenge, so I would take frequent breaks, switch studying locations, do different subjects in a day. For example, I would study

8:00-9:00 questions - 15 min break
9:15-10:15 review of question - then 30 min break
10:45-11:45 - 1st hour of 2 hour study - 15 min break
12:00 - 1:00 - 2nd hours of 2 hours study - 1 hour break

So four hours study, with 2 hours break, then restart routine at 2:00

Now, nothing is set in stone, so if you don't feel like studying and cant concentrate or aren't being productive, then do something else like take a nap or work out or whatever.

As for the specific subjects, this is what I used

PHYSIOLOGY - Used First Aid & BRS Physiology during the first year Physio course and also to review relevant physiology whenever we were doing path for that specific section. During the USMLE prep days, I used only BRS Physiology, then did the question in the back of each chapter. By this time I had read the book about 4 times. As for the equations (i.e CO, or Clearance of substance X, etc), I had some difficulty but once you understand the equation and know how to manipulate it around, its not that hard. On the USMLE, I had 3 or 4 problems with equation.

PATHOLOGY - Used BRS Path during all of second year and read all of robbins path during the course. Used WebPath during the year, and did all the questions for the system that we were studying at the time. Finally, I did all of the web path question again at the end along with rereading BRS Path several times.

PHARMACOLOGY - Used Lippincot Pharm for the class, and Simultaneously Used High Yield Pharm and First Aid, to keep track of the main drugs and their toxicity. At review time, I used first aid exclusively, however my first aid was scribbled with notes or other information from lippioncot or high yield pharm which I felt was important

MICROBIOLOGY - Used Micro Made Ridiculously Simple (one of the best books ever written) during class and Medical Micro & Immuno by Warren, Md, Phd Levinson, this book has a really go section on immunology, which I felt was not covered well by first aid. Micro in first aid was sufficient. MM&Immuno also has a really good section of quick review of all medically relevant bugs. At the review time, I read MMRSimple Once and read the immunology section of MM&Immuno once and did board like question as the back of MM&Immuno book. Finally if anything important was missing in first aid, I added it to micro section. Know you IL (1-10, etc) and immunodeficiency diseases (Burtons, etc). I had lot of questions on these from Immuno.

BIOCHEMISTRY- Not really my favorite subject. Used Lippincot Biochem during the course. Forgot everything over the summer and second year. Surprisingly a lot of it came back during review time. Used BRS Biochem which I read once (without doing the question), then read high yield Biochem twice, and finally just read the Biochem section of first aid & BIOCHEMICAL TECHNIQUES SECTION OF BRS BIOCHEM ( once every day for 4 weeks). Surprisingly I had very little Biochem on my test (go figure), but I did get tested on PCR and some other lab stuff that I cant remember. If you have limited time. Then I would just study First Aid 2003 and look up unfamiliar concepts Lippincot.

BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE - Used High Yield Behavioral Science during the course. During review, I also purchased High Yield Bio-Stats, because a lot of people of people who just took exam said that the emphasis on biostats had increased recently. In the end I had read high yield biostats and high yield behavioral science twice (but, I read the patient physician relationship section everyday for 4 weeks, and it paid off big time, all the question were like, "what would you say to this patient", so emphasize this section and defense mechanism, and Sleep stages). This section is easy points, so don't ignore it. I didn't study first aid behavioral science, because I think it was too simplified.

ANATOMY/EMBRYOLOGY/HISTO - Hated all of these subject, barely passed and failed Neuroanatomy Course (which I repeated, and a lot of it showed up on Step I, so I was ready). First Aid is more than enough for Step One. I didn't' really study any embryology, overall I had about 2 or 3 embryo, and about 10-15 anatomy and few histo questions(mostly on junctions). In the last few days, just skim over (key word) some radiology atlas and histo/path atlas.

QUESTION BANKS - You can get your hands on tons of questions, but since you have a limited amount of time. Here's what I would recommend in order of importance.

1. USMLE Released Questions - Very similar to the real thing. The questions were similar with a lot more graphs and interpretation of research experiments. I did not get a chance to do the online assessment from NBME, so I cant say anything about that. ALSO, DO THE TUTORIAL on the USMLE CD, so you are familiar with the format.

2. QBANK - Good source, although somewhat more detailed with HLA and other suff. Don't pay too much attention to details, just try to learn the main concept being tested. When simulating tests, always construct the test with ALL SUBJECTS & UNUSED QUESTIONS. I started out with 44%, which was kind of depressing but was mostly due to genetics/anatomy. However towards the end, I was consistently scoring in the 70-75%. I also did the IV QBANK - which is also really good source, but I would do it in the end (after QBANK & Qbook), when you have all the knowledge to integrate everything.

3. QBOOK - Also a good source of questions, especially behavioral science questions. I didn't get chance to finish it. But this is definitely helpful, so make sure you go through this.

4. WEBPATH - Best preparation for path questions of the exam. I would read the BRS Path chapter on a system and then do the corresponding web path questions. I felt that path was my strongest subject.

5. NBOME/COMLEX RELEASED QUESTIONS - People who write comlex questions have a 200 question booklet that you get which I felt was about 90% similar to comlex exam. If you are from MD school, I still suggest this because, you can just skip the OMM (Which I hate) but still do other questions, which I felt were really quality questions. This book is like 15 dollars. .


5. MEDREVU - I did about 1000 questions, but most of the questions were not that good and the explanations are long and difficult to read. I would not recommend these, unless you have a lot of time and would really like just practice questions.


I took both COMLEX/USMLE in same week and I want to say a little bit about COMLEX. Just study for the USMLE and use the Blue book by Saverese for the OMM component and you'll get most of the omm questions. Comlex is more exhausting because its 800 question and its two days with the paper and pencil format.

As for the USMLE Step I, the test was an interesting experience. Remember, USMLE is a test of concepts and fundamental principals. Its not direct recall test. So during my prep I would pick a concept or topic and tried to explain it to somebody, so that I really mastered it. But there is always some esoteric question that you just mark at move on.
During the last week, I just used first aid and did not do any questions. Secondly, I started getting up early in the morning and sleeping early to get back regular sleep cycle. A few days before the exam, I visited the center where I was going to take the exam, and to get familiar with directions and alternative routes. The day before test, I had backup transportation and backup alarm clock to make sure I would make it to the test center in time. Although I couldn't' really sleep the night before. Just kept thinking about stuff I still wanted to learn and had all kinds of negative thoughts. So, just go watch a movie or read something and its OK to be nervous.
Finally got to the test center and there were some people sitting there reading First Aid, so I stayed as far away from them as I could , to avoid being stressed out. Finally, they call you in and seat you. Just request to be seated far away from the door, so people who take breaks don't distract you, because there are always people coming in and out of the test room. Also make sure you have a good breakfast.
As for the test, it took a few question to get into the rhythm of everything. With the above listed question sources, I felt that I had seen about 70-80% of the questions in some form before.
Most of the questions, I could narrow it down to two choices. Don't' dwell on question that you cant answer, mark and more on, and come back to it if you have time.
Overall, the test is really fair and not that difficult (besides stupid research questions). Remember you may get like 10 hard questions in a row, so don't panic, just keep going.
Well, its all over now, and for those who still have to take it, good luck. For those who took, I hope everybody passes. If you have any question or comments, please feel free to post. Good Luck, and I didn't really proofread this.
 
WOW!! Thanks so much for taking the time to write about your experience!! It was really helpful and reassuring to read. It was a very levelheaded account.

Thanks again and congratulations for being done!!
 
yea.. definity a helpful post.

i have a question tho... i didnt really get to do any of the question sets from Robbins Path Review question book during the school year... and i'm wonderin if i should go back and do them now. i really can only afford to put in one week for path at most (this week).. and i'd like to know if youd recommend me doing the RObbins Review book questions.. or should i do Webpath questions instead? i looked over some of the robbins quesitons and some of them seem really difficult and detailed, as opposed to the webpaths which look alot more clinical releated. and it seems to me from your post, that you thought webpath was really helpful. anyways, since i only have one week.. basically, what should i spend my time on most, the Robbins or webpath? tahnks.
 
I haven't taken the exam yet, but the Robbins book is very good -- both for practice questions and for reviewing path as well. There's no telling what type of questions you'll get on your version of the exam, so I'm just trying to cover as much as possible.

good luck
 
Originally posted by Jattdoc
With the above listed question sources, I felt that I had seen about 70-80% of the questions in some form before.

Wow. You seemed to have a very comprehensive review yet there was still 20-30% questions that you hadn't seen before. Can you elaborate on what you mean by that? Were those questions you had no clue about? Can you share the subjects that you felt your review did not adequately cover?


Also, for pharmacology, is FA enough? If I were to memorize every word in the pharm section, will I be able to answer 95% of the pharm question?

Thanks for your detailed review of the test.
 
______________

j_side

In my opinion if you have a week you should use Webpath with BRS PAth. I did have robbins path review book, however i choose webpath for several reasons. First, webpath is similar to USMLE, in that you are actually sitting in front of a computer and answering questions based on long cases with integrated lab values. Secondly, the explanations are accessable right away and you can also look has histopath slides for the disease or learn more about the system or underlying disease. Also, another very important point is that you need to empahsize you weakness. For example, I hated HEME/ONC & RENAL/REPRODUCTIVE - so, i spent more time on that rather than other systems that i was already familiar with, this will help build more confidence. Also, dont forget about general path (inflammation, injury, etc). I had serveral questions dealing with reprefusion injuires, chornic inflammation, etc.

_______________

GrandMasterB
There are no stupid questions on this forum, each question here will definately help you in some way or another on the real thing, so ask anything or anyone, send them an email directly, or just post here

__________

LoneSEAL

First Aid if more than sufficent for Pharmacology. However, don't just memorize pharm, understand (key word) the interactions of various drugs. Know the toxicity and especially which drugs induce/suppress P-450. Most of the pharm questions are relatively straight forward. Also, dont' ignore drugs for neoplasia & tranplantation (which were test fairly heaviliy on my test). Plus I got that horrible question, you know the one about, where a person is given and certain type of blocker (a/b blocker) and then given a second drug, and they give you chart to show you whether it has a pressor or depressor effector. I just guessed and moved on. Pharm, is realitively straightforward, however most of the question are in form of an experiment (i.e research injected an artery with drug X, Z...blah blah)

Let me explain about the 20-30% questions. These were in a format of clinical experiments with multipal graphs and tables. Something, we are never tested or taught in medical school, unless your into medical journals. However, If you get a long case or something, then quickely skim the question, because it might be something stupid like (what do you say to this patient...and waste a lot of your time). These question are not impossible. You can always narrow it down to two choices. But, i had about 1-10 questions, that i can honestly say i had not clue about (even if i studied for two more months), so i just picked my favourite letter and moved on.

In my opion the test covers all of the basic stuff that you have to know about. Some of my friends said that they had a lot of biochem, or biostats, but I think thats because they probably spent of a lot time on those questions and that's why they probably rember them and forgotten the easy one's that they knew about. I think its ok the be weak in low yield subjects (antomy/embroy) or even behavioral science. But you definately need to know the majors (path/pharm etc.)
 
thanks for the support jattadoc, you have been very helpful to everyone on this forum. sorry about the autonomics question- our phram prof writes those- so we do them to death during pharm- sadly those are the questions i feel the best about- but we dont learn almost anything about neoplastics.
 
Hi Jattdoc. For what percent of the questions regarding path do you really need the picture to answer the question. I have a pretty good path understanding and think I will be fine except for repro which I hate. What's your take?
 
Jattdoc,

Thanks a lot for all that info, its inspiring to hear from someone who just took the test and is reflecting on how/what they studied. I have 2 weeks before I take the exam, so I'm basically in hell right now with all the books and information.


I'm still on pharm now (its been over 6 days!!) and I'm wondering if what im doing is effective. I aced the class during school but forgot a lot of the specifics. Theres no way I have time for lippincott, nor do I recall anything in there. I remember most of the drug names and general concepts, but thats it.
I really try to emphasize cardiovascular and autonomics in terms of understanding. I also go into things like how exactly do B-blockers cause hyperkalemia, why digoxin toxixty is TX'ed with lidocaine or phenytoin. Basically, I'm all about mechanisms of side effects and action. I hate memorizing, and I'm not too good at it unless I understand the mechanisms. It seems like every other drug causes nausea or neutropenia or some other unrelated totally idiosynchratic side effect. Its really driving me crazy, and there are tons of things in 1st Aid I'll never be able to remember.

The most I can do with brute memorization is know the names and generalities of the drugs in 1st AID, the big inhibitors/stimulators of P450, which chemo drugs dont cause BM suppression, who causes disulfuram rxn's, which antibiotics for anearobes in general, Gm- bugs in general, which ones for STD's or UTI's (seems like quinolones or TMP-SMX for almost every UTI), which NMJ blockers are depolarizing or nondepolarizing. How will this hold up for the real deal? Where there a few drugs on the exam which weren't even mentioned in 1st AID?
Once again, thanks for your advice.
 
jattdoc, thanks for the answer. I'm sure you will get a score that you will be very happy with 🙂
 
thanks alot men...great write up. i just finished a 3 hr micromini board this morning .....i jsut imagine how the main one is going to feel like...7hrs.whew.
 
____________

Christiangirl

60-80% of questions with slides could be answered just from the case. For example, I had a case where you had to know the state of mycardial tissue after M.I. The case explained the time frame after M.I and asked about type of cells would be prominent. So for this you can just tell without looking at the slides. On the other hand about 10-20% slides required you to look at the slides (for example Heme Onc - AML / CLL & Kidney Immunoflourecence pattern Linear/Granular etc). So, I would not worry too much about slides (I never even went to any of my path lab). On the last day before the exam, i would just skim over the wheater pathology atlas, nothing major.


____________

1Neuro1

The temptation to read Lippincot Pharm is the voice of the darkside. I also aced pharm, and i also knew the basics and really wanted to read lippincot again. However, if you learned it well, then it will come back to you in review. One thing that you need to understand is that most people go into the test really well prepared and by memorizing a lot ot stuff. However, you need to do questions so that you can get use to recall and applying the knowledge. If you use First Aid & Questions, then you will most likely be able to answer most of the questions. One way to study pharm is to make up a case or when your are doing questions unrelated to pharm, try to think which drug would be effective in managing this patients condition (say on a path question about CHF, or question about pneumonia). This will help cement and integrate the knowledge.
One reassuring fact for me was that there we no drugs that i did not know about. I think that is becaue the pharm department at our school really stays on top of things. But first aid if more than enough. Most of the drugs were the most common faces of the specific class of drugs.

_______

tega

Your right, the test is exhausting, but not impossible. Coupe of time i was getting really frustrated in middle of the block. So I just closed my eyes and took some deep breaths for about 30 seconds and got back into it, and it really helped. I think endurance is one of the things that you really need, because towards the last blocks, your really tired. I found myself making a lot of stupid mistakes. So i slowed down and had to reread a couple of questions.
________

So when is everybody up for their exam?
 
High yield vs. low yield subjects. What courses are in them?? I still have a year before my test, but it'll be nice to keep in mind in the back of my head in case I need to "sacrifice" a topic (I would assume that histo is definately low yield -- god I hated that class -- we had to do glass slides and wasting hours thinking you're looking at something in the microscope that you're reaally not lookin at. I have much bitterness towards this class!). Glass slides should be an elective for those who are really interested in pathology. I am a believer on projection or computer images.
 
Top