First Year MD - Non-trad student

  • Thread starter Thread starter 534455
  • Start date Start date
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
5

534455

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Hello everyone. I am new to SDN.
I am a non-traditional student currently enrolled in a USA accredited MD Program. I am a first year MD student. I also have a blog that might be of help to some of you:

http://roadlesstraveledmd.wordpress.com

My experiences as a first year MD student have been nothing of what I expected. Academics aside, the shock of being with kids in their early 20s to 30 have been painful, depressing and frustrating. When I was a college kid years ago, we never did what I see these future doctors do during class. I have spoken at length with my faculty and school administrators, and they share their own frustrating and depressing stories of how medical students (or grad students in general) are not as mature as they used to be. That is putting it mildly.

Have any other non-traditional MD students had this experience? I study hard, love that I am enrolled in an MD program, and look forward to graduating. I especially look forward to my third and fourth year rotations where I will no longer have to witness what these kids do in class, hear their complaining and whining and overall demonstrate they really have no business being physicians.

I look forward to hearing from some older students in MD programs.

Thanks
 
I focus on the rock stars among my younger classmates. They are not difficult to find.

The growth between M1 and M3 is astounding. At my school I helped with the free clinic when I was in the SMP in 2010. I'm seeing the M1's from that period as M3's, back in clinic, and I cannot believe my eyes. Some are still punks, but for the most part, they are remarkably mature and proficient.

There's no limit to how disappointed I'll be by people, if I choose to spend time being disappointed. There's no beautiful endeavor on the planet unsullied by the frailties of human character. There's nothing you or the faculty or the administration can do to change what the average American 22-30 year old is like, except this: be a good role model. And this: don't make the mistake of thinking they'll listen to you now.

Best of luck to you.
 
Though I'm not in an MD program, I am at the tail end of my post-bacc, so I'm taking 4000 level science classes with all the other hopeful would be doctors of tomorrow. I have very little good to say about what I perceive to be their general overall attitude, worldview, and maturity level.

We have the, "Everyone gets a trophy, I should get extra points just for showing up to class, I really have to get an A in this class even though I don't think I should have to fight and struggle through hard work to get it, I've never been told I was anything but awesome, who are you to tell me that question was dumb and a waste of the classes time, entitled ones".

The, "As soon as lecture starts I surf DailyMail, Facebook, cracked.com and shop until the professor stops talking at the end of lecture. Then I lie, cheat and steal my way to an A in the class somehow, Not really learning anything but somehow still scraping by and getting the grade ones".

The, "This professor is a jerk for making that test so hard so I'm going to create anonymous email addresses and send him hate mail all week until he relents and throws out a question or two on that exam that I thought were unfair. I will also trash him on all the review sites, because ain't no body got time to study hard and suck it up, I'm not ready for reality ones".
 
Dear Patassa,

Your comments are really breathtaking as to what the kids say/write. I am stunned! I am not on Facebook, twitter, do not take my laptop to class to shop, surf, etc, other than edit my PDF documents and powerpoint slides that our professors give us beforehand for class notes. Otherwise, I go to class, take notes, and am the first one out the door....literally. I sit in the front row, talk to no one unless if someone talks to me. I used to be social but I gave that up after a few months into my first year.

The kids? I'm not here to raise them nor do I care to. Sorry, but I'm not getting into debt to do the job of what their parents should have done.

please do one thing:

ignore the naysayers. There are a ton of them, any many from physicians, sadly. Do what is in your heart, do it passionately and you will thank yourself for following your dream....and not someone else's.

I look forward to hearing about your progress.

last words

GO FOR IT!!!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I may be in the minority on this one, but what exactly is "breathtaking" about his comments?

I think we're being a bit self-righteous here don't you think?

Have you ever been in a physicians/staff lounge and see how many of them talk/act when non-health professionals are around?

So a bunch of them multi-task during lectures or seem to have an interest in their social life, should we kick them out?

Lie, cheat and steal??? wow, I respect the hell out of any non-traditional student because I've been there, done that, and I KNOW what it takes...But I'll also say that some of the biggest "*ss kissers" I've ever seen in my life have been 35+ year old non-trads slobbering all over an O-chem professor.

A TON of my med school class seemed incredibly immature during M1 year, myself included I'm sure, but I've watched A LOT of them morph into the makings of some pretty fantastic future physicians. Hell, my friends are some of the most sarcastic, potty-mouthed SOBs you'll ever run into...we'd make construction workers uncomfortable...but I have ZERO reservations in saying that in the coming years these guys will be exceptional docs and future leaders in their respective fields.
 
Dear Patassa,

Your comments are really breathtaking as to what the kids say/write. I am stunned! I am not on Facebook, twitter, do not take my laptop to class to shop, surf, etc, other than edit my PDF documents and powerpoint slides that our professors give us beforehand for class notes. Otherwise, I go to class, take notes, and am the first one out the door....literally. I sit in the front row, talk to no one unless if someone talks to me. I used to be social but I gave that up after a few months into my first year.

The kids? I'm not here to raise them nor do I care to. Sorry, but I'm not getting into debt to do the job of what their parents should have done.

please do one thing:

ignore the naysayers. There are a ton of them, any many from physicians, sadly. Do what is in your heart, do it passionately and you will thank yourself for following your dream....and not someone else's.

I look forward to hearing about your progress.

last words

GO FOR IT!!!

Keep things in perspective - these kids have gone straight from undergrad to med school. You'll find the same thing in any grad school (as opposed to the "real world" where the kids are mixed in with the grown ups). Remember how stupid we all were in college? Do you really expect anything else out of your younger classmates? If you do, then I'm afraid it is you who has to change and readjust your expectations, not so much them.

Also, a bit of advice. I scanned one or two entries in your blog and found the details very, very specific. It will not be long until somebody from your class/school finds the blog and you'll be known as the bad-mouther wierdo sitting in the front row who doesn't talk to anybody else and runs his/her mouth online passive-aggressively, targeting specific students while at the same time *****-kissing proferssors and alluding to personal relationships that involves kicking back and and laughing at other students and their immaturity.....rather than the student with the guts to directly confront his/her peers they have a problem with. You'll be completely utterly miserable M3 and M4 year when you have to work with these people.

So, laugh it off, lower your expecations, and focus on learning. You chose to enter a world filled filled with a mode population age of 22 years. And do talk to your younger peers - not talking to anybody during class is pretty isolating.
 
I may be in the minority on this one, but what exactly is "breathtaking" about his comments?

I think we're being a bit self-righteous here don't you think?

Have you ever been in a physicians/staff lounge and see how many of them talk/act when non-health professionals are around?

So a bunch of them multi-task during lectures or seem to have an interest in their social life, should we kick them out?

Lie, cheat and steal??? wow, I respect the hell out of any non-traditional student because I've been there, done that, and I KNOW what it takes...But I'll also say that some of the biggest "*ss kissers" I've ever seen in my life have been 35+ year old non-trads slobbering all over an O-chem professor.

I don't think one necessarily has to feel superior just because they are capable of observing behavior and attitudes around them. I have my faults, they just look alot different then the 20 year olds I sit next to and they don't have much to do with school.

When a professor has to apologize to the class because he said "Hey everyone, now that we've covered how long term potentiation works, that's the reason I tell you to sleep, because it helps you learn, it's not because I care about your health" something is wrong. He apologized because he received hate mail from students in the class for a week about that comment. I can't even imagine pretending to be offended by this comment, yet apparently the response was so overwhelming he took up lecture time to address it. I can not relate to the mentality of someone who can't handle the idea that this man who is teaching 600 other kids just like me would dare say he doesn't care about me personally.

My genetics professor would address some of the hate mail he got after exams and make sure he let us know he thought whoever was sending them were cowards for making them anonymous. Then he'd show the grade distribution and what would happen to it if he got rid of all the questions that people were saying were "unfair", 80% of the students with As or B's in the class, he would try to explain why that is unacceptable, and he would get hisses and snarls in return.

I'm not sure when it became acceptable to bully and harass professors for your one's personal gain, but when someone gets an A through methods like that that did not earn it, it dilutes my grades and cheapens my achievements. I take issue with that, as I think anyone paying alot of money for their education so that the grades are worth more than the paper they are printed on would.

Are students free to multitask during class? It's a free country, they can do whatever they want. But when the ones doing it are the ones I over hear complaining about the exams, wanting curves or questions thrown out, wasting everyone's time at the professor led review sessions with unrelenting questions because they've never looked at the material before, then their "having an interest in their social life" and "multitasking" ??, just became a problem for the rest of us.
 
Last edited:
Ah yes. The kids of today thing.

The most annoying people in my class are the older ones. It's embarrassing. Much more so than the Internet habits of people, who unlike us, grew up using it to communicate, or that type of thing.

It's not age selection. It's that we're all @ssholes. Performance competitors who have the added hideous tendencies of missionaries and saviors. This is how we're groomed. This is what is rewarded. So we collectively are sort of a pain in the @ss to be around.

I like an odd assortment of my classmates for no other reason than their funny, can hang well, and are interesting. Age has been a random factor.

Try to ask yourself how funny you are. What do I offer some one across the table with a pitcher of beer. If the answer is a lecture. You're not fun.
 
I am a non trad and I find this to be self righteous, self important ramblings of a disgruntled arrogant individual. Do you think you were "all grown up" just out of college. These kids are sacrificing their 20s to become doctors, so if on a rare occasion they want to act their age, let them. Appreciate it for what it is. You say they have no business being physicians, do you realize the MCAT and USMLE have had to increase difficulty every year to maintain their scale? These kids are becoming doctors at a time of great uncertainty with no promise of wealth or a repeat of the golden years of the 70s and 80s. They are facing competition from midlevels with half the sacrifice and are looking at being further restricted but compensated less. They still do outstanding on the USMLE and have found a way to do it without attending lecture. Yes they are often immature and still learning, but that is what it means to be 21,22, etc. You had your chance to grow up, give them theirs. To say they have no business being physicians is self important back patting. They embrace older students like us, the least you can do is respect them for the place in life they are. There are many things that could be said about non trads too.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using SDN Mobile
 
It could be said that if you were so mature at 22 why didn't you pick medicine OP? Why waste valuable tax payer dollars on lost years of service for your government subsidized training?

Sent from my SCH-I535 using SDN Mobile
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
OP, what you've observed is probably accurate and true. However what you've said is "intolerant" and politically incorrect, you will continue to be skewered here for pointing out what is obvious to you from observation and through experience. People will defend actions they've never seen nor heard in order to appear morally superior and condemn you for self righteousness, out of their own self righteousness. This is the sad state of affairs that we live in, and part of the reason the generation you're speaking about acts the way they do, they were raised within this ideology.

Make whatever efforts you can to remain anonymous. Good luck.
 
Except that I am from an older generation, I was with him until he threw out the "they have no business being physicians" judgement. I am often frustrated because I don't remember being the same way, but then I am often reminded of some of the dumb decisions my 22 year old self made. These students have to transition to adulthood in the bubble of grad school, I didn't. I had to grow up fast, get a job, but I also got to enjoy my early 20s in ways they never will.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using SDN Mobile
 
I focus on the rock stars among my younger classmates. They are not difficult to find.

The growth between M1 and M3 is astounding. At my school I helped with the free clinic when I was in the SMP in 2010. I'm seeing the M1's from that period as M3's, back in clinic, and I cannot believe my eyes. Some are still punks, but for the most part, they are remarkably mature and proficient.

There's no limit to how disappointed I'll be by people, if I choose to spend time being disappointed. There's no beautiful endeavor on the planet unsullied by the frailties of human character. There's nothing you or the faculty or the administration can do to change what the average American 22-30 year old is like, except this: be a good role model. And this: don't make the mistake of thinking they'll listen to you now.

Best of luck to you.


From what I have read Dr. Midlife, you are not a parent, but from my experience, you sure sound like one. That was eloquent and very true. 👍
 
OP, what you've observed is probably accurate and true. However what you've said is "intolerant" and politically incorrect, you will continue to be skewered here for pointing out what is obvious to you from observation and through experience. People will defend actions they've never seen nor heard in order to appear morally superior and condemn you for self righteousness, out of their own self righteousness. This is the sad state of affairs that we live in, and part of the reason the generation you're speaking about acts the way they do, they were raised within this ideology.

Make whatever efforts you can to remain anonymous. Good luck.

Front row note scribbling screeder and his new fan...realize something: you're not funny and nobody will like you unless you lighten up. Knowing a thing or two is just that. Knowing how to use it effectively and to harmonize with various constituencies is sophistication. Something I've seen in old and young.

The most impressive person I've seen to date was a 4 year old boy who remained calmly in the lotus position while I gave him five shots. When I was done. I bowed to him silently in earnest. Moved almost to tears. Realizing I was in the presence of someone special.

We're not morally superior. Your just no fun. And it's more fun to be me. Drinking and laughing with my 20 something buddies after exams.
 
Except that I am from an older generation, I was with him until he threw out the "they have no business being physicians" judgement. I am often frustrated because I don't remember being the same way, but then I am often reminded of some of the dumb decisions my 22 year old self made. These students have to transition to adulthood in the bubble of grad school, I didn't. I had to grow up fast, get a job, but I also got to enjoy my early 20s in ways they never will.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using SDN Mobile

It sounds like an opinion born out of frustration that will have no real bearing on the future of his/her classmates. So the OP is blowing off some steam and looking for similar feelings, big deal.
 
Front row note scribbling screeder and his new fan...realize something: you're not funny and nobody will like you unless you lighten up. Knowing a thing or two is just that. Knowing how to use it effectively and to harmonize with various constituencies is sophistication. Something I've seen in old and young.

The most impressive person I've seen to date was a 4 year old boy who remained calmly in the lotus position while I gave him five shots. When I was done. I bowed to him silently in earnest. Moved almost to tears. Realizing I was in the presence of someone special.

We're not morally superior. Your just no fun. And it's more fun to be me. Drinking and laughing with my 20 something buddies after exams.

Take your self seriously, that's more than you ll get from me. Now was it be funny or be fun? In your incoherent self important pseudo philosophical nonsense rants you seem to have gotten your wires crossed.
 
Take your self seriously, that's more than you ll get from me. Now was it be funny or be fun? In your incoherent self important pseudo philosophical nonsense rants you seem to have gotten your wires crossed.

Haha. Witless whiner...that was my point. To not take yourself so seriously. You do that and you start getting comfortable as judge of others.
 
Hello everyone. I am new to SDN.
I am a non-traditional student currently enrolled in a USA accredited MD Program. I am a first year MD student. I also have a blog that might be of help to some of you:

http://roadlesstraveledmd.wordpress.com

--My First Breast Exam
Posted on February 22, 2013 by roadlesstraveledmd
It was a big deal. Four of us medical students were huddled in a room in the clinic with our professor-physician, all of us wearing our white coats and stethoscopes. The standardized patient arrived in the room prior to us and she was waiting. The air was thick with tension but excitement.

Part of the problem with doing breast exam procedures is that there is a great deal of pressure, awkwardness, proper vs. improper methods on how to approach the patient and eventually grab her boobs. It does not stop there. We also have to squeeze the breast to see if there is any discharge coming from the nipple. Both sides. We were all on heightened alert, and no one wanted to botch this lesson.

There was, as expected, a lot of nervous chatter. The medical students are all very young. I doubt some of the guys had even felt a woman’s breast for longer than a sexual exploit, so I eyed them carefully to see how they would respond to their moment with their breast in hand. Surprisingly, it was the female student in my group who was the most inappropriate.

The patient was in her mid 50s, in shape, good disposition and wore her athletic bra in preparation for teaching us students. Our physician professor was amazing, as always. He seems to know what to say each time we gather as a group of students in front of a patient. He is not phased by the two extremes in the group: patient vs. young kids studying to be doctors. He serves as a great bridge.

Our professor approached the patient calmly, professionally, with decorum and frequently asked her questions before doing anything. He was, as we say in sales, getting a “buy-in”. That is, the patient had to “buy-in” to what the physician was about to do before he could even perform it. We referred to our textbook as our unseen chaperon: Bates Guide to Physical Examination and History Taking, a primer in medical student education. In no short order, we all were taking turns on how to appropriately, professionally and clinically examine a woman’s breast to look for signs of breast cancer. It was a very impressive exercise. I’ve had a few breasts in my hands as a non-traditional medical student, but this one visit was really neat. There was no hot and heavy breathing, no sexual penumbra and definitely not excitatory. It went really well...--

🙄 Lol

And you're concerned about your younger classmates acting inappropriate??
 
Haha. Witless whiner...that was my point. To not take yourself so seriously. You do that and you start getting comfortable as judge of others.

Name calling?
Please enlighten us more while using the devastating tactic found between 5 year olds on school yards across the world. Yes yes, let's be fun, funny, and call people names. Who wouldnt take their cues from you.
 
Last edited:
Name calling?
Please enlighten us more while using the devastating tactic found between 5 year olds on school yards across the world. Yes yes, let's be fun, funny, and call people names. Who would take their cues from you.

Actually if you really wanna get somebody good try going elementary school on them. Their insults are fresh, instinctual and kind of right brained in approach.

I like to yell out of my car window at idiots in traffic like ... You are poop in the head. And you smell funny!!! Whatever comes to mind without thinking. Try it. You might like it.

Call me a good name. I like the exchange we're having.

I think it's necessary. Because a lot of us have had adaptation trouble including myself. In my case is wasn't related to age. But the idea of relaxing, grooving, and having a good time of it has never failed to be good self-advice for me.

The OP is free to make scathing commentary. I'm all for it. But the age superiority thing is just not realistic in my opinion. And misses entirely the real suckage this thing does on our personalities and dispositions.

Come at me stanky!
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Additionally. "Maturity" is one of those loaded terms like "professionalism." Depends most on who's using it and for what purpose because it has little meaning outside of that. Except to note that I have gray beard hair. Or something. It can also be a euphemism for some fat unf@ckable specimen of a certain age. Or I can say she....was....mature. And everybody knows I went cougar hunting. Or one of my favs: the desperate haymaker of p@ssy mind control--"you need to grow up, you need to be a man, you need to get it together and be mature." These things lack irony and recognition of alternate possible meanings. Such as he likes not being tied down and while he enjoys you sexually, settling down and becoming domesticated is not going to happen with you. And so on.

Not once does the OP allow for a curmudgeonly crack of irony. And therefore is to be laughed at until such a point in time as can be laughed with.
 
As a non-trad myself, I'm struggling to wonder why anyone would care what students were doing on their laptops during class? How does a student on facebook/reddit/whatever affect your learning from the lecture?

Seems pretty petty to me.
 
I am not much of a poster/online social network kind of person. I am a published writer and have written for a few decades, an outlet of my self-expression. I had forgotten how kids use the internet to flame, lambast, write things behind computer screens that they would never say in public, much less to someone else's face. So I am not surprised by the comments by some here. I had to think about what "OP" meant, and then it hit me: original poster? LOL. Kids crack me up today. Communication is non-existent, other than abbreviations, shorthand and anything that will "save" them investing in others. I have three children (in their 20s) and they are nothing like the kids in class today. They are my pride and joy. They are amazing kids, helping in the family as a group. I just don't see kids like that today - everything is "on my own terms"....

Yes, some in my class are "rock stars" like one poster wrote. So true. I like that poster's perspective: "focus on the rock stars". Touche. You got me there and I will do so. Thanks for that one.

I was hoping to hear from the 40+ year olds, which would limit the above comments to 3 of us. As long as society continues to produce a cadre of young individuals who show disregard for others, then inappropriate, selfish, narcissistic behaviors will continue to manifest itself as witnessed on internet venues, including this thread.

These are the kids who lack interpersonal skills, don't have social graces in how to act with groups, are all about them and will implode in their third year and fourth year rotations when they hit the hospital floors. They are the type that will complain that an attending, resident, nurse "insulted" them or were "mean" to them b/c they did not know how to act in social circles. Heck, they are already complaining today by lambasting the poor professors with hateful emails as to how "unfair" questions were, and they up the ante on their Facebook page for our class to bully the professors to throw out questions from the exams.

I AM ASTOUNDED PEOPLE WOULD DO THIS!!!

yes, I know some of you will defend this deplorable behavior. This is the internet. It is expected you would defend the indefensible.
I would venture to say that personality disorders are increasing in society b/c people are not learning how to interact, opting instead of have "online friendships" (oxymoron).

I'd like to hear from the adults (those over 40), not those focused on priorities like being "fun", "cool", or focused on "winning friends"
Thankfully I outgrew that insecure phase.

Thanks also to the others who made comments that were instructive I do hope these kids evolve from 1/2 year to 3/4 years. Is is that impactful? Do they really mature that much? What gives? I am open for discussion on this.

One salient point not missed by one PM: to ignore the kids, and not try to change them. They will be who they are, and I should not try to help them.

Right on
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As a non-trad myself, I'm struggling to wonder why anyone would care what students were doing on their laptops during class? How does a student on facebook/reddit/whatever affect your learning from the lecture?

Seems pretty petty to me.

If you get accepted to medical school, since you are now pre-med and much younger, you will learn that you will be sitting on the edge of your seat in class to listen, learn, try to understand what was said in class, and walk out with your head low. Lectures are 2 hours long, we often forgo breaks so that the professor can cover the material, which isn't all of the material of course. Class lectures are only a quick summary of the textbook readings. Lectures are priceless. Some will opt to skip them. For those lectures not worth skipping, kids giggling, asking questions on material they missed 5 minutes prior b/c they were shopping online are a definite drag.

One professor said it best. When he went to medical school, these behaviors would not have been tolerated. The kids would have been thrown out of class.

I don't understand why they allow them in class now.

Off to study today. I don't have time to raise a class of kids, nor educate them (nor online users).

Cheers
 
---deleted for bandwidth.

JourneyAgent....you are an MD Student? You joined SDN in November 2012 and you already have 212 posts on this forum?
You posted at least 5 times to this one thread in less than 6 hours. No wonder you have 245 posts in less than 5 months!!!

An MD Student does not have time for these types of forums. No way. Unless if you have zero friends in real life which would explain alot.

Get out and interact with your neighbors, make friends on the street, develop your interpersonal skills and.....

who am I kidding!! LOL

Cheers :laugh:
 
JourneyAgent....you are an MD Student? You joined SDN in November 2012 and you already have 212 posts on this forum?
You posted at least 5 times to this one thread in less than 6 hours. No wonder you have 245 posts in less than 5 months!!!

An MD Student does not have time for these types of forums. No way. Unless if you have zero friends in real life which would explain alot.

Get out and interact with your neighbors, make friends on the street, develop your interpersonal skills and.....

who am I kidding!! LOL

Cheers :laugh:

It's a strange habit to engage here as often as I do. But I enjoy it at times. I don't do other social media so this is the extent of my online interaction. I agree with you that the Internet creates a scenario where people would say things they wouldn't face to face. I suppose if we were face to face I might be a little less harsh. But the message would be the same: these young people are your cohort. You will rely on each other and do work together all through your training. All the long years of it. If you think they won't be able to pick up on your vibe of feeling superior to them think again.

Med school involves a lot of communications and trust me they will know stuff before you do. And they will happily keep you up to speed on what's going on at school if you are friendly with them.

If you think I care too much about being "cool" for them your onservational skill fails you. I do care very much about my own vibe. Which is hella cool. And how I work it for me. And the way it feels being me grooving with other human units is my main priority unless I get distracted and f@ck up. Then I pick myself back up and try again. More cool this time. Don't take it so serious. Only here for some moments. Enjoy them.

There is a humorous stance to being out of step with your surroundings that can endear both yourself to circumstance and it and they that inhabit them to you.

Your kids might be cool in comparison because they're not medical students. But "the youth of today" argument is as stupid as it ever was.
 
I'm trying to figure out how, or even if, I want to respond to this. I'm always a little suspicious when new posters show up to bolster another poster...

OP, there's a phenomenon called confirmation bias that seems to be playing a pretty large role here. When you expect to see certain things and are on the lookout for them, you'll find evidence to support your original conclusion everywhere, and completely miss any or most evidence to the contrary. This is an important phenomenon because it's also a very common cause of diagnostic errors in medicine.

It's perfectly possible that you have such a terrible group of classmates, but the fact that you come on here and want to immediately restrict the discussion to those 40 and over because you don't seem to feel anyone under that is mature enough to engage in this discussion with you tells me that you've already got your mind made up about the younger generation. All of them, despite the fact that any reasonable person will agree with the idea that there are some really mature 22 year olds and really immature 40+ year olds. You have some much more mature medical students on here describing different experiences than yours and disagreeing with you and you don't like it.

My experiences with younger crowds have been completely different. I work a full-time professional job at a hospital with people ranging from early 20's to 60's. My younger colleagues have tended to be the more hard working and professional one's in the bunch. They've been team oriented, dedicated to patients, and willing to go above and beyond to get stuff done. The worst behavior where I am tends to come from some of the older folks who've been there forever. There seems to be a lot of burnout at play there.

In my graduate program the majority of the students are in their early 20's. I have seen a some of the email, web surfing, etc during lecture that I think is kind of lame. But if they aren't disrupting me I don't care too much. They are the one paying major money for a class they aren't making the most of. Overall though, I've again been pretty impressed with this bunch. Yes they act young, and yes I can't relate sometimes.

I'm in public health and it's a very collaborative and hard working crew. I'm classmates with people going to school full-time, working on their master's projects, and starting a non-profit all at the same time. Yeah, some of them party hard and act young sometimes, but when the situation calls for it they adjust very fast. In fact I've noticed some of the students doing the more challenging stuff tend to be the one's a little who get a bit wilder blowing off steam. But at the free clinic we run, people step up. Some people get a bit shy, some who drop the F bomb every other word in the break room turn out to speak very kindly and politely while taking a history.

That's not to say I haven't seen entitled behavior, cheating, or any of the other stuff, too. Just not anywhere near the degree you're describing it. I really have to wonder if the reason you're seeing it so much is that you're so focused on it to begin with that you miss the counterpoints to balance out your perspective.


*** Feel free to come on here and vent, by all means. But do yourself and your classmates a favor: Instead of walking into lecture expecting or dreading all the inappropriate behavior and thus priming yourself to see it everywhere, even in little things set out with the goal of finding two strengths in everyone. Maybe that guy cruising all over the place on the computer screen multitasking during lecture is a computer whiz who also happens to be setting up a note/study guide database for his group and has experience doing online health promotion stuff. You've already counted him out, but you haven't gotten to know more about him than what you see in class, so who knows?
 
Hello everyone. I am new to SDN.
I am a non-traditional student currently enrolled in a USA accredited MD Program. I am a first year MD student. I also have a blog that might be of help to some of you:

http://roadlesstraveledmd.wordpress.com

My experiences as a first year MD student have been nothing of what I expected. Academics aside, the shock of being with kids in their early 20s to 30 have been painful, depressing and frustrating.

Have any other non-traditional MD students had this experience? I study hard, love that I am enrolled in an MD program, and look forward to graduating. I especially look forward to my third and fourth year rotations where I will no longer have to witness what these kids do in class, hear their complaining and whining and overall demonstrate they really have no business being physicians.

I am sorry your experience has not been what you had anticipated.

Whatever you think of your classmates, keep in mind dealing with difficult people is a necessary skill for any medical professional. Your success in many situations will be dependent upon your ability to perform regardless of the behavior of your peers. Think of this as practice for dealing with your future "difficult" patients. They are the reason we are all doing this in the first place, right?

FWIW, some of the most immature moments of my adult life have been when I've made assumptions of others based on experiences with a select few. That behavior is disgraceful and will only hold you back in this profession.
 
I thought older people worried less about what others were doing and more about achieving their own goals.
 
I'm sorry, but roadless traveled you sound even more arrogant than before. Do you not remember the 20 somethings of the 70s? Each generation has their own way of expressing their personality as they transition into adulthood, this one may be different, but that still does not make them unfit to be physicians. That is what really jumped out at me as ageism and judgemental. Different isn't worse, as a mature and cultured adult you should realize this. I'm sure many of your concerns are legitimate and belong in a respectful discourse, but to lambast a generation from behind the lofty stroke of your keypad is disingenuous. You claim this generation only knows how to "flame" and "assault" yet you started a thread dedicated to judgmental ramblings, so how are you better?
P. S.
Every generation feels the same way about the next generation, there is nothing new in this sentiment. Also, just to clarify, I don't doubt many of your observations are likely accurate. I just believe that these growing pains are normal for students who have never done anything else except live as full time students. You could probably learn to reinvigorate some youthful bliss into your life from them, while they could hopefully learn some maturity from you. This is the give and take I have developed with my future colleagues.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using SDN Mobile
 
Last edited:
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I am not much of a poster/online social network kind of person. I am a published writer and have written for a few decades, an outlet of my self-expression. I had forgotten how kids use the internet to flame, lambast, write things behind computer screens that they would never say in public, much less to someone else's face. So I am not surprised by the comments by some here. I had to think about what "OP" meant, and then it hit me: original poster? LOL. Kids crack me up today. Communication is non-existent, other than abbreviations, shorthand and anything that will "save" them investing in others. I have three children (in their 20s) and they are nothing like the kids in class today. They are my pride and joy. They are amazing kids, helping in the family as a group. I just don't see kids like that today - everything is "on my own terms"....

Yes, some in my class are "rock stars" like one poster wrote. So true. I like that poster's perspective: "focus on the rock stars". Touche. You got me there and I will do so. Thanks for that one.

I was hoping to hear from the 40+ year olds, which would limit the above comments to 3 of us. As long as society continues to produce a cadre of young individuals who show disregard for others, then inappropriate, selfish, narcissistic behaviors will continue to manifest itself as witnessed on internet venues, including this thread.

These are the kids who lack interpersonal skills, don't have social graces in how to act with groups, are all about them and will implode in their third year and fourth year rotations when they hit the hospital floors. They are the type that will complain that an attending, resident, nurse "insulted" them or were "mean" to them b/c they did not know how to act in social circles. Heck, they are already complaining today by lambasting the poor professors with hateful emails as to how "unfair" questions were, and they up the ante on their Facebook page for our class to bully the professors to throw out questions from the exams.

I AM ASTOUNDED PEOPLE WOULD DO THIS!!!

yes, I know some of you will defend this deplorable behavior. This is the internet. It is expected you would defend the indefensible.
I would venture to say that personality disorders are increasing in society b/c people are not learning how to interact, opting instead of have "online friendships" (oxymoron).

I'd like to hear from the adults (those over 40), not those focused on priorities like being "fun", "cool", or focused on "winning friends"
Thankfully I outgrew that insecure phase.

Thanks also to the others who made comments that were instructive I do hope these kids evolve from 1/2 year to 3/4 years. Is is that impactful? Do they really mature that much? What gives? I am open for discussion on this.

One salient point not missed by one PM: to ignore the kids, and not try to change them. They will be who they are, and I should not try to help them.

Right on

Stop calling adult college graduates "kids." It's obvious that you mean it to be pejorative. Adults, according to you, are those over 40. The dissonance here is delicious, as you accuse younger people of not being sufficiently mature, while at the same time explicitly infantilizing those up to age 39.

I'm considerably older than my classmates, and I'll gladly take their occasional naivete and lack of professional polish over this kind of pretentious, affected world-weariness.

Also, you got totally pwned (more lingo to google!) by alpinism, quoting your own torpid, juvenile writing, which you came here to promote.
 
I am not much of a poster/online social network kind of person. I am a published writer and have written for a few decades, an outlet of my self-expression. I had forgotten how kids use the internet to flame, lambast, write things behind computer screens that they would never say in public, much less to someone else's face. So I am not surprised by the comments by some here. I had to think about what "OP" meant, and then it hit me: original poster? LOL. Kids crack me up today. Communication is non-existent, other than abbreviations, shorthand and anything that will "save" them investing in others. I have three children (in their 20s) and they are nothing like the kids in class today. They are my pride and joy. They are amazing kids, helping in the family as a group. I just don't see kids like that today - everything is "on my own terms"....

Yes, some in my class are "rock stars" like one poster wrote. So true. I like that poster's perspective: "focus on the rock stars". Touche. You got me there and I will do so. Thanks for that one.

I was hoping to hear from the 40+ year olds, which would limit the above comments to 3 of us. As long as society continues to produce a cadre of young individuals who show disregard for others, then inappropriate, selfish, narcissistic behaviors will continue to manifest itself as witnessed on internet venues, including this thread.

These are the kids who lack interpersonal skills, don't have social graces in how to act with groups, are all about them and will implode in their third year and fourth year rotations when they hit the hospital floors. They are the type that will complain that an attending, resident, nurse "insulted" them or were "mean" to them b/c they did not know how to act in social circles. Heck, they are already complaining today by lambasting the poor professors with hateful emails as to how "unfair" questions were, and they up the ante on their Facebook page for our class to bully the professors to throw out questions from the exams.

I AM ASTOUNDED PEOPLE WOULD DO THIS!!!

yes, I know some of you will defend this deplorable behavior. This is the internet. It is expected you would defend the indefensible.
I would venture to say that personality disorders are increasing in society b/c people are not learning how to interact, opting instead of have "online friendships" (oxymoron).

I'd like to hear from the adults (those over 40), not those focused on priorities like being "fun", "cool", or focused on "winning friends"
Thankfully I outgrew that insecure phase.

Thanks also to the others who made comments that were instructive I do hope these kids evolve from 1/2 year to 3/4 years. Is is that impactful? Do they really mature that much? What gives? I am open for discussion on this.

One salient point not missed by one PM: to ignore the kids, and not try to change them. They will be who they are, and I should not try to help them.

Right on



I'm not defending the behavior. I just don't care. If no one is getting hurt, I can't give it much attention. If they want to maybe miss something important, it's on them. I can't control other people. I think that is the point others are saying.

Regardless of age or whatever else, the ones that are focused are the content/work are the ones to include in your circle, so to speak. I would be courteous to others that don't seem to care, but they aren't getting my time any energy.

And maybe a few just need to take a stress break. I mean, if they are getting the material, what difference does it make? If it's distracting to you, move away from it.

I teach on a part-time basis. I don't get my panties twisted if a student texts or isn't with the program. Now if the majority are disinterested, I would take that as something I am doing wrong. Most aren't and are involved in the material, and I get really good feedback. So, if the other person is out in left field, he or she paid their money. As long as they aren't disturbing anyone else, if they want to tune out temporarily, or if the do this regularly and want to waste their time and money, it's on them.
 
Last edited:
Some of this is true, but also understand it's NOT your job or concern to care about the younger students. Cuz guess what?? There isn't some "oasis" just cuz you get thru basic sciences. Guess who you work w/ when you are in the hospital?? These same students.

So keep your head down and study and do you. Who cares? If it bothers you then you might not have enough to do studying wise LOL (kidding).

It's difficult being the odd-man (or woman) out, but at the same time, it is a little lofty to expect traditional students to be so "mature" or behave like physicians. As some people have pointed out. My 35 year old self would totally find my 23 year old self kind of a boisterous douchey guy too. I sit, embarrassed at a retrospective assessment of where I was and where I am now.

Again, tho it's not your job to give two pieces of feces over how your fellow younger classmates behave. It's NOT part of being a non-trad's place to be the "behavior police". You know what you actual job is??? Is to beat these kids on exams. In lab. On the Step. Residency. It's not your job to whip them into shape. Cuz I was too busy in basic sciences to care.

You never know. You might be in a position I was recently during OB. My preceptor told me and a younger med student to suture up trocar defects. The younger student hesitated and politely refused. So my doc said, "Well if you were paying any attention like him, you would be suturing right now. Show her what to do!"

Lead by example. Nothing else. Good luck!
 
OP, I was disappointed in how immature some of my trad classmates were when I was a preclinical student, too. But instead of feeling contempt for my younger classmates, I saw myself as a role model for them, and that became a self-fulfilling prophecy.

When I was a freshman, one of my "entitled" trad classmates spent five minutes at the beginning of a PBL session complaining about how his humanities in medicine small group facilitator had sent a nasty email to him and the rest of his group (cc'ed to the student dean) because seven of the eight of them hadn't shown up for group session. I looked him in the eye and said, "You were wrong, and you and your group members owe your facilitator an apology, because you would be angry too if you took a morning off from your clinic to try to teach a group of medical students who disrespected you to the point of not showing up." I expected him to dismiss me or defend himself, but he didn't do either. Instead, he sheepishly said, "Yeah, you're right. Sorry I wasted some of our PBL time." I just about had to pick my jaw up off the floor. And that's how I discovered that I can challenge my juniors to live up to my expectations just as easily as I can expect them to live down to my expectations.

What it comes down to is this: after the preclinical years of med school, it's not enough for you to just be out for yourself. Regardless of your age, when you're a physician, your job requires you to be a team leader. But you are a team leader who is part of many teams, where sometimes your leadership is actually following someone else's lead, and guiding others to do the same. No, you don't have to parent your classmates, and they would resent any such effort on your part anyway. But all of us can use an older brother/sister to show us the ropes when the primary goal of some of our "elders" seems to be to pound us into the ground. You're hopefully going to develop into that person in a few short years anyway. Why not start now?
 
OP, I was disappointed in how immature some of my trad classmates were when I was a preclinical student, too. But instead of feeling contempt for my younger classmates, I saw myself as a role model for them, and that became a self-fulfilling prophecy.

I would understand if OP were just complaining about the trads. Hell, I probably will too (although not publicly to the extent that OP does as that will probably just come to bite her in the a**), but lumping anyone under 40 as a "kid" and unworthy to comment on her blog is just absurd.

OP, here's a word of advice from a "kid" who has served this country for 5 years in two war zones, stop worrying about what your classmates are doing and just focus on yourself and your studies. Be tolerant of their failings (while recognizing that you probably have some too) and lead by example, not by words (especially anonymous ones). That would be the "mature" attitude.
 
It's a strange habit to engage here as often as I do. But I enjoy it at times. I don't do other social media so this is the extent of my online interaction. I agree with you that the Internet creates a scenario where people would say things they wouldn't face to face. I suppose if we were face to face I might be a little less harsh. But the message would be the same: these young people are your cohort. You will rely on each other and do work together all through your training. All the long years of it. If you think they won't be able to pick up on your vibe of feeling superior to them think again.

Med school involves a lot of communications and trust me they will know stuff before you do. And they will happily keep you up to speed on what's going on at school if you are friendly with them.

If you think I care too much about being "cool" for them your onservational skill fails you. I do care very much about my own vibe. Which is hella cool. And how I work it for me. And the way it feels being me grooving with other human units is my main priority unless I get distracted and f@ck up. Then I pick myself back up and try again. More cool this time. Don't take it so serious. Only here for some moments. Enjoy them.

There is a humorous stance to being out of step with your surroundings that can endear both yourself to circumstance and it and they that inhabit them to you.

Your kids might be cool in comparison because they're not medical students. But "the youth of today" argument is as stupid as it ever was.


i agree with this.
it's weird to see the post college angst sort showing up, then gets resolved in my straight to med school classmates and remember how that went for me may be 5 years ago.

it's nice sometimes i can offer some comfort as someone who still remember what it's like since it's not like 20+ years ago for me.
 
I'm trying to figure out how, or even if, I want to respond to this. I'm always a little suspicious when new posters show up to bolster another poster...

OP, there's a phenomenon called confirmation bias that seems to be playing a pretty large role here. When you expect to see certain things and are on the lookout for them, you'll find evidence to support your original conclusion everywhere, and completely miss any or most evidence to the contrary. This is an important phenomenon because it's also a very common cause of diagnostic errors in medicine.

It's perfectly possible that you have such a terrible group of classmates, but the fact that you come on here and want to immediately restrict the discussion to those 40 and over because you don't seem to feel anyone under that is mature enough to engage in this discussion with you tells me that you've already got your mind made up about the younger generation. All of them, despite the fact that any reasonable person will agree with the idea that there are some really mature 22 year olds and really immature 40+ year olds. You have some much more mature medical students on here describing different experiences than yours and disagreeing with you and you don't like it.

My experiences with younger crowds have been completely different. I work a full-time professional job at a hospital with people ranging from early 20's to 60's. My younger colleagues have tended to be the more hard working and professional one's in the bunch. They've been team oriented, dedicated to patients, and willing to go above and beyond to get stuff done. The worst behavior where I am tends to come from some of the older folks who've been there forever. There seems to be a lot of burnout at play there.

In my graduate program the majority of the students are in their early 20's. I have seen a some of the email, web surfing, etc during lecture that I think is kind of lame. But if they aren't disrupting me I don't care too much. They are the one paying major money for a class they aren't making the most of. Overall though, I've again been pretty impressed with this bunch. Yes they act young, and yes I can't relate sometimes.

I'm in public health and it's a very collaborative and hard working crew. I'm classmates with people going to school full-time, working on their master's projects, and starting a non-profit all at the same time. Yeah, some of them party hard and act young sometimes, but when the situation calls for it they adjust very fast. In fact I've noticed some of the students doing the more challenging stuff tend to be the one's a little who get a bit wilder blowing off steam. But at the free clinic we run, people step up. Some people get a bit shy, some who drop the F bomb every other word in the break room turn out to speak very kindly and politely while taking a history.

That's not to say I haven't seen entitled behavior, cheating, or any of the other stuff, too. Just not anywhere near the degree you're describing it. I really have to wonder if the reason you're seeing it so much is that you're so focused on it to begin with that you miss the counterpoints to balance out your perspective.


*** Feel free to come on here and vent, by all means. But do yourself and your classmates a favor: Instead of walking into lecture expecting or dreading all the inappropriate behavior and thus priming yourself to see it everywhere, even in little things set out with the goal of finding two strengths in everyone. Maybe that guy cruising all over the place on the computer screen multitasking during lecture is a computer whiz who also happens to be setting up a note/study guide database for his group and has experience doing online health promotion stuff. You've already counted him out, but you haven't gotten to know more about him than what you see in class, so who knows?

This has been an interesting discussion and I'm surprised that it has escalated into some name-bashing, which I don't really expect in a nontrad forum. Anyhow, nice response Wholeheartedly.

OP, I hope that your view of your classmates will change eventually and I look forward to reading more about your experiences in med school. Thanks for sharing.
 
OP, I was disappointed in how immature some of my trad classmates were when I was a preclinical student, too. But instead of feeling contempt for my younger classmates, I saw myself as a role model for them, and that became a self-fulfilling prophecy. .......
[....]]

No, you don't have to parent your classmates, and they would resent any such effort on your part anyway. But all of us can use an older brother/sister to show us the ropes when the primary goal of some of our "elders" seems to be to pound us into the ground. You're hopefully going to develop into that person in a few short years anyway. Why not start now?

Touche. I appreciate your comment.

I like what St. Francis of Assisi is reportedly to have said: "preach often, use words seldom", or something like that. I was never fond of religious evangelicals pursuing people with their sacred texts and hitting them over the head like using a 2 X 4.

Behavior goes a long way in preaching a great message, words less so.

As I wrote earlier, I keep quiet in my school. I slip in to class, then slip out. I do not party on weekends, do not drink to excess, do not go to the bars (I miss my family a great deal), and don't even go to restaurants. My goal is to earn my MD and get the heck out of here.

During class group exercises, I speak when spoken to. When the group gets stuck, then I jump in and lead. We recently had to do the Glucose Tolerance Test lab. One poor girl volunteered to be the guinea pig after fasting the previous night. She weighs less than 100 lbs. The professor asked me to show the group how to do a glucose screening, but I said, "no, I want them to learn with each other. I will watch"

And I did

After watching two students stick the poor petite subject three times with a lancet, and watching her wince, with no water coming out of her finger, I stepped in. I spoke, grabbed her hand and the lancet, showed them quickly, and soon the next finger stick produced enough blood for a glucose monitoring. I told the kids as they were sticking the poor finger of the subject, "remember, milk the cow". they got it. It worked.

Same goes for our first semester doing History and Physicals with a patient. Again, I was part of a small group, and I decided to go last. I wanted the kids to experience an H&P without my meddling, and let them figure it out with our physician/professor monitoring.

I felt badly for the kids, and not so badly for the patient. They knew ( the patients) they had medical students on their hands so they had been warned. The MD students, though, were a wreck. They were nervous, one's hand shook as she shook the patient's hand. Another poor kid trembled in his lip as he attempted to speak to the patient. Poor thing. On another occasion, when it came for auscultation and palpitation, again, the kids were a wreck. Each time I went last. When I was up to bat for the H&P, I grabbed the patient's hand, greeted her warmly, smiled, looked in her eyes, told her how beautiful she was, and soon we were laughing. I hadn't even started the History portion yet. I love people. I am a people person. But I am learning I am not friendly towards entitlement attitude kids. What do they go by these days, anyways, this generation? I lost track of the Alphabet. X Gen? Y? Let me guess: "Double Zero"? just kidding.

When I was 23, I was working two jobs, and busting my back like my life depended on it b/c it did. Things are so different today. I respected adults, I kept quiet, and did my job to the best of my ability b/c I wanted to get ahead.

Today, the kids just complain, like today during a group project. I ended up doing the work just to shut them up and get them out of the library where we gathered.

I wish I had time to read all of the posts. I told my friends back at home that I had to stop reading the news online b/c it wasn't helping me earn my MD. I have no TV. And my computer is for studying. As it is, I suspect SDN will take up more time than I should give it, like with this very post. I may pull the plug on this forum for my account for now.

As many of the first and second year MD/DO/DMD/DDS/PharmD/DVM, etc students know, the basic medical sciences tenure of our programs are unforgiving. It cares not whether you can keep up b/c in the end, it wins and you lose. Pretty humbling.

If you are a non-trad older student, and you think you have it made b/c of your maturity or professional background in and out of medicine, think again. It will be humbling. It will be frustrating. It will knock you over relentlessly and not in a good way.

As a newcomer to online forums, I am flattered at all of the attention. I read only the responses by MD students (and MD graduates) and at that I just skimmed 3 or 4.

Today I put to practice what one person told me via PM: "look for the rock stars" or something like that. I found some. It made me laugh when I looked at it that way. There are quite a few older/non-trad students in MD schools, and our feelings are pretty universal. We understand why medical schools don't want us - the transition is incredibly difficult. It is painful. Very.

The studies are tough, but that really isn't the reason for our aches and pains. As someone pointed out to me, it's the incompetency, the immaturity, the lack of professionalism, the entitlement and, yes, the several students who get in who shouldn't. This is not the way we lived our adult lives, nor in the careers we had. Professionalism was rewarded, and chaff was sloffed off.

One such kid today as usual walked in 1+ hours late into our 2 hour class, uses the front door and distracts everyone and makes the professor stop, prances (waddles, really, he's morbidly obese) in front of the entire class, walking right between the professor and the auditorium seats, to sit his fat ass in a seat in the front row. and then played on his iPad near me. This kid is oblivious to hard work or sacrifice, respect or appreciation of others time and investment. Mommy and Daddy are both doctors, make a 7 figure income, he drives to school in a new sports car practically every other month, and he is failing classes . I sure hope the educational system has a "checks and balances" weigh station for people like him . He's the kind of doctor who will get arrested for Medicare Fraud, bilking his patients or being an otherwise physician scumbag that we see and read about in the news.

You do know there are unscrupulous doctors out there, right?

If you think they become "bad" and "diabolical" once they graduate after MD school, you are wrong. They came into medical school that way - no fiber, moral cripples, lack any integrity whatsoever. I've seen a few doctors in my life arrested by the US Marshalls for Medicare Fraud (a physician friend is also an expert witness attorney for the Feds), and it is disheartening to see what doctors do all in the name of medicine. Like the scumbag OB/GYN at John Hopkins who was video tapping his patients private parts in a pen-camera. Thankfully when he was discovered he offed himself. Now patients are suing in masses John Hopkins b/c of that doctor. Such a damn shame.

But it starts before medical school. And I am seeing some of them now. We had a coordinator during orientation who said it best, and I shall paraphrase: "coming late to class, playing on Facebook on your computer during lectures, cheating for exams, all reflect a great deal about a person's character. These behaviors say alot about who you are"

Amen.

I just thought that once we got into medical school, it would truly be a level playing field. I thought, silly me, that the students all for the most part would be stellar, upright people who hustled for the first seat in class 15 minutes before lecture, dressed their best, were hogging the reference books at the library b/c they are so competitive academically, and itching to raise their hands in class to answer questions.

I have seen many, too many, kids show up high, hungover or smelling like ETOH to Anatomy Lab in front of our cadaver, sit on their arse and do nothing, while joking who they banged over the weekend. Adderall in medical school? ha! More plentiful than M & M Chocolate Candies, and most of it black market. Yes, people cheat in medical school as well. I asked one of these kids, just to be polite, "how is your girlfriend?" His response was telling, and our last conversation till this very day: "which one, I bang so many of them". He thought he was being funny. He was being rude to me, disrespectful and the women see him in class as a player. Also filthy rich, he is another future Medicare Fraud physician lawbreaker.

I reported him to the professor for cheating on one of the exams. The professor told me he already knew. Sheesh.

This is not what I expected in medical school. Sure, there are bad apples where ever you go, in churches, temples, US Congress, etc. But I just thought, for some stupid reason, that medical school would be a sampling of the creme de la creme, the best of the best, not just the brightest (no one is stupid intellectually in my class), but I definitely thought these would be the people that everyone would stop and practically genuflect or curtsy, b/c when they walked in the hallways, everyone knew these people were exemplary members of society...be they poor economically or rich. Money means nothing as to a person's character.

Behavior is everything.

And yes, I am now looking for the rock stars in my class.
 
You say you only want to hear responses from medical students who are 40+. Fine, since I am one of the few who qualify, I will chime in.

Every day I give thanks that I have been given the opportunity to become a doctor. I am thankful that I get to learn alongside such bright, eager, helpful, and funny medical students. In every aspect of medical education, whether it's academics, clinicals, leadership, or support, I and my fellow students combine our prior skills and recent knowledge to teach each other and solve our communal problems. I would be more than happy to work with any of them in the future, and I can only hope they think the same of me. It saddens me that you do not find the same in your environment.

I spend the vast majority of time humbled that I am where I am today. On the rare occasions when I begin to judge the school, the profession, or my fellow students in a negative light, I think of Matthew Chapter 7 and the feeling soon passes.

May you find what you seek.
 
Speaking of behaviors....here are some telling ones:

A girl in my class the other walked by me and smiled. I told her she looked like she had lost some weight. She beamed. "Really?", she exclaimed. I was honest: "It's obvious, in your face, much leaner. What are you doing?"

And so it went.

Another girl in my class is very quiet, she sat behind me in class yesterday. I didn't even know her name. So i asked her. She told me. I told her mine. She said she knew my name. Oh well: I stink at names but am good at faces. I asked her if I could call her "Gloria". She was puzzled and she asked why. I told her the truth. She reminded me of Gloria Estefan: same shape, same smile, same hairstyle. She cooed. I asked her if she felt I had insulted her. She shook her head vigorously and said she adored Gloria Estefan. I told her I did too, and that Gloria was a role model to all Latinos/Latinas of which I am one.

Last behavioral story:

Class started, Professor was going full steam ahead on neuro, and then it happened.

Peggy Noonan put it best in her article today on the Wall Street Journal:

"Leaders of the world now are garish and brazen. You can think of half a dozen of their names in less than a minute. They're good at showbiz, they find the light and flash the smile."

One of our class "leaders" walked in 30 minutes late into class during the Professor's really important lecture while dragging her luggage on wheels cart behind her with one hand, and swinging her Mocca Latte in the other. She walked right in front of the professor while lecturing, and then the class leader stopped, looked at everyone from in front of the class, laughed, bowed before everyone, and then started walking while again while dragging her bag. The professor stopped, several of us laughed, and then class continued.

May we all find His Light and Shine it.

Habemus Papam Francesco!
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I blame Elvis, the Beatles, and Rock n' Roll. All that hip gyrating and those loud noises are corrupting our nation's youth!
 
I blame Elvis, the Beatles, and Rock n' Roll. All that hip gyrating and those loud noises are corrupting our nation's youth!

😀😀😀

Sent from my SCH-I535 using SDN Mobile
 
I would understand if OP were just complaining about the trads. Hell, I probably will too (although not publicly to the extent that OP does as that will probably just come to bite her in the a**), but lumping anyone under 40 as a "kid" and unworthy to comment on her blog is just absurd.

OP, here's a word of advice from a "kid" who has served this country for 5 years in two war zones, stop worrying about what your classmates are doing and just focus on yourself and your studies. Be tolerant of their failings (while recognizing that you probably have some too) and lead by example, not by words (especially anonymous ones). That would be the "mature" attitude.

This sort of goes to show that none of us should ever consider ourselves top of the maturity ladder. There's always someone who's seen more than us, who's wiser than us. One thing I did learn from the military is that you live with the people you're dealt with. If you can't see the positive in people, you're going to end up sad, bitter and, yes, immature yourself. As QofQuimica wrote, this environment is a chance for "riper" people to display leadership.

Roadlesstravel, what you're describing could indeed be construed to be symptomatic of a society that increasingly values immaturity. But that doesn't necessarily improve with age or even work experience. I know people in their late 30s who have both solid, middle-class lives and high-achieving ones (heck, isn't the mid-life crisis the ultimate symbol of society's desire to keep us from growing up?). Many of them aren't much more mature than kids straight out of college, because society encourages them to be extremely self-absorbed and that kind of self-absorption absolutely stunts maturing. Yet of course they believe that Age Has Its Privileges and resort to looking down upon anyone younger than them, because part of the human existence is that we need to create imaginary hierarchies with us at the top of them.

Tell that to a 22-year-old with multiple tours in Afghanistan, who's seen more in 18 months than most people see in a lifetime; who has been tested thoroughly and re-enters the civilian world with a strong, mature self-awareness, which he or she simply cannot share with the civilian world that values the opposite. You know what PTSD is for many veterans? Coming back home for good and realizing that civilians suck in comparison to the kind of people you fought and bled with in an environment where you were both utterly devoted to each other and utterly irreverent with each other. It's not the crap you saw overseas that does in veterans half the time - it's that you get to go back to a society that now resembles a 300-million-person Kindergarten that you simply cannot relate to (and that's compared to a military institution that seemed to treat you like an infant). Guess how that "kid" is going to look at you...you think you have it tough dealing with immature people?

Take heart that few professions have such a great equalizer as medicine's clinical years. If there's one domestic job field where experiences at the edge of humanity rival those of the military, it's medicine. Traditional med students may lag behind until their late 20s because they've had to be insulated to get where they are, but come their early 30s, they'll have streaked ahead of most peers working office jobs and such. Less than two more years, and you'll be sharing knowing winks and cynical-yet-somehow-still-idealistic jokes with your classmates in the hallways. Who cares about the immature present? The future looks bright.
 
This sort of goes to show that none of us should ever consider ourselves top of the maturity ladder. There's always someone who's seen more than us, who's wiser than us. One thing I did learn from the military is that you live with the people you're dealt with. If you can't see the positive in people, you're going to end up sad, bitter and, yes, immature yourself. As QofQuimica wrote, this environment is a chance for "riper" people to display leadership.

Roadlesstravel, what you're describing could indeed be construed to be symptomatic of a society that increasingly values immaturity. But that doesn't necessarily improve with age or even work experience. I know people in their late 30s who have both solid, middle-class lives and high-achieving ones (heck, isn't the mid-life crisis the ultimate symbol of society's desire to keep us from growing up?). Many of them aren't much more mature than kids straight out of college, because society encourages them to be extremely self-absorbed and that kind of self-absorption absolutely stunts maturing. Yet of course they believe that Age Has Its Privileges and resort to looking down upon anyone younger than them, because part of the human existence is that we need to create imaginary hierarchies with us at the top of them.

Tell that to a 22-year-old with multiple tours in Afghanistan, who's seen more in 18 months than most people see in a lifetime; who has been tested thoroughly and re-enters the civilian world with a strong, mature self-awareness, which he or she simply cannot share with the civilian world that values the opposite. You know what PTSD is for many veterans? Coming back home for good and realizing that civilians suck in comparison to the kind of people you fought and bled with in an environment where you were both utterly devoted to each other and utterly irreverent with each other. It's not the crap you saw overseas that does in veterans half the time - it's that you get to go back to a society that now resembles a 300-million-person Kindergarten that you simply cannot relate to (and that's compared to a military institution that seemed to treat you like an infant). Guess how that "kid" is going to look at you...you think you have it tough dealing with immature people?

Take heart that few professions have such a great equalizer as medicine's clinical years. If there's one domestic job field where experiences at the edge of humanity rival those of the military, it's medicine. Traditional med students may lag behind until their late 20s because they've had to be insulated to get where they are, but come their early 30s, they'll have streaked ahead of most peers working office jobs and such. Less than two more years, and you'll be sharing knowing winks and cynical-yet-somehow-still-idealistic jokes with your classmates in the hallways. Who cares about the immature present? The future looks bright.

That's very well put. And the military vs civilian comparison is a powerful argument for not underestimating a young person.

But I still think maturity is a slippery moving target. If it means having horrible things happen in your life or a score card of trauma then that's one meaning. I'm not trying to say I don't agree with that to some extent.

But our culture could be deemed immature because we don't begin procreating, marrying, serving, and dying for someone else's geopolitical agenda before we know what's what. That's immature with respect to harsh desolate realities. Well f@ck being mature. And thankfully we have enough of that attitude to make bohemian life a secluded and ephemeral reality. I'll take that brand of immaturity as the high water mark of human social creation. Knowing full well things can always be infinitely uglier and violent.
 
But I still think maturity is a slippery moving target. If it means having horrible things happen in your life or a score card of trauma then that's one meaning. I'm not trying to say I don't agree with that to some extent.

That's very true, and I should have added that veterans don't have any greater inherent claim to being more mature than others. It's just another perspective. It's true that we can't keep a suffering scorecard. Nor is suffering a path to wisdom <insert Yoda quote here>. No path guarantees wisdom or maturity (says the guy who bought a new car every time he deployed).

If anything, a key aspect of maturity is that we accept that people around are different - often in ways that seem deeply inferior to you - and become neither jaded nor snobbish. As a species, we're very low on the sentience ladder. We can barely contain our emotions and it's often impossible for us to tell where reason ends and emotion starts. When judging others, we have to keep in mind that our subconscious urges and desires play a great role in forming our perspective and that we can't really understand what's going on inside our heads. We can never be sure whether our opinion of someone else is even barely rational, and we shouldn't put too much stock in our strongest opinions in particular. In other words, one key to maturity is knowing when go say "frakk it, I've got better stuff to think about".

Oh, and we also have a tendency to blather on philosophically in order to demonstrate our superior wisdom, which has little to do with said 'wisdom' and much more with our desire to sway others to our views in order to boost our ego. You know, like what I just wrote. Oops.

PS: This is why I could never go into psych.
 
Tell that to a 22-year-old with multiple tours in Afghanistan, who's seen more in 18 months than most people see in a lifetime; who has been tested thoroughly and re-enters the civilian world with a strong, mature self-awareness, which he or she simply cannot share with the civilian world that values the opposite. You know what PTSD is for many veterans? Coming back home for good and realizing that civilians suck in comparison to the kind of people you fought and bled with in an environment where you were both utterly devoted to each other and utterly irreverent with each other. It's not the crap you saw overseas that does in veterans half the time - it's that you get to go back to a society that now resembles a 300-million-person Kindergarten that you simply cannot relate to (and that's compared to a military institution that seemed to treat you like an infant). Guess how that "kid" is going to look at you...you think you have it tough dealing with immature people?

Take heart that few professions have such a great equalizer as medicine's clinical years. If there's one domestic job field where experiences at the edge of humanity rival those of the military, it's medicine. Traditional med students may lag behind until their late 20s because they've had to be insulated to get where they are, but come their early 30s, they'll have streaked ahead of most peers working office jobs and such. Less than two more years, and you'll be sharing knowing winks and cynical-yet-somehow-still-idealistic jokes with your classmates in the hallways. Who cares about the immature present? The future looks bright.

Well said. I am a 32 yo veteran who completed 4 tours in the "sandbox" and I am two years removed from my enlistment and I have had to learn to really check my attitude towards civilians. I just finished my bachelors and am about to start my post-bacc and I didn't hang out with any of my classmates until darn near the end because they all annoyed the hell outta me. I judged them on their behaviors like the OP and KNEW that I didn't want anything to do with them. Funny how self-induced loneliness gets a person to look past someone else's faults so they can hang. Turns out, I had quite a few cool peeps in my classes.

It is too easy in this life, and this culture, to look at someone and see a couple of annoying habits and then deduce that I don't want anything to do with them. Funny thing is, the way we treat classmates is directly linked to the way we (will) treat patients and God knows we need less arrogant healthcare providers (MDs/DOs/DNPs/PAs/Nurses/etc) and more caring intelligent ones.
 
JourneyAgent and Goucher- you have made very solid points. (Great writing as well).

As for the original post, I think generalizing is one of the greatest faults of humanity. You can learn a LOT from people of different ages and different backgrounds. Sometimes the wisest people are those who you pre judge and don't give a second look. The point is, get to know and learn to appreciate people in every stage , every background because often they have a lot to teach and you have more in common with them than you think. I'm in my 20s and I have friends in 30s and 40s who I have learned so much from, and I hope they appreciate my friendship and take away from it as well .Just my two cents. One of the coolest thing about med school is the variety of intelligent self motivated individuals.

Edit: matchb0x thank u for serving our country. Very well put as well.
 
These kids are sacrificing their 20s to become doctors, so if on a rare occasion they want to act their age, let them.

😴

I'm sacrificing my 20's just trying to get in and facing the dreaded uncertainty of what happens if I don't.
 
This sort of goes to show that none of us should ever consider ourselves top of the maturity ladder. There's always someone who's seen more than us, who's wiser than us. One thing I did learn from the military is that you live with the people you're dealt with. If you can't see the positive in people, you're going to end up sad, bitter and, yes, immature yourself. As QofQuimica wrote, this environment is a chance for "riper" people to display leadership.

Roadlesstravel, what you're describing could indeed be construed to be symptomatic of a society that increasingly values immaturity. But that doesn't necessarily improve with age or even work experience. I know people in their late 30s who have both solid, middle-class lives and high-achieving ones (heck, isn't the mid-life crisis the ultimate symbol of society's desire to keep us from growing up?). Many of them aren't much more mature than kids straight out of college, because society encourages them to be extremely self-absorbed and that kind of self-absorption absolutely stunts maturing. Yet of course they believe that Age Has Its Privileges and resort to looking down upon anyone younger than them, because part of the human existence is that we need to create imaginary hierarchies with us at the top of them.

Tell that to a 22-year-old with multiple tours in Afghanistan, who's seen more in 18 months than most people see in a lifetime; who has been tested thoroughly and re-enters the civilian world with a strong, mature self-awareness, which he or she simply cannot share with the civilian world that values the opposite. You know what PTSD is for many veterans? Coming back home for good and realizing that civilians suck in comparison to the kind of people you fought and bled with in an environment where you were both utterly devoted to each other and utterly irreverent with each other. It's not the crap you saw overseas that does in veterans half the time - it's that you get to go back to a society that now resembles a 300-million-person Kindergarten that you simply cannot relate to (and that's compared to a military institution that seemed to treat you like an infant). Guess how that "kid" is going to look at you...you think you have it tough dealing with immature people?

Take heart that few professions have such a great equalizer as medicine's clinical years. If there's one domestic job field where experiences at the edge of humanity rival those of the military, it's medicine. Traditional med students may lag behind until their late 20s because they've had to be insulated to get where they are, but come their early 30s, they'll have streaked ahead of most peers working office jobs and such. Less than two more years, and you'll be sharing knowing winks and cynical-yet-somehow-still-idealistic jokes with your classmates in the hallways. Who cares about the immature present? The future looks bright.

👍 Said what I meant, only a lot more elegantly. Acceptance of other people (without judgment) and recognizing your own self(and your own faults and weaknesses) and focusing on self improvement is one of the hallmarks of so-called maturity. Something, despite her age, I feel OP has demonstrated through these judgmental "observations", that she lacks.
 
I blame Elvis, the Beatles, and Rock n' Roll. All that hip gyrating and those loud noises are corrupting our nation's youth!

They were made out to be quite the villains decades ago.

Good to see another medical school student have humor on here.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Top Bottom