For AMCAS, how do you know what specific type of letters of recommendation each school wants?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

runningpenguin

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2016
Messages
60
Reaction score
0
For AMCAS, how do you know what specific type of letters of recommendation each school wants? For example, on their website, some schools will list that they want 3-5 letters of recommendations. But how do I know if they want 2 science letters + 1 non-science or if I can choose all 3 as science letters? Some schools don't mention what specific types of letters they want.

Members don't see this ad.
 
For AMCAS, how do you know what specific type of letters of recommendation each school wants? For example, on their website, some schools will list that they want 3-5 letters of recommendations. But how do I know if they want 2 science letters + 1 non-science or if I can choose all 3 as science letters? Some schools don't mention what specific types of letters they want.
Try looking at the FAQ section for more detail. You could also call the admissions office. Or, just stick to the basics that most schools ask for: two letters from science faculty who taught you and one non-science faculty who taught you. If there are room for more, get LORs from a PI, employer, or volunteer coordinator who can make substantive comments about your personal qualities.
 
The safest way to handle this would be to call each admissions office and ask if they have specific preferences. Sometimes schools don't update their websites often, so getting your information directly from the source via a phone call will be good.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
If your school doesn't have any letter service, use Interfolio. That puts all your letters into a packet and it counts as one upload so you can send that to every school you apply to and it makes your life easier. The rule is 3 letters minimim: 2 science letter one non science letter
 
Last edited:
Imagine that....actually going to the school admissions website and finding out what the specifically asks for. Gonnif, you radical you.

I am always appalled that many SDNers, who have hundreds if not 1000s of hours of research experience, can't lift a finger to research a school's requirements and recommendations.

Virtually every school's website that discusses letters will tell you in great detail what they are specifically looking for.


PS Just use google and search "NAME" Medical School Letters of Recommendation

For sample here are the 4 SUNY Med Schools which details goes from a line or two to a full page

SUNY Buffalo
Admission Requirements - Jacobs School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences - University at Buffalo
submit three letters of recommendation—one from a science professor—or a prehealth committee letter of recommendation

SUNY Stony Brook
Admissions | Stony Brook University School of Medicine
A letter of evaluation from the applicant's premedical adviser is also required. If no such official exists, letters from two instructors, one of whom is in a science field, should be submitted. No other letters are solicited. However, the Committee on Admissions also welcomes letters from others who may provide important information about the candidate.

SUNY Downstate
Letters of Recommendation

Letters of Recommendation
All letters (packet or individual) must be submitted on letterhead, and must be signed by the letter writer. Letters not meeting these requirements will not be considered. All letters must be submitted electronically—through the AMCAS letter service (including Virtual Evals or Interfolio). The AMCAS application letter types are: Committee letter, Letter packet or Individual Letter. We do not accept letters of recommendation sent by mail, email, or fax.
If you are submitting an AMCAS Committee Letter or a Letter Packet, we accept all the letters included in the packet. Please make sure that at least one of the letters is from a science professor who has taught you in a biology, chemistry or physics course.
Guidelines for Letters of Recommendation which must be submitted or included in your packet
If you are enrolled
in a graduate program, your faculty advisor/major professor must submit a letter of recommendation. This should be in addition to the letters specified above.
If you have graduated from college and are currently employed or are a non-traditional applicant, you may submit two individual letters of recommendation if you are unable to submit a premedical advisor or a committee letter. One letter should be from a science faculty member who has taught you in one of the science courses required for admission, and the second letter may be from your supervisor at your place of employment, or a faculty member who has taught you recently.
If you have not taken any college course work recently (within the last six years) but are currently employed, you may submit two individual letters of recommendation. One should be from your supervisor at your place of employment and the second may be from a physician or health professional with whom you have worked or a faculty member who has taught you and knows you well.
Please do not submit more than the specified number of recommendation letters, as this will delay the processing of your application. All letters must be submitted through AMCAS Letters. If you are submitting a packet of letters (e.g., Committee Letter or Letter Packet), we accept all the letters included in the packet.

SUNY Upstate
Letters of Recommendation | College of Medicine | SUNY Upstate Medical University
Letters of Recommendation
SUNY Upstate Medical University participates in the AMCAS Letters of Recommendation/Evaluation Service
C:\Users\Richard\AppData\Local\Temp\msohtmlclip1\01\clip_image001.gif
. This service allows medical schools to receive all letters of recommendation electronically via AMCAS. It will allow letter writers to send letters of recommendations directly to AMCAS rather than to each individual school. Currently 138 medical schools are participating in this service.

Sending Letters of Recommendation
Letter writers may upload letters directly to AMCAS through the AMCAS Letter Writer Application.
Your letter writer must include your AMCAS Letter ID found on your Letter Request Form when sending letters to this service.
SUNY Upstate Medical University requires the following letters of recommendation:
Current Undergraduate Students: Applicants must submit a letter of evaluation from the Health Professions Advisory Committee or the Pre-Health Advisor from their undergraduate institution. In the absence of such a committee, two letters of recommendation from faculty members in different departments are acceptable, although one of the departments must be a science department.
Current Graduate Students: Students in a degree-granting program must submit a letter of recommendation from a graduate advisor or department chairperson. This letter is in addition to the Health Professions Advisor or Committee letter for undergraduate students (see above). For those applicants who have recently started their graduate program, we are looking for a letter of "good standing" from your graduate advisor or department chair. Non-matriculated students taking graduate courses do not need to submit this letter.
Non-Traditional Students: Applicants who graduated from an undergraduate college more than 5 years ago, and are currently employed full-time, may submit one letter of recommendation from a science faculty member with whom a medical school prerequisite was taken and one letter of recommendation from a current supervisor.
MD/PhD Applicants: Applicants must submit a letter of evaluation from their Health Professions Advisory Committee or Pre-health Advisor AND three (3) additional letters of recommendation from people familiar with their academic background, their interest in research and their suitability for the MD/PhD Program. The three letters of recommendation to fulfill this requirement must be communicated when submitting a supplemental application to the MD/PhD Program. For the three additional research letters required, each letter must be in it's entirety and on college or business letterhead with a signature. If one or mores letters are already within a committee letter, this is acceptable so long as it is the full letter and has the writer's signature and still must be identified in the supplemental to fulfill the requirement.
 
They probably had friends talk to the PIs rather than do it themselves. Expect handouts rather than be proactive.
 
That is not correct. interfolio allows each of your writers to upload a letter separately, stote if neccessary, and then have each separately transferred to AMCAS where they will each count for a letter entry. You must have a letter entry for each writer created on AMCAS.

My bad. I never bothered to see how it worked in depth since I will never need it. I was judging it based on what my peers have told me
 
Gonnif, I think you forgot to mention MD-PhD require PI letters. You can get by with 1 if you can justify it having more if you worked with more than 1 PI.
 
Last edited:
I called up admissions and asked if my volunteer mentor/supervisor, who is a faculty member who runs a program for students to learn about social determinants of health while they volunteer, would count for the third letter, even if I hadn't taken a course with her. Woman on the phone said it was perfectly fine. What would you advise?

EDIT: Actually, I assume if it was/is a problem it's too late at this point anyways. Nevermind.

The purpose of science letters is to attest to your academic competency. Therefore, you should not have gotten a letter from her unless you had a class with her. If you did research with a science faculty, I would count their letter as a PI letter, not science professor letter.
 
Imagine that....actually going to the school admissions website and finding out what the specifically asks for. Gonnif, you radical you.

I am always appalled that many SDNers, who have hundreds if not 1000s of hours of research experience, can't lift a finger to research a school's requirements and recommendations.
You havent taken a course with her, so no I would advise against. this is exactly the kind of scenario that posters would tell me and when I discuss it with a dean or admin director, they say absolutely not.
If I emailed the admissions office and they wrote on the email that the third letter can come from any class (science or non-science), is this enough? I emailed (not called) so there's paper verification.
 
Top