For Past Applicants W Large # of Early II

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

jj_Sharp2

Full Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2018
Messages
177
Reaction score
427
So I've been blessed to have gotten a large # of II early in the cycle thus far, BUT it's caused me to be in a bit of a pickle with work right now. My boss is getting kind of angry that I've been taking large amounts of days off to travel to interview at these schools and wants to know when I'll be done interviewing. I've received 9 thus far, but it seems the frequency has definitely decreased month-by-month (5 in july; 3 in August; 1 in September). I told him before I joined that I'd be interviewing for schools, but that it wouldn't be an issue as I genuinely did not think I'd get more than 3-4.

The issue is that the vast majority (7) of these schools are more my "safety" schools, but the other two are T-10 and seem to be a bit out of my league. In short, I've received nothing from my target schools (LizzyM - 75).

So I guess my question is: for those of you who have had similar luck early on does it continue throughout the year? Or should I expect to have already gotten the vast bulk of my invites? I applied to 35 schools, almost all complete by ~July 15 and the vast majority of schools I have yet to hear from are T-30 schools (all crapshoots; I know). I know there's no rhyme or reason to the process and I'm not looking for a concrete answer. Rather, I'm trying to gauge an understanding of how ppl in past cycles with similar situations have ended up faring.

My follow-up question would then be whether or not I should cancel or postpone my "safety" interviews until I get more news from these T20/30 schools? I'm afraid I'm walking on eggshells and don't want to use my remaining days off to travel to these schools if I'm going to end up having to go again later in the cycle and risk losing my job. However, I've also read enough of SDN to understand that I shouldn't cancel interviews until I have an acceptance.

Again, NOT looking for a guru to tell me my fate or try to helplessly figure out how schools decide for II. Genuinely looking for advice from ppl who have been in similar situations so I can tactfully figure out how to reschedule/act and how to chat with my employer.
 
I personally would attend every interview as soon as possible until I had at least one acceptance in hand. I know someone last cycle who attended 6 interviews and never received an acceptance. Not saying that will be you, just that you cannot predict what will happen.

I would also explain to your boss, in a professional respectful way, what your priorities are.
 
I personally would attend every interview as soon as possible until I had at least one acceptance in hand. I know someone last cycle who attended 6 interviews and never received an acceptance. Not saying that will be you, just that you cannot predict what will happen.

I would also explain to your boss, in a professional respectful way, what your priorities are.
Yeah stories like this scare me.
 
No reason to cancel until you have an acceptance.

I would inform your boss of the interview dates, and ask if you can finish your work tasks before you go to them. Shows that you’re a team player.

For schools that you are not crazy about/aren’t rolling admissions, push the interview date to sometime after Oct. 15th. The schools that do not allow for re-scheduling — bite the bullet and go.

I have over 15 IIs, this is how I’m approaching it.
 
I would vote with @Boola Boy . I don't have time to look for it now, but I think last year somebody did an "anecdotal analysis" of SDNers reporting a high number of IIs and concluded that they generally received almost all of them early in the process and that was true for me: 15 - all but one before the end of October when, coincidentally, I got my first acceptances (from non-T20s). My last actual interview (a T10) was late November. Keep your eye on the prize.
 
I would vote with @Boola Boy . I don't have time to look for it now, but I think last year somebody did an "anecdotal analysis" of SDNers reporting a high number of IIs and concluded that they generally received almost all of them early in the process and that was true for me: 15 - all but one before the end of October when, coincidentally, I got my first acceptances (from non-T20s). My last actual interview (a T10) was late November. Keep your eye on the prize.
Interesting. I’ll take a look to see if I can find it. How many schools did you apply to?
 
How do people get so many IIs? Is it some amazing non-trad story or URM coupled with exceptional stats and/or story? Or ORM coupled with Nobel Prize?
 
How do people get so many IIs? Is it some amazing non-trad story or URM coupled with exceptional stats and/or story? Or ORM coupled with Nobel Prize?
Personally, it’s been a combination of being verified from day 1, no Cs or lower, >90th percent MCAT, multiple gap years, thousands of clinical, non clinical, research, and underserved community experience hours, copious hours spent on PS and prewriting, in addition to being URM and a first-gen college student.
 
I wasn't complete until mid August and have a low GPA for MD/PhD but I believe a well written application that shows my passion really helps.
 
How do people get so many IIs? Is it some amazing non-trad story or URM coupled with exceptional stats and/or story? Or ORM coupled with Nobel Prize?
what I think it's been for me is completing everything day one, story (1st gen American/college student, rural+inner city experiences), years of research @ HYPSM, meaningful volunteering, great letters of rec (I think?), and applying to >40 schools
 
Last edited:
I have most of those things but do not have a large number of II. I've only received II from schools where my MCAT is in their 90th percentile. Thousands of hours of both volunteer EMS and research with 2 posters. 95th percentile MCAT and graduated magna cum laude (3.6+). SES disadvantaged, first-generation college, and other adversity. All apps complete 7/24 (was waiting on committee letter).

It's really just random. Hang in there @deweystrontium @MCATLasagna
 
what I think it's been for me is completing everything day one, story (1st gen American/college student, rural+inner city experiences), years of research @ HYPSM, meaningful volunteering, great letters of rec (I think?), and applying to >40 schools
wow, you are every adcoms dream. congrats on your achievements!
 
@OP.

Congrats on your success thus far. Based on your post, obviously you are a competitive applicant this cycle and you will be able to pick and choose where you want to matriculate at.

When you are deciding where you want to go, remember to ask the admissions office for their 2018 match list. This will help you to see which programs are successful at training their students to reach their destination.

Good luck.
 
@OP.

When you are deciding where you want to go, remember to ask the admissions office for their 2018 match list. This will help you to see which programs are successful at training their students to reach their destination.
Just had to point this out... I always thought it's poor taste to ask about match lists during interviews...but I see so many applicants doing it!

After one has received an acceptance, it would seem reasonable to ask about match lists.
 
Just had to point this out... I always thought it's poor taste to ask about match lists during interviews...but I see so many applicants doing it!

After one has received an acceptance, it would seem reasonable to ask about match lists.
Considering that most schools post their match list online (one of the schools I interviewed at had theirs printed out on their coffee table) I don’t think it’s poor taste to ask.
 
Considering that most schools post their match list online (one of the schools I interviewed at had theirs printed out on their coffee table) I don’t think it’s poor taste to ask.

on the other hand, considering that most post their match lists online, is there really a reason to ask? I don't think it matters either way, but I would be nervous about coming off gunner-ish.
 
Top