genetics or physiology??

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

medmom

Senior Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2005
Messages
313
Reaction score
1
I am taking the MCAT next semester. My class schedule includes second semesters of Ochem and physics, I only have room for one more. Is Physiology or Genetics better for the MCAT? The genetics will be way out of my schedule and will be difficult to schedule due to kids, physiology will be easy to schedule.
Medmom
 
medmom said:
I am taking the MCAT next semester. My class schedule includes second semesters of Ochem and physics, I only have room for one more. Is Physiology or Genetics better for the MCAT? The genetics will be way out of my schedule and will be difficult to schedule due to kids, physiology will be easy to schedule.
Medmom

Physio, no question about it. Any genetics you need you already had in Bio 101.
 
👎 Well from the practice tests I have taken so farin the BS section I have only really seen questions that reflect what I have learned from my Gen Bio and Orgo classes so far. Now there is some biochem in small amounts. Most of the questions are not whether you can spit out info you remebered from class though, I find that most of the questions were passage based. If I had to choose though I would go with the physiology classes, though I doubt you really even need that. A good review in your basic sciences and doing practice test will help I hope. Genetics 👎 I havent seen anything farther than the basics.

Good Luck and I hope that helps a little. I'm not gonna pretend to know it all.
 
I agree. You probably know all you need to know about genetics for the MCAT. Physio is definitely helpful and you can use ALL the info you learn from it on the MCAT. Good luck! :luck:
 
Definitely Physiology... the genetics stuff is pretty basic on the MCAT.
 
physio, bc i was a physio ta and its more interesting than genetics for me 👍
 
Physiology is the better choice. Remember that adcoms look at you and if you've taken some physiology it will look better.
 
Unless things have changed I found having taken Genetics helpful with the MCAT. My form was heavy with genetics and I struggled with one pure genetics passage even though I had taken advanced genetics courses. I don't remember much about Physio on it though, I guess it depends on the year and the form. My vote is with Genetics though from personal experience.
 
Secondly, I never took Physio before med school and I have found Physio challenging but easy to learn while here, on the other hand, I couldn’t see how anyone could understand Genetics here if they hadn’t taken it before. On the other hand (third hand), I don’t see how having taken either in undergrad could help that much.
 
I'm sure that a solid basis can serve a purpose in preparation for med school level, no?
 
i would take genetics because some schools require it (think kcumb) and others strongly recommend it. schools seem to be pretty silent on the physio issue. for the mcat itself, eh, it doesn't matter. you really don't need anything beyond the basic bio sequence. all the little physio and genetics things can be learned on your own doing mcat prep.
 
I don’t know, I was a science major and the only class that I feel gave me somewhat of a footing here so far is Biochem (and I took 3 Biochem courses in undergrad). It’s just a different way of learning between undergrad and now. In undergrad I learned from test to test and I only cared about what I was told to learn in class. In med school everything builds up like a huge mudslide and interrelates. You really have to learn why and how everything works. For instance in undergrad it may have been suffice to know that sympathetic innervations speeds up heart rate in Physio, and then forget it a week after the test, but now we have to know what the transmitter is and how it works on which receptor and what would administration of this drug do and how does the body compensate and what is the chemical basis of that etc. etc. Maybe it depends on your undergrad and what type of learner you are, everyone is different. All I can say is there is no way to prep for the fire house, because that is what you get; a firehouse to the mouth turned on full blast with knowledge.

The whole basis for first year medical school is to bring everyone to the same level. People come in with PhDs and JDs and MS and Underwater Basket Weaving BS degrees. In theory everyone is on equal footing by the end of first year to take on the “abnormal” and the stuff that is specific to medicine in the second year. Having said that, you have to realize that every school has a different curriculum and different way of doing things but the end result and focus is always the same, get you through the board exams and with the knowledge to be a capable physician or surgeon.
 
I guess I should add that Fall of 06 will be my last semester and if I don't take genetics this semester I will take in in the fall anyways along with biochem. Physiology is not offered in the fall (pretty small college).
medmom
 
medmom said:
I guess I should add that Fall of 06 will be my last semester and if I don't take genetics this semester I will take in in the fall anyways along with biochem. Physiology is not offered in the fall (pretty small college).
medmom

Take physiology 👍 Do it Do it Do it DO IT DO IT. :laugh:
 
Genetics. You don't need either for MCAT, but like someone already said, schools like it. Most school either require it or strongly suggest it. I have never seem physiology in the strongly recommended category that I can think of.
 
Do it Do it Do it DO IT DO IT.











But seriously, i think physio would definitely help for the mcat and for med school. Half of the bio mcat book is physio. Only one chapter is genetics.
 
medmom said:
I am taking the MCAT next semester. My class schedule includes second semesters of Ochem and physics, I only have room for one more. Is Physiology or Genetics better for the MCAT? The genetics will be way out of my schedule and will be difficult to schedule due to kids, physiology will be easy to schedule.
Medmom
neither...keep a lighter sched. and play with your kids or something. or start studying for the mcat during the time you would have devoted to those classes
 
That's what sucks, I have a full scholarship that requires me to take 15 credit hours so I have to take one of them. I am done with everything lower level and electives.
medmom
 
medmom said:
That's what sucks, I have a full scholarship that requires me to take 15 credit hours so I have to take one of them. I am done with everything lower level and electives.
medmom
can you take something really easy??
 
not really,other than those two I need Plant bio, which wouldn't fit my schedule, senior thesis and 2 other upper levels. I really don't have anything easy left to take. I am going to try and take the least brutal, best for the mcat, between genetics and physiology.
medmom
 
take them both so you can hammer the MCAT when the time comes ....
 
medmom said:
I am taking the MCAT next semester. My class schedule includes second semesters of Ochem and physics, I only have room for one more. Is Physiology or Genetics better for the MCAT? The genetics will be way out of my schedule and will be difficult to schedule due to kids, physiology will be easy to schedule.
Medmom

Genetics.

They took out 1-2 O-chem passages and added genetics to replace it the year I took the MCAT. It is still that way now.

Any physiology you need will be learned in general bio.
 
OSUdoc08 said:
Genetics.

They took out 1-2 O-chem passages and added genetics to replace it the year I took the MCAT. It is still that way now.

Any physiology you need will be learned in general bio.

👍 👍
 
At my school they bearly cover any physio, not even close to the level that is necessary for the mcat. They kinda just squeezed it in at the end, i think we were running out of time.
 
OSUdoc08 said:
Genetics.

They took out 1-2 O-chem passages and added genetics to replace it the year I took the MCAT. It is still that way now.

Any physiology you need will be learned in general bio.

honestly, i thought that there was a lot of patho and phy. especially about partial pressures in the lungs, respiration and all that jazz (i can't think of any more examples but i remember thinking that i was glad that i had taken phy and patho when i was done.) 🙄 the 1-2 genetics sections were easy enough to figure out based on the passages. but again, that is just my opinion.
 
Top