I've seen mentioned a few places that there can be a strong geographic bias in EM residency interviews, e.g. if I'm at a med school on the east coast, programs on the west coast won't even bother interviewing me unless I've done an away there. How much truth is there to that? I'm a non-trad, have lived all over, and have no particular ties to where I'm currently in school. I like new places, and would ideally like to end up somewhere I haven't lived before for residency. Would I need to do multiple aways to open up various parts of the country? (As much as I love EM, I'd rather spend 4th yr doing stuff I won't be doing for the rest of my career, rather than doing 3 or 4 EM sub-Is. And I already have a soul-crushing mountain of debt, so the idea of multiple aways is also less appealing from a cost standpoint.) I'd appreciate any insight!
Speaking from the other side of the match, programs are nervous about the match just as much if not more than the students.
We always match someone, but we want to match the best students. We only have so many interviews, rotations, and resources to grant to a student, so we want to allocate wisely.
Geography does matter to us, but not because we are biased against a certain coast. We want to know if a student is genuinely interested, or just going on the interview....We can't just ask, so we have to look for trends.
Generally students who are more interested in us are:
1. Did base rotations at our hospital
2. Is from a local medical school
3. Rotated at our program
4. Has some sort of tie to the area (family, significant other, lifelong dream to live in the midwest (not typical haha)
The match is biased toward the students (as it should be), but that means that the programs have to choose our ROL very carefully. Where students should rank the place they most want to go regardless of their chance, programs can NOT do this. If we rank someone very highly, and they aren't interested, we can (and have) fallen a long ways down our ROL.
ie. Student (Jenny Overacheiver) - Harvard grad. 4.0. Honors everything. USMLE 2 million....Nobel peace prize winner, double black belt, speaks 12 languages.....most amazing medical student EVER. We would LOVE to have her at our program, and she would be our top choice any day, but we there is NO WAY IN HELL she will ever pick our program. We tend to rank those candidates way down our list, because if we use that number 1 slot on her, we may miss out on other great candidates who will rank with us.
I hope that helps explain things. It's not that we don't like "those east coast folks" here, it's just that we don't want to be stood up for the prom....