I've been with GL advisor for over a year now and wanted to post a review:
Overall I have been VERY pleased with my experience at GL advisor. While several people are saying just "figure it out yourself", I have a high expectation that these people either have small loans with (potentially) big incomes, or, are just making horrible financial decisions. I have about $300,000 in debt that's currently increasing by $2,000 each month with interest, AND, I chose subspecialty / academic pediatrics, which is kind of the rock bottom of the payscale (yes, even less than general pediatrics). That said, this makes me the perfect candidate for IBR / public service loan forgiveness, and I'm grateful to have had GL advisor's help on this.
The way I look at it, is GL advisor at minimum is an insurance program that keeps me from screwing myself over on my loans. If I screw up my PSLF stuff, I'm out hundreds of thousands of dollars. $450 a year in comparison is a small amount to keep me on the right track. As a resident, you don't have time to sit and read up every night on all the new legislation and loan programs being rolled out. GL advisor does, because it's their job. And on that topic, fyi, if your doing PSLF I hope you know that there is a new PSLF employer certification form that is important to fill out, as it actually changes who your loan servicer is (
http://www.myfedloan.org/pslf). Again, while I did a lot of my homework up front, in the middle of residency, there is no way I would have picked up that tidbit on my own. (Thank you GL advisor).
The other side of the coin, is that I'm positive I have already saved far more in loan repayments than I have payed them. When I crunched the numbers (and I did engineering as an undergraduate, so yes I know how to do math), I figured I would roughly end up with monthly payments of a few hundred. When GL advisor did it though, I'm know sitting pretty with $0 payments through my first two years of repayment. (FYI, don't expect that though if you don't have kids).
Granted, there are a few drawbacks:
1. I think a lot of your experience depends on which specific "advisor" you're paired with. Mine happens to be awesome, and for how many questions I send her way she's probably thinking "$450 a year aint enough".
2. Yup, they were VERY slow with taxes this year, although mine still got done in time and they got me a very good refund. Last year was better, and they've sent out a bunch of emails apologizing and soliciting feedback as they overhaul their system for next year.
3. Just know this: applying for consolidation, IBR, etc; should be simple, but don't discount the governments ability to mess things up. No kidding, I had to sort and re-sort out my loans multiple times over to get all of the right loans consolidated. At first, I wasn't sure if GL advisor was the cause of these problems or not, but after talking to others who had the same problems and were not using GL advisor, I have come to the conclusion that GL advisor was definitely not the cause, and, were actually a huge help in sorting out the mess. No kidding, one time while on conference phone call with a government loan officer, my advisor basically had to tell the loan officer how to do her job (in a nice way) because clearly she had no clue.
4. Yes, all of your interaction will be by email and phone calls, but this is actually preferable for me. (As a resident, it's not like I would have time to drop into their office anyways).
So in sum, I'm super happy with GL advisor. Wouldn't hesitate to sign up for them again.