gravity and tension depiction

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

rmm30

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2010
Messages
276
Reaction score
1
Why is gravity ubiquitously depicted as such in text books. Where M1 and M2 are the mass of any two objects and the arrows represent a force:


M1 F1------------> <--------------F2 M2

To me this is counterintuitive. Gravity is an attractive force. If you were pulling on M2, it would be depicted like so:

F1 <---------------M2


Likewise if you were pushing on M2, it could be depicted as follows:

F1 ---------------> M2

Same goes for tension. When two people pull on a rope ala tug of war, it's always illustrated as such:

Person 1 T1 --------> <------------- T2 Person 2 .

Again, in a FBD if you were person one and tied a rope around person 2 and pulled, it would look like this:


Person 1 T1 <-------------------Person 2.


What is the reason for this disparity? I'm pretty handy with problem solving and this hasn't caused any problems but it always eats at me when I see these two illustrations. What am I missing here? Thanks in advance for any replies.
 
This depiction is usually so the reader can understand Newton's third law where a mass experiencing a force will apply a force of equal magnitude back on the other mass

At least, that is my 2 cents
 
This depiction is usually so the reader can understand Newton's third law where a mass experiencing a force will apply a force of equal magnitude back on the other mass

At least, that is my 2 cents

How does that explain the directionality of the vectors? Is nobody else thrown by that diagram at all?
 
Top