Healthcare in different countries

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

GREATwarEAGLE

New Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2006
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
I dont want to start a debate here. I realize this subject can do that.

I would like to know which developed countries that have government funded healthcare for all its citizens are generally considered to be the "best."

"Best" being a relative term.

Or, if this question is too vague and subjective, then which aspects to the approach of different countries stand out as being especially effective and practical.

Thank you.
 
I dont want to start a debate here. I realize this subject can do that.

I would like to know which developed countries that have government funded healthcare for all its citizens are generally considered to be the "best."

"Best" being a relative term.

Or, if this question is too vague and subjective, then which aspects to the approach of different countries stand out as being especially effective and practical.

Thank you.


Hi,
Your asking questions like this one in a student doctor network. You will not get an answer and will most likely get the debate you don't want.
 
To avoid a debate, anyone who is willing to answer this question can send me a PM.

I am not going to challenge or debate any answer.

Thank you.
 
To avoid a debate, anyone who is willing to answer this question can send me a PM.

I am not going to challenge or debate any answer.

Thank you.

I think you misunderstood the post from erichaj - his first line was meant to highlight the fact that many of the members here at SDN are STUDENTS or resident physicians and have little to no knowledge of their own country's healthcare system let alone those of another country. Therefore, it is unlikely that you will get many responses or at least, very few helpful ones.
 
I was just about to tell you that France was rated number 1 but this was a couple of years ago. I'm not sure if the cbs link you posted is current as I couldnt find a date on the story.

I've has this debate many times as I came here to train from the UK which has a socialized health care system. The UK system called the 'NHS' was initially an excellent system when it was formed after WWII. However, in recent years it has suffered terribly from chronic government underfunding and numerous bureaucratic reforms. As a result, currently both patients and doctors/nurses are suffering. Every week in the newspapers there are stories of NHS failures. Training is very lengthy leaving many (such as myself) to leave the country. Not surprisingly doctors morale is very low, a shocking statistic is that last year 1 in 3 junior doctors were unemployed in a country where ironically there is a shortage of doctors.

Although the US system is by no means perfect, since training here, there is certainly a stark difference in morale and opportunities; likely a result of organized shorter post-graduate training.

However, many of the countries at the top of the WHO table do not have as large an immigrant and heterogeneous populations as the US and UK. In the UK particularly, whenever something is 'free' it tends to get abused, and thus currently privatization is already occurring in the NHS and is likely to increase.

I believe if people are ready to pay significant amounts of money ruining their health (such as tobacco, alcohol, drugs, fast food) etc, then they should also be prepared to pay for their health with insurance payments which arguably is money better spent. However, this should be means-based depending on income.

Anyway time to get off my soapbox..😴
 
Please can anybody write a summarised article on how the USA Health system operates???

I know I could get this info on the net but there are so many articles out there. I want a med student or graduates summary hahahah

Thanks
 
Not surprisingly doctors morale is very low, a shocking statistic is that last year 1 in 3 junior doctors were unemployed in a country where ironically there is a shortage of doctors.

Surely this statistic is including the thousands of immigrant doctors from Pakistan/India/Eastern Europe who can't get a house officer job. I know that graduates of UK med schools do not have a problem securing UK junior doctor spots.
 
Surely this statistic is including the thousands of immigrant doctors from Pakistan/India/Eastern Europe who can't get a house officer job. I know that graduates of UK med schools do not have a problem securing UK junior doctor spots.

Of course it includes immigrant doctors, however, UK grads have also been affected. I personally know several of my classmates in this situation. If you are interested refer to numerous articles including the one below on the BBC website:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4720905.stm
 
Top