HELP: Neuro question

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Mr. H

Full Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2001
Messages
652
Reaction score
0
hey, I got a quick question. What is the basis behind spatial and temporal illusions? Why is it beneficial to the brain to have a distorted sense of the world?

This is the question my TA and professor refuse to answer, so I assum it'll be on my exam tomorrow, damn the instructors!
 
Your question is not really specific, so I don't know exactly what's being asked, but here are a couple of things to think about.

1. Illusions are caused when the brain makes what it thinks is a reasonable assumption, but the input contradicts that assumption.

For example, our visual system has developed over the ages to interpret the same object as small when far away, or large when close up. This perspective effect helps us as predators/prey, for example. So, a standard illusion would be to place two equal-size objects in such a perspective field: the object that is "in the distance" will appear larger, although it isn't. It's reasonable for your brain to do so, since it was designed or prewired to make such interpretations. Presumably, it was not evolutionarily advantageous or efficient for our neurons to detect such optical illusions: a lion running toward you gets bigger, that's all your brain needs to know.

2. You don't have enough neurons in your retina to receive light for every single point that you see when you have your eyes open. For example, even though you think your eyes are responding to a white spot on a white wall, and telling your brain that there is "white" here, in fact, chances are your brain is filling in the white for you and not responding to any retinal neurons at all. Instead, your retinal neurons are trained to recognize differences in intensities, so that they will fire only if there is a change. You can imagine your retina's neurons are more like a huge edge detection machine. So, if you have a millimeter each of black-blue-blue-blue-blue-black in sequence, your eyes will only respond to the first black-blue and to the last blue-black. Your brain will fill in the middle part. I believe this is another kind of illusion. The reason for this is purely economical and again for efficiency: you want to minimize the number of neurons required to make a sufficient and correct assessment of the outside world.

I imagine you can find similar analogies for auditory illusions.

Hope this helps.
 
thanks, but I was thinking last night and it kind of struck me. What is the most obvious illusion that we perceive every day? COLOR!! We only have three cones, our brain can put these together to make what appears to be 16.7 million colors, but of course there are really only three.
 
Hmmm, possibly. Just be prepared to explain why we use three different color sensors to generate the full gamut, and WHY this is might be considered an "illusion."

I would think they're more looking for my type of answers, but you're taking the class.

Good luck.
 
yeah,I know what you mean. The thing is we haven't gone over any illusions what so ever in my class. He told us that everything would come from his notes, if that weren't the case, then people could bring up a million different illusions. So I think color is what I'm going with for the spatial dimension. But do you have any idea for an illusion in the temporal dimension? Speech for example?
peace
 
Top