help! should i go to my jefferson interview?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

banannie

Senior Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2002
Messages
368
Reaction score
0
i realize i have to make this decision myself, but i'm looking for input from anyone who knows anything about jefferson. if you think this thread is lame, please just ignore and move on.

i was really excited about the interview . . . that is, until I found out I got accepted to Mount Sinai, my first choice.

on paper, Sinai is undoubtedly the better school for me. jefferson definitely has its good points. and i'm sure i'd find out a lot of wonderful things about the school if i went to visit.

but . . . is it worth $118 for the train (which I will have to ride for 6 hours each way), using up a vacation day, and being gone 2 days before my boss is submitting a big grant application (she's cool with me going, but i know she'd love it if i stayed) . . . . is it worth all that just find out that *maybe* i'd like jefferson just as well?

can anyone tell me anything about jefferson that will make it worth going? that will convince me that maybe it can offer something that Sinai can't? does jeff have really great financial aid packages? any input, either way, would be very much appreciated!

Members don't see this ad.
 
go buy some CDs for your gf with that money. id go to Mt Sinai without hesitation
 
I've heard good things about Jefferson, but if you have already been accepted to a great school where you feel you'll be happy for the next four years.......save yourself the money (and stress) by not going.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
anyone else????
 
I've you've already got an acceptance that you're happy with...then cancel the interview and give someone else a shot 😉
 
If you are in your true first choice, the game is over.
I will say that I really liked Jeff, much more than I anticipated. I don't know exactly why, but the friendly atmosphere that every school tries to show off was very genuine at Jeff. I got multiple post-acceptance letters from them, nice little things like happy new years, if you have any questions feel free to come in, etc. It is one of the bigger classes in the nation, most people live in Jeff's own dorms, it is relatively laid back and not ultra-competitive.
At the same time, NYC is NYC and Sinai has one of the most amazing hospitals in all the land.
 
Did you tell Mt Sinai they were your first choice? If so, you're more or less ethically bound (at least in my mind) to go there.

After visiting Jefferson myself, I have to agree with others that it is a much better place than it appears on paper. Location, facilities, faculty, and (with one expeption) students-- I was very impressed with everything. Tufts, a similar school on paper, was not nearly as impressive.

In any case, Congratulations, it's not everyone that gets into their top choice (I'm still pulling for UMASS, which makes a large portion of their eventual acceptees wait months and months to hear). Ackkk!
 
thanks so much for your advice!

Adjectives that I have heard used to describe Jefferson are "conservative" and "competitive", and to be honest, that has scared me off a bit. I'd be much more comfortable in an atmosphere that really embraces diversity and cooperation, and where students and faculty are more on the progressive end of the political spectrum. But I hear that things at Jefferson, particularly the grading system, are changing. And I do keep reading on interview feedback that, like you said, Jefferson is much more impressive in person than on paper.

And of course, the fact that DW got some nice scholarship money from Jefferson, made me think twice. I realize I'm not high on Jefferson's priority list (hence my late interview), but just the idea that there are tons of alumni floating around waiting to throw money at students is kind of exciting.
 
When are you interviewing? My interview is coming up next week.....
 
Originally posted by banannie
Adjectives that I have heard used to describe Jefferson are "conservative" and "competitive"
again, what does hearsay do for anyone?

people say disparaging things about sinai as well. if you're entirely 100 percent sure sinai is yout top choice, fine, save your money and good luck there. BUT, dont exclusively rely on things you've "heard" when evaluating a school, go see for yourself.
 
dw

you got money from jeff? can i ask how 🙂 i need some money too haha
 
Originally posted by DW
again, what does hearsay do for anyone?

people say disparaging things about sinai as well.

i apologize, i did not mean to offend. i guess what is disparaging is in the eye of the beholder. there are plenty of people who thrive on competition, and plenty of people who may prefer to be in an environment that is not as super-liberal as most universities in the north east are considered to be. so for them, conservative and competitive are positive. that is fine, that's just not my preference.

but DW, you are absolutely right, hearsay is no good. i was just hoping that someone who knew the school better than i do could confirm or deny what i've heard. my impression, from the AMSA surveys, from evaluations written by alums of my undergrad, and from Jefferson's admittedly "political" admissions process, is that "conservative", or at least "traditional", is not far off the mark. i know that they've changed their grading system a lot, so it's obviously not going to be as competitive as it once was, but it's difficult to know at this point whether the attitudes of faculty members have also changed in a way that favors a more cooperative approach to learning.

anyway, someone should tell all of those students at Jefferson who love their school so much to go fill out that AMSA survey, because from looking at their ratings, i'm just not feeling the love.
 
AMSA survey for Jefferson=OUTDATED

If you're a lower year you can't really fill out the survey with your experiences because it's set up for people to rate all four years, so any info on that website will be behind the times.

I think the best way to do things is to go see for yourself and make up your own mind. If there is no way you would ever go to any school except Sinai, then by all means, withdraw from all of your other schools, no reason to take someone's interview spot who might not even have an acceptance yet. But if your decision is going to be based on something you've heard about a school that is bad, I think it's worth the money to go and see for yourself.
 
Originally posted by banannie
thanks so much for your advice!

Adjectives that I have heard used to describe Jefferson are "conservative" and "competitive", and to be honest, that has scared me off a bit. I'd be much more comfortable in an atmosphere that really embraces diversity and cooperation, and where students and faculty are more on the progressive end of the political spectrum. But I hear that things at Jefferson, particularly the grading system, are changing. And I do keep reading on interview feedback that, like you said, Jefferson is much more impressive in person than on paper.

And of course, the fact that DW got some nice scholarship money from Jefferson, made me think twice. I realize I'm not high on Jefferson's priority list (hence my late interview), but just the idea that there are tons of alumni floating around waiting to throw money at students is kind of exciting.

Hi Banannie,

I'm a Jefferson first year, and I also heard lots of the rumors that you also heard. I'll try to let you know where *I* agree and disagree.

First about financial aid and "priority": I was interviewed in late March, and was waitlisted. I was accepted (called by Dean Callahan) in July. I did the financial aid info, and everything went perfectly well. They were very competant, and gave me a good deal -- they gave me a few scholarships (ie free money), a few Jefferson low-interest loans (5%, no interest until 1 year post graduation) and also a federal low-interest loan and Stafford loans to make up the rest. I was very happy with the financial aid. I have heard that they do sometimes give very generous financial aid out, but I assume that is very much on a case by case basis. You could always see if you could use a financial aid offer at one school to leverage generosity at another.

This was the first year that Jefferson went to a H/P/F system. I LOVE it. It absolutely takes the insane pressure off (even though I still get stressed at times) but people are absolutely always learning to learn as much as possible -- so it's more about learning the material to be a knowledgeable physician rather than for a grade. I can't speak as someone stressing to get honors, because I generally don't -- if I do, it's a happy coincidence. I am very very glad it's H/P/F and I think it's a really important aspect of the Jefferson system.

I also heard about competition, and I really don't feel it. Students are all the time working in groups, and teaching each other tidbits, or even sharing miserable lab practical grades. Preparing for exams, people really help each other out, coach each other, and ask people they barely know for help -- and help is generally given, very kindly and happily. So again, I really have only seen some people be competitive who are really hyper about trying to get honors -- complain that they missed it by one point etc...but those types of people will be in every medical school, so you can just ignore them (or gossip about them with likeminded friends).

In terms of diversity, Jefferson ranks pretty low on that -- I know it's something they want to improve, and I'm not sure it's very different from most med schools, except for maybe Temple and Howard etc. But diversity groups are very active and have lots of cultural events that everyone is invited to -- very welcoming.

For the most part, I do find students and faculty to be progressive and open-minded. There will be some in any med school class who are not. For example, in an ethics class, the prof asked us (if we were comfortable) to raise our hands if we were pro-choice. Out of a class of about 200 or so (estimating how many attended the lecture), the vast majority raised their hands. About 20 or so raised their hands as pro-life.

A few things I am impressed with about Jefferson. I personally am happy with their teaching style -- it is mostly lecture based, with some small discussion groups. I like being taught the basic information, learning it, and then incorporating it further using clinical examples, which is usually the approach. They try to provide us with lots of clinical examples, and visits to clinics to learn about patients and illnesses.

I also have been very impressed with how receptive the faculty and school are to our input. They are really anxious to hear what we like and don't like and how we'd like to see things improved.

Things that I haven't loved: I wish that Jefferson were affiliated with an undergrad institution. You miss out on the facilities and events of a large university when you got to a free-standing medical school. For instance, I personally think the library is crappy. The gym leaves something to be desired. But students here seem happy enough and able to study and work out. I often go and use the UPenn library, or study at coffee shops. There also also other gyms nearby that are more fancy if you like that, and they can be cheap.

I also came from Boston and this has been one of the harder adjustments. I was expecting Philly to be a larger city. It is much smaller than Boston, and I like Boston a lot more -- although Philly's character is growing on me. There are certainly lots of little neighborhoods (china town, italian market, south street etc), but nothing on the scale of Boston. The subway is more like the Commuter Rail rather than the T. I take buses if I want to go somewhere "far" in the city. Mostly I walk, and it's great that Jefferson is very central. It's also an adjustment because Boston is more segregated -- poor from comfortable. It's more integrated in this way in Center City. You're not hanging out in Coolidge Corner or Davis Square. It's a little closer to Central Square (without necessarily the funky shops -- look to South Street for that).

Sorry for such a long post, but there are so many things you could say about your school! Email me with any further questions.

-J
 
hey everyone,

thank you for the helpful information!
i've decided to go! i just can't resist.
i was born there, i grew up around there. . .
when i was very little, my dad was a bartender at Moriarty's and Doc Watson's. . .
i feel like i'm almost a legacy. almost. 😉

i knew it was a good idea to gather opinions from SDNers. not only am i now set on going, but you've all managed to get me really psyched about the place again!


:clap:
 
Also, right now Amtrak is even cheaper than usual -- you can go for about $100 -- if you combine their online deal + another discount, like student advantage or AAA or something.

Also I feel like I've seen deals with USAirways (not sure on airline) on Boston-Philly fares -- approx $118 or so. Shorter than Amtrak!

One last interview tidbit -- be prepared that there will be a TON of people interviewing on the same day as you. It is a very busy day, not much downtime. But they give you the essential info without wasting your time.

Good luck and have fun!
 
Originally posted by banannie
hey everyone,

thank you for the helpful information!
i've decided to go! i just can't resist.
i was born there, i grew up around there. . .
when i was very little, my dad was a bartender at Moriarty's and Doc Watson's. . .
i feel like i'm almost a legacy. almost. 😉

i knew it was a good idea to gather opinions from SDNers. not only am i now set on going, but you've all managed to get me really psyched about the place again!

Moriarty's, I love that place. And it is literally just a block away from Jeff's classes.
Good luck on the interview!
 
whenever i buy tickets on amtrak, they won't let me combine discounts, for some reason. am i doing something wrong?

although, i do love their "blue man group" deal --- basically any train going to/from Boston or NY is 20% off. (it's promotion code V529, everyone!) That's saved me a lot of money this interview season. though i have yet to see the blue man group . . .

Moriarty's has an incredible list of beers on tap. One thing that scares me about Jefferson is that if I were to end up going there, I'd be in great danger of becoming an alcoholic. I'm a little bit too excited about their bars . . .
 
I'll be interviewing there this wednesday; anyone have any pointers??

I normally fly down to philly, but I can't stay over on a sunday so the fares are insane. Taking amtrak instead.
 
Check this out.

http://stacks.msnbc.com/news/825053.asp
http://www.ivymedia.com/dragoncoach/

If you don't mind switching buses in NYC, you could technically go to Philly and back to Boston with less than $50 spent.

However, I seriously believe that you guys overplay the importance of med school curriculum and classmates per se. In the end, every med school has some profs who are not interested in teaching, has some gunner classmates with premed mentality, etc. I don't understand why you want to go all the way to philly. If you really think that you will like Philly better than NYC, then go ahead. Otherwise, I don't see anything that Jefferson has while Mount Sinai does not (and vice versa).

About H/P/F, I actually think that that is the worst system out there. If they are going to discourage competition, go all the way to p/f. If they are not, then keep A/B/C because if you don't get honors level of work, you will at least be compensated with a B in this system. Otherwise your pass at 84% is the same as some other guy in your class who will also pass, albeit at 68%. If they say that in a grade system, most people will get B's anyway, then keep it because H/P/F awards those A students with the same grades (i.e. Honors) but penalize those hard-working students who might not make the honors cut and yet still get the same grade (i.e. pass) as a number of kids who don't care and want to slack off starting at 1st day of med schoo.
 
This gripe about H/P/F is one of the common ones from people who dislike the H/P/F system. I think it might be better if it were just P/F, but then people might worry they couldn't at ALL distinguish themselves in terms of their grades. It is sometimes dissapointing when you are only one question away from honors, but it happens.

The most important thing to keep in mind, however, is that your grades are one of the LEAST important things that residency programs will look at. High on their interest list IS how you score on the boards. If you think about it, someone who consistently got an 88 in every class and missed honors (highly unlikely that anyone would have this misfortune) is going to score MAJORLY higher than someone who got a 70 in every class and also passed. Your board scores are very important. And nothing gets you great board scores like learning the material consistently well (like someone who is often missing honors -- in that unlikely scenario).

So in the end it's a moot point. That's the way I think of it anyway. What really matters is your personality and the type of grading system you'd flourish under. If you want to go to a graded system so you can get A's and be ranked better than those who got B's, chose a grading system. Beware though that they are getting harder to find -- generally the really quality schools have a variation on P/F. I am really happy with the grading system. At Jefferson, for all the classes before mine, they were not only graded by letter, but by points! So an 87 really differed from an 81. It was more miserable for the students (they are all jealous of our H/P/F) and I have to assume that a lot of grade grubbing occured (ugh).

Just my two cents.
 
Top