How do residency programs actually choose their residents?

[xxir01]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Genuinely curious here.
I’m applying to a program I respect a lot — been working hard for this for years. A little background - I have strong work ethic, aways reading and learning, 3.6 GPA & I took feedback seriously
But it’s a very competitive program.

I've seen some really well-prepared externs rotate through — many of them are outgoing, polished, and seem to shine socially. I’m not always the most standout person in the room, and I know that.

Still, I try to show up every day, ask good questions, help where I can, and just… be solid. But sometimes I wonder: how much does personality and presence weigh vs. work ethic and quiet consistency?

Also, be real with me — can programs usually tell when someone’s being fake? Like, super performative, “I’m everyone’s best friend” vibes? Or does that actually work?

I know interviews will matter too, and I’ll give it my all. But I want to understand realistically: What are programs really looking for when they rank students?

Would love to hear from attendings, residents, or anyone who’s been in that selection room. What stands out? What’s overrated? How do you see through the noise?

Not fishing for validation — just trying to see where I really stand and how to keep growing. Appreciate any honest insight.

 

[Hybrocure]

It really depends on the program. In my experience now as an attending, residents at programs want incoming residents to be someone they can get along with and be reliable. A normal person who can get work done and not make life harder for everyone else.

Attendings on the other hand at a program, particularly directors can care about any one stupid thing under the sun. It’s no use trying to read their minds

 

[Adam Smasher]

 

[Adam Smasher]

 

[Weirdy]

If you're at a program that values butt kissing, being fake, and resumes- that's the type of applicant they will pick.
If you're at a program that has normal people who can see through all that- they'll select a normal genuine person they can rely on for 3 years.

Yes, we can see through all of that.

 

[Adam Smasher]

 

[Adam Smasher]

One more then I promise I'm done

 

[Sendin_Toes_2market]

Just work hard and be prepared. Don’t take things personally.

The residency does not make the
doctor. The doctor does.

 

[Feli]

Programs don't choose in different ways.
They all basically want the best candidates they can find (free of obvious red flags or deal-breakers).
That goes without saying, year after decade. Tale as old as time.

The only exception is that a few programs are very strict about choosing only among clerks (yet they obviously broaden the search if they strike out there). But in any year, the qualities of being friendly, smart, quick-thinking, attractive, tall, charming, confident, etc etc (just as in nearly any aspect of life).

It's basically like dating... try for whatever you want, but you're usually going to end up where some programs clearly have better options than you, some of them you're their best option (but maybe not into them), and some are roughly right (you'd like to do a bit better, maybe they'd prefer a bit better... but it's a match).

Now, some student do choose in different ways (geography over quality, quality over geography, program with easier hours, programs they are sure they can get vs ones that might not want them, etc).

But yeah, just try for any that you like that you are reasonably qualified (gpa/rank), try for any clerkships that weren't places you absolutely would NOT want to go... and then add a few safety nets where most of their apps will be below their level. It costs almost nothing to interview and rank more programs, but it's foolish to do ones you obviously have no shot (denied clerkship, did terrible on clerk month, didn't clerk when they have MANY strong clerks every cycle, way below program avg gpa/rank, etc). GL

 

[Hybrocure]

Programs don't choose in different ways.

Gotta do a hard disagree on this one. There’s definitely a spectrum. Everything else you said is spot on.

 

[wakaflocka88]

I externed at my #1 choice program in January, 3 weeks before interviews and got it. Very competitive program and PD said I just outworked everyone that rotated before me

 

[SoleSucking]

1. Be normal
2. Work hard
3. Not be a dummy

Bonus: be attractive.

 

[iridocyclitiss]

Current resident right now at a pretty good program. I feel like its pretty easy to read people. do your best and don't worry about anything else. This batch of students is also pretty awful so the likelihood of you matching where you want is probably more likely than you think.

 

[ParNoMoney]

Always be yourself, unless it's not working for you

 

[Bluecollarmed]

Everything everyone else said. Another addition is interest. We'd occasionally rank students higher if they actually showed interest, joined virtual academics etc even if they weren't academically as high or our favorite student on any given month. I went to a good program where residents basically decided who was coming so you definitely looked for people who you wanted to hangout with and had similar interests. These things don't fit in boxes though honestly. For some candidates, the academics or their knowledge throughout the month weighed more and sometimes the social aspect did. Difficult to give an across the board answer when talking human psyche and preference. But at the end of the day its a job and if you weren't reliable or willing to work hard during one month you better believe no one at a good program is going to believe you'll do it over 3 years.

 

[Robin-jay]

Be a "yes man" to your seniors and attendings, you'll do fine.
Be kind and reasonable to your juniors, you'll be fine.

It's not complicated.

Normal, easy to work with, will work with you and not against you, works moderately hard (not even that hard is fine), and if you don't know something don't be a dummy and do things out of your knowledge zone.

Very easy.