- Joined
- Mar 12, 2014
- Messages
- 7
- Reaction score
- 2
if someone is good at understanding, but not memorizing, what techniques can they use to memorize vast amounts of data ?
Spaced repetition, visualization, motivation on why you need to memorize, understanding in the integration of data, and make a rap out of data and you can sing it during a shower everyday until it sticks into your head.
Look into spaced repetition programs like Supermemo and Anki. Biggest improvement to my learning process I've ever made. IMO Supermemo is much better than Anki, but it has a somewhat steep learning curve. Supermemo also costs $60 whereas Anki is free, but that's a small price to pay for how useful it is, especially if you use it for all of your classes and into med school.
Go download Anki for free and play around with it to see if you think this is something that would be beneficial for you.
So, as someone who has spent the past year training myself to study solely via Anki (and I'm loving it!) what are the advantages of Supermemo? Pros/cons vs Anki?
Short term memory is about half a minute, so no, anki and other methods are not meant for that or help with it.These are helpful for committing things to short term memory; however, for long term memory, I think more is needed. What I advise is to relate the things that are new and unfamiliar to things that are already familiar and known. That's why I think that is important to have a very strong foundation when going to college. Think of your previous knowledge as a cognitive scaffold upon which you can attach new ideas. Cognitive psychologists maintain that this is how people learn and it has worked for me. That's why I think synthesis of information throughout a course and with your previous course work is always useful. Concept mapping has helped some relate ideas in the past, but I tend to use this less personally.
Hmmm...when was the last time you used Anki? Because a lot of the features you mention ARE present in its current incarnation. For example, Ctrl+v works fine for pictures (I use the snipping tool for that too), there's a stats window which shows your response time, times (and percent) answered correctly for new, young, and mature cards, you can adjust the Ease and learning intervals (similar to your 'forgetting index?', etc.I only used Anki for a few weeks before discovering Supermemo and switching over, so you can probably speak more intelligently about it than I can. Basically Anki introduced me to the concept of SR, and then I decided to explore what other options were available before committing heavily to one. After doing a bunch of research on all the programs that are out there, Supermemo seemed like clearly the best choice to me. Supermemo is a pain in the butt to learn but it's easy to use once you get the hang of it, and it feels like a much more powerful and effective program so I think it's worth the trouble in the end.
The biggest pro (to me) for Supermemo is that it uses a much more advanced algorithm than Anki (and every other SR program that I could find). Anki is using SM-2 algorithm which was designed in the 1980's... Supermemo is now on SM-15. The rigidity of Anki's algorithm was really off-putting for me. I hated looking at a card for Anki and seeing that all it was doing was rescheduling the card for 3, 4 or 5 days from now based on which option I picked. Supermemo feels much more responsive: it collects and uses data on your overall retention rate, response time, etc. I trust it more to make good scheduling decisions and to adapt to my performance.
I appreciate how Supermemo lets you actually see all the data it collects, and do things like adjust the forgetting index. You can sort of manually do the same thing Anki but it's awkward and I trust Supermemo to do a better job of it than I could do.
When it comes to making cards, I'm torn. I was a computer science major for a while during undergrad and I'm pretty good with HTML. I enjoy how Anki lets you separate things out into different fields and then dynamically create cards. Makes it easy to quickly put a bunch of info in and then make a ton of cards super fast. I've also seen people use the image occlusion addon and though I haven't played with it myself, it looks amazing for making a lot of cards quickly.
On the other hand, card creation is reasonably quick and easy in Supermemo as well once you get the hang of it. Templates save time, and card creation feels more flexible than Anki's. It took some fiddling at first but I figured out a good way to quickly do image occlusion in Supermemo that doesn't require downloading an addon or anything. Not as fast as Anki, but fast enough.
Copy/pasting images onto your supermemo cards is a lot easier than it is in Anki. I make a lot of my supermemo cards with the windows "snipping tool": just grab a piece of text or an image or whatever, click onto the supermemo component and control+v.
Supermemo is not pretty, is not user-friendly, and is slower in many ways. I'm a power user and the first two of those problems did not bother me at all. The third problem can be overcome somewhat once you figure out how to use the program efficiently. Fast card creation is also not my primary concern because I'm going to be studying these cards for a long time and then using them for MCAT review. I don't mind spending an extra 5 seconds per card when I'm going to be using them for the next 2+ years (and maybe beyond if I want to go back and review). Same goes for if/when I get to med school and am studying for boards - an extra few seconds spent creating a card isn't a big deal when you're going to be using those same cards for 2 years of studying.
My general impression is that Supermemo is simply a better program... if you're willing to put up with it (which most people aren't when alternatives are so easy to use) and aren't intimidated by it. If the creators would just hire somebody to make them a decent website, overhaul the UI and make a smart phone app, they'd be making millions I bet. (if you look at supermemo.net and supermemo.com, they have sort of done this... But the phone app doesn't really mesh well with the PC version and I haven't been able to figure it out. I just do my studying on a tablet running full version of supermemo and then sync databases between tablet and PC)
Short term memory is about half a minute, so no, anki and other methods are not meant for that or help with it.
Spaced repetition is all about the longer retention!You're right, I used the term in artfully. I meant for optimum retention for longer periods of time (which is not the same as saying that it is short term memory - you're absolutely right).
Hmmm...when was the last time you used Anki? Because a lot of the features you mention ARE present in its current incarnation...
Yeah, I found Anki's default intervals really annoying. I like the program a lot more now that I've put in the time to adjust the intervals to suit me. I suppose that's the advantage of Supermemo.Sounds like you are making really good use of Anki.
I guess my main gripe is that while it's a joy to create cards with Anki and the phone app automatically syncing is amazing, I feel that it just doesn't do as good a job when it comes to actually LEARNING the info, which is the whole reason we're using SR in the first place. I don't want to manually fiddle with intervals, and I don't think a system as simple as "it was hard? See again in 2 days. It was easy? See again in 5 days" can be anything close to optimal especially for retention of info over longer periods of time (ie MCAT and USMLE studying). If you're cramming for a test a week from now it probably doesn't make any difference which program you use.
On the other hand it works fo, maybe I will appreciate Anki's usability more when I'm in med school making 1000 cards per day... It could also potentially be really beneficial to be able to share cards with classmates. You could theoretically do this pretty easily with Supermemo, but the process is infinitely more streamlined for Anki.
Side note:
I don't really see variation in cards and remembering something based on the way a card looked as a problem. In fact, when I used paper flashcards, I did this on purpose. I used different colored cards and laid them out differently to help distinguish them and make them easier to remember. When I would see the term/concept/whatever in context, I would see the corresponding card in my head. This association ("oh, that's the pink card!") helps me, but everybody is different of course. As long as you can remember the question that goes with the answer, I guess!
Look into spaced repetition programs like Supermemo and Anki. Biggest improvement to my learning process I've ever made. IMO Supermemo is much better than Anki, but it has a somewhat steep learning curve. Supermemo also costs $60 whereas Anki is free, but that's a small price to pay for how useful it is, especially if you use it for all of your classes and into med school.
Check out this video for an example of how powerful Anki is:
Go download Anki for free and play around with it to see if you think this is something that would be beneficial for you.
I am a terrible SDNer...I rarely, if ever, watch embedded videos. I don't like watching videos if other people are in the room (which they always are), and I'm too lazy to get my headphones (and would feel too antisocial wearing them.) Maybe I should give it a shot, though...Great video!
Srsly?