How enforceable is a non-compete really?

Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Medman2737

Full Member
15+ Year Member
Greetings all,

Currently I'm in the muck of a divorce from my employer.

As a bit of back story, I am currently burning out a non-compete with my former employer-a two year, 20 mile radius that is set to expire in September, 2027.

Needless to say, my current arrangement only lasted a year and he began charging me overhead about six months into the relationship and I drowned . . . I am currently bringing home about $3000/month because of this wretched place.

Now that I am leaving, my current employer is wanting the original $130K that he fronted for the first six months of my salary AND two years of salary as a non-compete buyout . . . a total of about $630K (which I absolutely refuse to pay)

My question is: Do I just move across town and start with my new practice? It is not far enough outside the non-compete radius, but I can't pay that outrageous amount!

How difficult is it for my current employer to come after me? Wouldn't he end up spending a decent amount in legal fees to not make it worth his while?

Any advice appreciated

PS-I really don't want to go to a lawyer about this, their worse than everyone with their charges - $600 to return a simple e-mail!!!
 
Post in private forum so we can look at the verbiage of your actual contract

Contracts in general are enforceable, otherwise what would be the point. There would have to be something egregious ie too restrictive or something happened during your employment that breached your contract on his end.
 
you can apply.




yes, noncompetes are enforceable, depending on the state and local environment.

yes, you need an attorney otherwise you will get screwed.



truth be told, you're gonna get screwed either way, but at least you will know the attorney doing it rather than the other entity...
 
the contract is void if he committed fraud. so if there is anything on HIS side that didn't live up to the contract, then he can't enforce the non compete. but the devil is in the details and you need a lawyer to determine the bounds of the contract. you also may need a judge/magistrate ruling on this prior to opening across town
 
I think the consensus is that it is enforceable enough to need a lawyer to look at. Preferably one different from the one who agreed to this contract to begin with. Still post in private forum for advice but you need a good lawyer
 
Even if it's not clear cut, if they sue, as defendant you have to respond and continue fighting or else they win, so your bills can add up quickly.
 
The answer is that it depends. It depends on the state. It depends on the contract terms.

Most have a non-compete buyout clause in the contract.

If your state allows them, you should assume that they are enforceable.
 
my current employer is wanting the original $130K that he fronted for the first six months of my salary AND two years of salary as a non-compete buyout . . . a total of about $630K (which I absolutely refuse to pay)

My question is: Do I just move across town and start with my new practice? It is not far enough outside the non-compete radius, but I can't pay that outrageous amount!

PS-I really don't want to go to a lawyer about this, their worse than everyone with their charges - $600 to return a simple e-mail!!!
You're potentially on the hook for 130k, you want to knowingly violate your non compete and hope that it simply works out, and you don't want to get an attorney? This is remarkably bad judgement.

You need to get off of the Internet and get a lawyer who can give you a real answer to these questions which will have extremely material significance to your life.
 
A long time ago I paid a lawyer $3,500 to work out an employment contract for me. As a fellow, that price stung. As a mid-career attending I’m glad that there are some basic protections I had included that I may need to tap into someday.
 
it really depends on the state and where you live. if you live in manhattan 20 mile radius is too big. if you live in dallas, i would just set up shop outside of 20 radius and setup another shop next to him after 2 yrs. but really spending the money on attorney is important in your case
 
One thing that Abbott did before getting defeated yesterday is sign a new Texas non compete law.

Now it is

5 miles around primary practice only
if doc is fired, non compete is void
buyout cannot exceed one year salary
Noncompete cannot exceed one year.

So you have to believe that very few people would pay 1 years salary if they could just move 5.1 miles away from their primary site (odds are the a secondary site is close by).

It is not retroactive to older non-competes but when a contract renews (most renew every year) the non-compete then takes effect.