One of the other advantages I want to point out is that when you extubate deep, there is no STIMULUS to cause the vomiting. That's most likely the missing piece of information that the staunch defenders of pulling the tube awake are not considering.
The pt is laying there and whatever in the stomach is not coming up. It's not randomly gonna shoot out of the stomach when they are just sitting there breathing.
At a certain point the pt senses the stimulus at the vocal cords and then the bucking and reaction to the tube also causes intra abdominal pressure to raise. THAT is what causes the stomach content to move.
The reason you haven't seen it in 20k cases is probably because in your 20k cases you pts never had a stimulus to increase their intra-abdominal pressure.