I believe part of their agreement to the FTC when they approved the merger was that Caremark have to reimburse CVS pharmacies the same as other pharmacies.
The problem with that now is it doesn’t matter what they reimburse their regular pharmacies. Reimbursing their stores at a loss allows them to say they are not “profitable”, cut hours, avoid taxes, and get tax deductions.
Meanwhile Caremark profits can be shifted to tax states where they avoid paying taxes. It’s all a numbers game.
I am guessing Arkansas is a tax friendly state for them to be giving their pharmacies that much extra in reimbursement. In NY, most of the scripts filled are at a loss or break even.
Damn if you do, damn if you don’t.
Only way to win is to get rid of PBMs together.