Inconsistent/interesting applicant -- what to do to improve

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

tommymomo24

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2015
Messages
36
Reaction score
44
Hi everyone, I just want opinions / advice / encouragement since all of this has been on my mind but I can't disclose this information to everyone I meet.
 
Last edited:
I am unsure what you're looking for? At this point, you sound like you're doing everything you can.
 
Hi everyone, I just want opinions / advice / encouragement since all of this has been on my mind but I can't disclose this information to everyone I meet.

I have a 3.4 GPA from a top tier non-Ivy undergrad (finance/business) and went straight into healthcare consulting for 2 years post grad. Struggled with severe mental illness in college and still recovering. My undergrad transcript reflects this -- a couple semesters with 3.9s taking 18 credits and a few 3.1s while taking like 12 credits. I'm an inconsistent person when it comes to my mental health/academics and I think my records reflect that. From a family of emergency medicine physicians (both parents and my sister), got to focus on preventative/primary care including policy for providers while in consulting and thats both my professional interest and incorporated into my personal statement (or will be). In high school, I was accepted into an early assurance premed program at a mediocre school but purposely chose business at a top tier school for both the challenge and because, in all honesty, I did not appreciate healthcare at all or the way its run -- I was raised with a "if its not broken dont fix it" emergency medicine mindset - again, in my personal statement.

I did my 12-18mo post bacc (including MCAT) at University of Washington and will finish somewhere between a 3.8-3.9 for my science GPA (3.5-3.6 cumulative GPA) and during that time I did 4months of pro bono consulting work. I have made the personal/professional decision NOT to apply this summer for a few reasons:

1. I'm inconsistent. I realize that. My science GPA (all at UW) was between 3.5-3.6 my first few months as I readjusted to the college environment that had produced numerous panic/anxiety attacks for me in undergrad, and while handling the pro bono project I was doing. The rest of my quarters are 3.8-4.0s, but last quarter I had a mix of physical illness/panic attack the week of finals (I was in 17 credits=> physics, bio, biochem and organic chemistry) and will have "Incompletes" indicated on my transcript even after I make-up those finals (this March and this December). Im in counseling and plan to take overtime credits (15-18) this summer as my last quarter and I know Im capable of achieving a 4.0.
2. I would like to work professionally for 2 years until 2020 matriculation and currently have an offer to return to strategy consulting as well as an offer from a healthcare venture firm. I get to "shadow" executive physicians as well as practicing clinicians at my clients, which is awesome. These offers are in California, where I would establish residency for UC school applications.
3. I would like to take 5 credits a quarter the next several quarters while working full time to potentially raise my GPA and show that I'm consistently doing well. I did this for 1 quarter while in consulting to start my post bacc and actually feel like it made me work harder (I got an A in that course)
4. I've just started therapy, need some time to get my health in order and truly feel like I've recovered from what I struggled with during adolescence and young adulthood.

I don't want to list all of my extracurriculars etc etc but I dont have research experience beyond industry (from consulting) and am not really interested in clinical research / those types of med schools anyways. Im good with my extracurriculars from college and volunteer/shadow regularly just as a personal hobby so I dont have issues with any of that. I perform stand up and storytelling, where I talk a lot about my childhood/mental illness lightheartedly and am considering sending that video in to med schools as part of my application/extension of my personal statement.

Everyone who knows me tells me I'm a really interesting candidate but a lot of them don't know how much I've struggled since high school. They think I'm this finance/consulting guru who has crushed my post bacc and will get into any school I want (to be fair, they dont understand the app / rejection process either).

Im studying for the MCAT and am confident I can do well, but Im not feeling confident about my application in general and just want some guidance in terms of how else I can improve. I realize its a numbers game and that I had red flags all across my transcript and this has been nothing but discouraging even when I continue to get better academically/mentally.

Thank you.

You should apply when you feel you are ready. Lots of schools don’t look at your grades too closely, they just see gpa. Some schools will look at your trends and look for an upward trend. This is more the case for a lower gpa. Your gpa while lower is still fine, plus science gpa is good.

The main recipe for getting interview.
Gpa that is higher than minimums.
MCAT is average or above.
ECs are average or above.
Personal statement is average or above.
All of that balanced into a score that is compared to current applicants.

Then getting in; schools try to compile all of that and your interview into some type of score and accept and reject people. If you are average everywhere, it’s a reject. If your are below minimums or do terrible in an interview, auto reject. If you are awesome except something, you have a good chance.

Schools fill the spots. There is no shortage of applicants. So as long as your holistic self is in the top third of applicants you will get in somewhere. If you are not ready and need to figure out yourself or if you need to improve to be in the top third, it’s probably worth waiting.

You can take this with a grain of salt. I’m no adcom, just another pre med
 
Hi everyone, I just want opinions / advice / encouragement since all of this has been on my mind but I can't disclose this information to everyone I meet.

I have a 3.4 GPA from a top tier non-Ivy undergrad (finance/business) and went straight into healthcare consulting for 2 years post grad. Struggled with severe mental illness in college and still recovering. My undergrad transcript reflects this -- a couple semesters with 3.9s taking 18 credits and a few 3.1s while taking like 12 credits. I'm an inconsistent person when it comes to my mental health/academics and I think my records reflect that. From a family of emergency medicine physicians (both parents and my sister), got to focus on preventative/primary care including policy for providers while in consulting and thats both my professional interest and incorporated into my personal statement (or will be). In high school, I was accepted into an early assurance premed program at a mediocre school but purposely chose business at a top tier school for both the challenge and because, in all honesty, I did not appreciate healthcare at all or the way its run -- I was raised with a "if its not broken dont fix it" emergency medicine mindset - again, in my personal statement.

I did my 12-18mo post bacc (including MCAT) at University of Washington and will finish somewhere between a 3.8-3.9 for my science GPA (3.5-3.6 cumulative GPA) and during that time I did 4months of pro bono consulting work. I have made the personal/professional decision NOT to apply this summer for a few reasons:

1. I'm inconsistent. I realize that. My science GPA (all at UW) was between 3.5-3.6 my first few months as I readjusted to the college environment that had produced numerous panic/anxiety attacks for me in undergrad, and while handling the pro bono project I was doing. The rest of my quarters are 3.8-4.0s, but last quarter I had a mix of physical illness/panic attack the week of finals (I was in 17 credits=> physics, bio, biochem and organic chemistry) and will have "Incompletes" indicated on my transcript even after I make-up those finals (this March and this December). Im in counseling and plan to take overtime credits (15-18) this summer as my last quarter and I know Im capable of achieving a 4.0.
2. I would like to work professionally for 2 years until 2020 matriculation and currently have an offer to return to strategy consulting as well as an offer from a healthcare venture firm. I get to "shadow" executive physicians as well as practicing clinicians at my clients, which is awesome. These offers are in California, where I would establish residency for UC school applications.
3. I would like to take 5 credits a quarter the next several quarters while working full time to potentially raise my GPA and show that I'm consistently doing well. I did this for 1 quarter while in consulting to start my post bacc and actually feel like it made me work harder (I got an A in that course)
4. I've just started therapy, need some time to get my health in order and truly feel like I've recovered from what I struggled with during adolescence and young adulthood.

I don't want to list all of my extracurriculars etc etc but I dont have research experience beyond industry (from consulting) and am not really interested in clinical research / those types of med schools anyways. Im good with my extracurriculars from college and volunteer/shadow regularly just as a personal hobby so I dont have issues with any of that. I perform stand up and storytelling, where I talk a lot about my childhood/mental illness lightheartedly and am considering sending that video in to med schools as part of my application/extension of my personal statement.

Everyone who knows me tells me I'm a really interesting candidate but a lot of them don't know how much I've struggled since high school. They think I'm this finance/consulting guru who has crushed my post bacc and will get into any school I want (to be fair, they dont understand the app / rejection process either).

Im studying for the MCAT and am confident I can do well, but Im not feeling confident about my application in general and just want some guidance in terms of how else I can improve. I realize its a numbers game and that I had red flags all across my transcript and this has been nothing but discouraging even when I continue to get better academically/mentally.

Thank you.
A continuous stretch of academic excellence will allay Adcoms concerns about your mental health issues.

But keep in mind that medical school is a furnace, and I've seen it break even healthy students. The #1 reason my school loses students to withdrawal, dismissal or LOA is to unresolved mental health issues.
 
I can't recommend CA residency to someone interested in medical school.
Only two of the UC schools have a stated preference for CA residents and one of them is mission-based.
That effectively leaves a single school with 108 MD seats that has a preference for its own undergrads and those with a commitment to serve the SJV (thus 31 of those seats went to Latinos last year).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Top