Hi All,
Have been wanting to ask about this case discussion. So, I wonder, is this (a good example) of the academic dogma that some of you talk about? Real word versus residency stuff?
For example, when I observed a CT Anesthesiologist and friend for a week, he took me aside and made a point to say: anesthesia starts with making sure you can ventilate. Period. So, I thought it was a takeaway that I'd hang on to as the time between now and medical school/residency passes. i.e. Can you mask ventilate? If not, why induce? Because, if you cannot, and the patient has lost spontaneous resipirations, oh darn.
But then I read a lot of the replies here, Sevo's in particular, and he brings up the discussion and the debate, and the majority of the peeps on this board say, "why bother?" So, I understand this to be: if you induce, and patient cannot be ventilated, you're not going to wait for propofol to wear off (the FRC and desaturation argument) so, you're going to paralyze (make for optimal intubation) and try and intubate anyway. This is what I'm gathering, as Jeff05 said.
So, my question is, understanding the above, why would you induce in the first place without assuring you can mask ventilate by giving it a go? I understand that once you induce, in a theoretical patient that let's say cannot be ventilated or tubed w/o paralytic, you might have to move forward and paralyze and do whatever the heck you have to do to get the tube in, BUT, why not avoid that unknown and mask ventilate? What do you lose?
I guess that then begs the thought, in the perfect world, you induce obese patient and w/o paralytic you stick a tube in. Done. So, when that doesn't happen, and you have chosen to take a known/assumed difficult airway (obese or prior history of) and induce WITHOUT mask ventilating, why, with all my naivete, would someone knowingly burn that bridge? When you don't have to?
I understand that either way, you must ultimately induce, right? But, do you really have to? If you try to mask ventilate, and fail, would you still induce normally? Change things up a bit? Get an emergency airway kit within arms' reach. Chill out and get some support. Awake FOB thoughts start churning, I dunno. If so, and you would not change a thing after failing a mask ventilation, then that answers the question, and I've learned something. But isn't that the point of assuring you can mask ventilate in first place?
Maybe, if I'm lucky, somebody can ask ME a question, or present a scenario is what I mean, so I can clearly see the logic in case X or case Y and how those scenarios change. That would be a NICE exercise... 🙂
Curious,
THANKS IN ADVANCE
D712