I am neither pro nor con, but this article makes for interesting reading:
www.tampabay.com/news/health/medicine/article1061189.ece
www.tampabay.com/news/health/medicine/article1061189.ece
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
Ok, granted there may be a negative slant. So, using apparently Ross published data, here are there "accomplishments" as a MEDICAL SCHOOL:This article if one can call it that is seriously flawed and extremely negatively biased . Ross has graduated almost 10 000 fully licensed doctors in every speciality . Why didnt the author mention this accomplishment ?...
Why move to this to pre-allo, it was a discussion about medical education and residencies, why not keep it in the general residency section where residents (both carib grads and AMGs) can discuss it.
...I would like to move it to pre-allo, where people who are trying to decide between US MD vs. DO vs. caribbean MD can read this and take this article into account.
I think this is a topic posted by a medical student and not a premed... It does have impact on those that are at Ross and potential residency issues. I think leaving it in general residency forum is reasonable.Why move to this to pre-allo, it was a discussion about medical education and residencies, why not keep it in the general residency section where residents (both carib grads and AMGs) can discuss it.
If someone here thinks a parallel discussion may be useful in pre-med forums, I am certain they can easily post a new thread for that group....I think that that's something that pre-meds need to consider if they're thinking about going to the Caribbean.
I think it's more important for people considering which med school to attend to read that article ...
You really do not need to strip this one out of General residency issues forum.scratch that idea....
It has implications at all levels, be it med-students you may be rotating with in clinicals or even your fellow residents...apparently you do....
4. Most ross grads take more than 4 years to graduate not because they fail something, but because Ross does not have enough clinical rotations. Hence, some students end up waiting for a rotation to be open for them. This is a fault of Ross -- they should simply take less students so they have enough rotations for all of them.
5. The reports of poor rotations / poor training is concerning. I have worked with a few Ross grads and all have done well, but I can't imagine trying to keep track of the quality of all rotations when students are rotating in many different locations.
Actually wasn't posting here... thus wrong audience...I am posting this here...
It does have impact on those that are at Ross and potential residency issues.
Yes. I have read numerous WAMC posts from USA grads. Then I hear them speak about how they are good guys/gals, nice people, got poor scores, think this, that, or the other social issue should count more. I hear how the "ERAS" filtering is unfair... I think the person already at Ross needs to hear some of the fears and bias they face and understand more then the sales pitch of positivity they may be getting on the island. They need to realize, their road is harder, possibly harder then USA med-students and as such, not get distracted. They do not have a choice to be average.... many are below average thus entry to Ross. Now, while in Ross they MUST be ABOVE average. They must "rock" the USMLE. They must pound harder then ever before in their clinicals within the USA. Yes, I think it does matter.Does it?...
correction, no similar/paralell thread allowed....
Yes. I have read numerous WAMC posts from USA grads. Then I hear them speak about how they are good guys/gals, nice people, got poor scores, think this, that, or the other social issue should count more. I hear how the "ERAS" filtering is unfair... I think the person already at Ross needs to hear some of the fears and bias they face and understand more then the sales pitch of positivity they may be getting on the island. They need to realize, their road is harder, possibly harder then USA med-students and as such, not get distracted. They do not have a choice to be average.... many are below average thus entry to Ross. Now, while in Ross they MUST be ABOVE average. They must "rock" the USMLE. They must pound harder then ever before in their clinicals within the USA. Yes, I think it does matter.
I think I read somewhere on these forums from someone else, "no social promotion in medicine...". I think that is absolutely a requirement. These are human lives in which mistakes cause death. Poor clinical education means poor physical examination and/or diagnosis. So, "social promotion" and caribean purchased diploma will NOT be enough. Ross students need to understand that and work hard to assure they are the best they can be....
The getting into University Med/pedes slot and flunking out is NOT a GenRes issue....But how does someone score an IM/Peds spot in a university program, and not even make it 2 months?Why move to this to pre-allo, it was a discussion about medical education and residencies, why not keep it in the general residency section where residents (both carib grads and AMGs) can discuss it....(I'd agree it's a little out of place in pre-allo though.)
I suspect folks applying Caribean do so after their GPAs & MCATS are done and the interviews/offers are not coming in and they want to be an MD. Will leave this thread for the premeds.... most of whom have pretty much set their GPAs, etc...It was an article about the quality of education you get from Ross ...and how hard it is to get a residency (and stay in a residency) after coming out of one of those schools. Some of those people that the article talks about didn't even finish med school there, and aren't even eligible for residency...
I think it's more important for people considering which med school to attend to read that article than it is for residents...I agree with what you're saying. I'm not saying that none of this is important...
...I moved the thread because I think that the people who benefit the most from hearing about the cautionary tales coming out of Ross are those who are in the position to choose. You can choose to try and bump up your MCAT more and get into a DO school. You can choose to throw medicine away entirely. You can choose to become a nurse instead...
The getting into University Med/pedes slot and flunking out is NOT a GenRes issue.I suspect folks applying Caribean do so after their GPAs & MCATS are done and the interviews/offers are not coming in and they want to be an MD. Will leave this thread for the premeds.... most of whom have pretty much set their GPAs, etc...
OK, got the message.
This article if one can call it that is seriously flawed and extremely negatively biased . Ross has graduated almost 10 000 fully licensed doctors in every speciality . Why didnt the author mention this accomplishment ?
Due to the large classes there are bound to be people who do not make it through the process. Choosing a few examples of such people who fail and writing a horrendous article such as this one is extremely unfair . This article is loaded with inaccuracies and straw arguements . Poor writing .
What's sad is that is Ross is considered one of the "Top 4" of Caribbean med schools and still has such horrible results at 4 and 6 years out. While the other Caribbean schools may be even worse, what does it say when one of the standard bearers provides this crappy of an education with little recourse for those who invested in.
While I understand that some people have difficulties getting into med school, going to Ross does not and should not equal redemption. Further, why should US taxpayers be investing their tax money in financing education for a group of rejects who couldn't get into any American school when the graduation rate and matching rates aren't very good. Seems like a waste of taxpayer money.
While I have worked with residents from Caribbean schools and have had good experiences, I still rate their education as 2nd rate and feel they succeeded in spite of their education which many of them have told me as well. While I don't view Caribbean grads as second tier physicians I continue to believe that they should be viewed as second tier residency applicants and not match untill all AMG's have filled.
I am feeling the warmth and love😍That's exactly what you SHOULDN'T do....So please don't stop posting in the thread because you think it is restricted to pre-meds. If anything your input is more valuable than theirs given you have more experience in working with Ross students and grads.
I think this is the point that we need to consider and consider carefully. I appreciate the concept of redemption. But, let's really consider what we are dealing with, cause this "rehab program" is costing $150+million per year to produce, after 6 years, 60+% graduation rate of which only 20% can obtain a residency!!! We don't know what the residency completion rate is... I don't think any USA based med-school would last very long with around 40% fail rate/6yrs (70% fail to complete at 4yrs).... especially if you can reasonably predict a very high fail rate based on your candidate selection pool....The article also points out the need to question the legitimacy of these schools, since they receive so much federal funding.
I am all for "personal responsibility".... But, Ross stating that is like a crack dealer chastising the crack whoe for prostitution. They recruit from the desperate, undergrad pool, mostly composed of folks that have proved for several years an incapacity for independent/self directed/disciplined learning... Then, they say it's all about "personal responsibility" while collecting 100s of millions of dollars churning folks through class after class... Ross functioning under the "personal responsibility" mantra is their way of washing their hands of accountability....The one thing that's been hammered into my head is the idea of "personal responsibility" when it comes to every stage of a Ross education...
I am all for "personal responsibility".... But, Ross stating that is like a crack dealer chastising the crack whoe for prostitution. They recruit from the desperate, undergrad pool, mostly composed of folks that have proved for several years an incapacity for independent/self directed/disciplined learning... Then, they say it's all about "personal responsibility" while collecting 100s of millions of dollars churning folks through class after class... Ross functioning under the "personal responsibility" mantra is their way of washing their hands of accountability.
I was not reading a positive or negative component to your expressed experience. I was simply expressing my interpretation of what Ross was doing when citing "personal responsibility".... Again, it wasn't a you thing.👍I think you misunderstand ...When I say "personal responsibility," I don't say it as a virtue. I say it as a complaint that successful students are forced to overcome.
I agree that the article is a bit unfair. However:
1. Ross clearly has lower acceptance standards than US medical schools. In some ways this is reasonable -- it gives people a "second chance" if their GPA is low but doesn't really reflect their full potential.
2. Because of this, their large class size, etc, it's almost certain that the failure / dropout rate at Ross will be higher than US medical schools.
3. Because loans are "guaranteed" by the US Gov't (although I remain uncertain as to what that really means), US taxpayers have some vested interest in the default rate. Exactly how high the default rate should be "allowed" to be is unclear.
4. Most ross grads take more than 4 years to graduate not because they fail something, but because Ross does not have enough clinical rotations. Hence, some students end up waiting for a rotation to be open for them. This is a fault of Ross -- they should simply take less students so they have enough rotations for all of them.
5. The reports of poor rotations / poor training is concerning. I have worked with a few Ross grads and all have done well, but I can't imagine trying to keep track of the quality of all rotations when students are rotating in many different locations.
Our mission is to provide students with free, unbiased information, resources, and advising for careers in the health professions. We believe every student deserves access to trustworthy guidance, regardless of background or ability to pay.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.