Interview question?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

GenusTide

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2011
Messages
219
Reaction score
4
I was curious if any of you guys who have gone to interviews, have had any questions to the such as " would you perform an abortion and under what circumstances"? The reason I ask is because I was trying to prepare for my interview and came across this question as a commonly asked question. Is this true and how could we possibly answer this intelligently?
 
Not really.... But, honestly, it's not about preparing for individual questions. It's about preparing for the PROCESS of answering these kinds of questions. The abortion thing isn't really a hot topic anymore. That said, you ought to be able to intelligently answer questions related to abortion.... or genocide... or watching millionaires play catch.
 
...
there is no right or wrong answer for most of these questions....

in most jurisdictions, the law creates a single "right" answer on the abortion issue. Regardless of your personal beliefs, which you are always entitled to, you have to be willing to abide by the law or few institutions will want you working there. Additionally, depending on who your interviewer is, there might be a better received "right" answer for these loaded questions. A female OBGYN is more likely to have a predictable position on the abortion issue. An interviewer at a more religious school (Loma Linda) possibly will have a different view. You are allowed to know your audience. You need to show your reasoning, but at the end of the day your conclusion better jibe with what is legal in that state, even if you indicate you would do it under protest. So yeah, there usually is a right answer, ie one that will be better received. But there are permissible ways to frame an answer so that you still come off okay even if your answer is the "wrong" one. fWIW, I did have abortion questions back when I interviewed, usually in the context of minors who were patients and didn't want to tell their parents.
 
in most jurisdictions, the law creates a single "right" answer on the abortion issue. Regardless of your personal beliefs, which you are always entitled to, you have to be willing to abide by the law or few institutions will want you working there. Additionally, depending on who your interviewer is, there might be a better received "right" answer for these loaded questions. A female OBGYN is more likely to have a predictable position on the abortion issue. An interviewer at a more religious school (Loma Linda) possibly will have a different view. You are allowed to know your audience. You need to show your reasoning, but at the end of the day your conclusion better jibe with what is legal in that state, even if you indicate you would do it under protest. So yeah, there usually is a right answer, ie one that will be better received. But there are permissible ways to frame an answer so that you still come off okay even if your answer is the "wrong" one. fWIW, I did have abortion questions back when I interviewed, usually in the context of minors who were patients and didn't want to tell their parents.
Regarding the OP's example question, are there any states that have a legal requirement for a doctor to perform an abortion? Are there any that do not limit this requirement to actual cases of immediate need, such as you are the only doctor available and if the abortion is not performed immediately, the patient will die? I am curious because I was under the impression that there was no LEGAL duty for a physician to perform a procedure they are morally opposed to, such as abortion, with the possible exception of situations of dire need as mentioned above. I am neither a lawyer nor a doctor (yet), but that was my understanding. If there is no legal duty to perform a procedure, there wouldn't be a single, correct answer dictated by law.

Regarding notifying parents about a minor who wants an abortion, that is a completely different ethical question that I understand is quite clearly prescribed in individual state laws....
 
Physicians cannot be forced to perform elective abortions though as I remember Bill Clinton tried and failed to force military GP's to offer those services in remote locations whether they morally opposed them or not.
 
Top