Quantcast

is affirmative action used in the residency selection process?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Mdude

New Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
May 30, 2006
Messages
80
Reaction score
0

Members don't see this ad.
Just curious. Please, no flame war. If you don't know the answer, don't insert your opinion.
 

Instatewaiter

But... there's a troponin
Account on Hold
15+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 28, 2006
Messages
6,133
Reaction score
2,360
.
 
Last edited:

soulofmpatel

Full Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2008
Messages
306
Reaction score
20
No...although being a URM might help you to stand out. Most programs desire diversity in their class
 

Chemdude

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2008
Messages
1,656
Reaction score
168
^^^^ROFL....hahahahahahaha:laugh:

You are my hero Milkman.
 

PagingDrP

Kind of a big deal
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
May 3, 2008
Messages
151
Reaction score
0
Yes, it is used wherever certain minorities are underrepresented, which is definitely the case in medicine.
 

TupacalipseT96

R U Still Down?
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2008
Messages
560
Reaction score
4
So why does 90% of SDN have their panties in a bundle over "unqualified URMs getting into med school" ? If these terrible people are being 'let' in, then in theory they would just wind up in the least competitive specialties with unfilled residency spots anyway. Serving the needy and doing other filthy things.
 

DrYoda

Space Cowboy
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2008
Messages
13,815
Reaction score
129
So why does 90% of SDN have their panties in a bundle over "unqualified URMs getting into med school" ? If these terrible people are being 'let' in, then in theory they would just wind up in the least competitive specialties with unfilled residency spots anyway. Serving the needy and doing other filthy things.

Because a scapgoat is needed for when they don't get their dream residency spot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

Narmerguy

Full Member
Moderator Emeritus
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
6,874
Reaction score
1,352
Oh lordy here we go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

AZFutureDoc

Full Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
May 26, 2008
Messages
770
Reaction score
4
Actually, I can be of expertise here, because I'm in the process of writing a paper on cultural competency, and I read a long paper on how to increase it.

Example: Some town in AZ or CA has a hospital near or in the middle of a large Mexican population. The goal of most hospitals is to have certain proportions. In this case, one of the most important is the percentage of Hispanic staff, and especially doctors and nurses. So, if 65% of patients that go to this hospital are Hispanic, the hospital really wants to have a staff that is also 65% Hispanic, see what I am saying? One of the ways that they increase the percentage of Hispanics in the staff is to set up residencies at that hospital specifically designed to get Hispanic residents. So they set up this residency for only Hispanics, have a few positions, and get some Hispanic residents in there.


So yes, AA does exist, to a certain degree, in residency. First, there's programs, like the one above, that are common. But second, for any residency program, a hospital might want more of a certain race, and believe it or not, that race might be WHITE! However, you really can't know about any racially motivated goals of the people letting you into the residency, so its hard to take advantage of this. But race does come into play in residency because every hospital wants certain proportions of minorities and majorities, and they want "under-represented" minority docs available for "under-represented" minority patients. This can avoid a ton of problems similar to the whole Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down Hmong incident.


I actually feel like I was able to make an intelligent post! wow...
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Members don't see this ad :)

Law2Doc

5K+ Member
Moderator Emeritus
10+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2004
Messages
30,878
Reaction score
10,060
It depends on the residency director whos chosing people. Usually not, though some may want a more "diverse" group.

It's almost always done by committee, so it's not like a single person's bias is going to control this. A lot of programs like a diverse class of folks who are otherwise qualified. Bear in mind that in a match system, even though you rank someone highly, it doesn't mean you get them. So programs tend to rank many times more people than they need, and don't have a good sense of how deep into the ranking they will fall. So a program can end up all white, but that doesn't mean they didn't rank a lot of minorities toward the top of their match ranking. I doubt any program approaches the match with an affirmative action goal, but in putting together a diverse group, some impact may be seen.
 

BlackDr2b

JESUS DID IT, NOT ME!!!
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2006
Messages
2,616
Reaction score
4
We, as in SDN, just can't seem to get past this AA thing. Boy oh boy! I hope this one doesn't get ugly. In before the lock. God bless!
 

HumidBeing

In Memory of Riley Jane
Moderator Emeritus
Lifetime Donor
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2007
Messages
18,706
Reaction score
7
Law2Doc gave an excellent description of how the match works and the impact that has on the answer to this question.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

sirus_virus

nonsense poster
10+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2006
Messages
1,254
Reaction score
2
The more important question is "is there racism in the residency selection process" and the answer is yes, big time. There are lots of programs who have not seen a minority on staff for the past 20 years. I wonder why us white folks keep assuming diversty translates to less oportunities for us. If a minority takes your spot, remember another white guy could have easily done the same.
 

MsKrispyKreme

The "Hot" sign is on...
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2008
Messages
1,020
Reaction score
16
The more important question is "is there racism in the residency selection process" and the answer is yes, big time. There are lots of programs who have not seen a minority on staff for the past 20 years. I wonder why us white folks keep assuming diversty translates to less oportunities for us. If a minority takes your spot, remember another white guy could have easily done the same.

Interesting post.

I've read studies regarding discrimination in the job application process involving identically standardized applicants of varying ethnicites/races. Black applicants were half as likely to get a job offer than White applicants even though both groups had the same education, experience, etc. I wonder what the results would be if this was replicated using residency interviews. Hmmm...

Some people like to pretend that racism doesn't exist just because Obama is PE, but I guess they forget that there are no AAs in the Senate so we haven't come *that* far. :rolleyes:
 

cyclin M

megaman
10+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 24, 2008
Messages
337
Reaction score
1
Some people like to pretend that racism doesn't exist just because Obama is PE, but I guess they forget that there are no AAs in the Senate so we haven't come *that* far. :rolleyes:

And some people also like to pretend that just because there are no black people in X position The Man is out to get them and keeping them down.

Of course the reality is somewhere between these extremes. We cannot just say "AA" and "URM" and place these labels on people. That just puts them in a box and everything we see from that point on is the box talking/walking/etc, not the actual person.

The truth is, there is a mix. There are some URMs who are well-qualified and even without AA would have gotten into X medical school. In contrast, there are some URMs who are not qualified and would not get into those schools without AA.

It follows that there are non-URMs that would get into X medical school under an AA system (like in the status quo). In addition, there are also non-URMs that would NOT get into X medical school even with out AA.

So basically, just work hard, do your best, and stop attributing your failures to external forces that are beyond your control anyways. :thumbup:
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

MsKrispyKreme

The "Hot" sign is on...
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2008
Messages
1,020
Reaction score
16
And some people also like to pretend that just because there are no black people in X position The Man is out to get them and keeping them down.

Of course the reality is somewhere between these extremes. We cannot just say "AA" and "URM" and place these labels on people. That just puts them in a box and everything we see from that point on is the box talking/walking/etc, not the actual person.

The truth is, there is a mix. There are some URMs who are well-qualified and even without AA would have gotten into X medical school. In contrast, there are some URMs who are not qualified and would not get into those schools without AA.

It follows that there are non-URMs that would get into X medical school under an AA system (like in the status quo). In addition, there are also non-URMs that would NOT get into X medical school even with out AA.

So basically, just work hard, do your best, and stop attributing your failures to external forces that are beyond your control anyways. :thumbup:

What a useless post concerning med school when the topic is residency!
 

cyclin M

megaman
10+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 24, 2008
Messages
337
Reaction score
1
What a useless post concerning med school when the topic is residency!

Wow you have a bad attitude. Just replace med school with residency. Sorry you couldn't figure it out for yourself. :thumbdown: It is the pre-allo forum after all.

EDIT:

Why yes, it is indeed the pre-allo forum! A place where immature snots who can't admit they're wrong is not a rarity!

My favorite!! <3

hmm, not sure why you're attacking me, but I thought her post was pretty rude and the same goes for yours.:thumbdown: :thumbdown:
 
Last edited:
Members don't see this ad :)

snicket

ghettochip malfunction
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2008
Messages
182
Reaction score
1
Wow you have a bad attitude. Just replace med school with residency. Sorry you couldn't figure it out for yourself. :thumbdown: It is the pre-allo forum after all.

Why yes, it is indeed the pre-allo forum! A place where immature snots who can't admit they're wrong is not a rarity!

My favorite!! <3
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

HumidBeing

In Memory of Riley Jane
Moderator Emeritus
Lifetime Donor
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2007
Messages
18,706
Reaction score
7
This question has already been well answered. If you wish to discuss the original topic at hand, please stick to the topic and avoid being disrespectful and rude to other members. Rudeness does nothing to promote understanding of issues, and insulting other members is a violation of our Terms of Service.
 
2

229141

Who knows if it officially used or not...but even if they don't say they are using affirmative action they could still be doing it although not "officially"

(NO RACIST!!!)
 

EMDO2018

Membership Revoked
Removed
Joined
Oct 8, 2013
Messages
1,885
Reaction score
1,270
This question was never really answered.
 

Optimus-Prime

Full Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2013
Messages
693
Reaction score
475
And some people also like to pretend that just because there are no black people in X position The Man is out to get them and keeping them down.

Of course the reality is somewhere between these extremes. We cannot just say "AA" and "URM" and place these labels on people. That just puts them in a box and everything we see from that point on is the box talking/walking/etc, not the actual person.

The truth is, there is a mix. There are some URMs who are well-qualified and even without AA would have gotten into X medical school. In contrast, there are some URMs who are not qualified and would not get into those schools without AA.

It follows that there are non-URMs that would get into X medical school under an AA system (like in the status quo). In addition, there are also non-URMs that would NOT get into X medical school even with out AA.

So basically, just work hard, do your best, and stop attributing your failures to external forces that are beyond your control anyways. :thumbup:

good post, but you broke the commandment

Thou shalt never question the URM advantage
 

kavorca

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2008
Messages
455
Reaction score
397
and men will be at an advantage when applying to OB/GYN or peds and women will have an edge in many of the surgical subspecialties and attractive people will have an advantage in all specialties. Just suck it up.

and become more attractive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users

BestDoctorEver

Membership Revoked
Removed
5+ Year Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2009
Messages
2,854
Reaction score
815
Yes it is used in many ways or forms IMO. If going to offshore schools automatically disqualifies some applicants for some residencies, I would call that 'affirmative action' for US grads... It is always easy to complain about injustice when one is at the other end of the stick, but forget about injustice perpetrating on others... By the way, I am saying that as a US student.
 

mdambitions

Full Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2011
Messages
124
Reaction score
61
2008 was 6 years ago. still wondering though, if AA stops with med school admissions.

Ha! I swear...I can count. I'm sure others' biases and preferences filter through the process somehow. But like anything else, do your best, be your best, and it shouldn't really matter.
 
Top