- Joined
- Apr 15, 2005
- Messages
- 137
- Reaction score
- 0
How do you all feel about Kevin Troudeu and his book "Natural Cures they don't want you to know about?
Cowboy DO said:This man is such a fraud. He b!tches about the FDA and the pharm industry saying they want to keep you sick to make more money then in the same breath he says "buy my book for only 30 dollars". He is one of the few people in the world i truely hate. Just hearing his name makes me want to punch something.
adennis said:There is some merit to the natural cure comments though... there are some lesser known theories that the body's pH contributes to its health. You might want to check it out....
If you've had any experience with coping with illness that there is no medicinal cure/treatment for then you'll also know that there is little research done in those fields.. mostly because no pharmaceutical companies will pay for it (because they won't get any gain)...
I won't go into the conspiracy theory aspect of it all... but I think it may have some merit as well...you never know...
it kinda reminds me of that omm/craniosacral(sp?) crap the osteopaths push. no?Dies Irae said:What pisses me off about this jackass the most is how absurd and completely uneducated his claims are: curing cancer by making "the body less acidic?" That kind of BS is an insult to my intelligence!
housecleaning said:it kinda reminds me of that omm/craniosacral(sp?) crap the osteopaths push. no?
but if i am "trolling" then cranial is a-ok? typical osteopath response/logic.Dies Irae said:If you're not posting this for the purpose of trolling, then yes, I agree with you on the cranial, but not OMM.
housecleaning said:but if i am "trolling" then cranial is a-ok? typical osteopath response/logic.
Dies Irae said:Cranial is not ok, but judging by your other posting history, you are more interested in bashing osteopathic medicine than defending responsible scientific practice, which is why I do not see a need to defend my profession against you.
espbeliever said:dies, how can u say that cs is not ok? ur not even in school yet! neither am i, so i refuse to decide one way or another on it yet until i can learn more and experience it.
there is soooooo much to the human body that there are no studies on that we already know about, and there are even more studies yet to be done that we know nothing about. saying there is no study to prove/disprove is pointless. to use it to argue against alternative treatments is wrong. like the early church saying the sun revolves around the earth or something.
wait to learn more about things before you make decisions..., and even more so, before you advise others with your "decisions"... i have personally experienced some of the "alternative" treatments and actions and i can say there is definitely yet more to learn that they are not KNOWLEDGABLE enough to teach us...
espbeliever said:dies, how can u say that cs is not ok? ur not even in school yet! neither am i, so i refuse to decide one way or another on it yet until i can learn more and experience it.
there is soooooo much to the human body that there are no studies on that we already know about, and there are even more studies yet to be done that we know nothing about. saying there is no study to prove/disprove is pointless. to use it to argue against alternative treatments is wrong. like the early church saying the sun revolves around the earth or something.
wait to learn more about things before you make decisions..., and even more so, before you advise others with your "decisions"... i have personally experienced some of the "alternative" treatments and actions and i can say there is definitely yet more to learn that they are not KNOWLEDGABLE enough to teach us...
Dies Irae said:You misunderstand why I said it. Primarily, I was responding to this insecure troller's wisecrack. How am I "advising others" for or against alternative medicine by stating my personal opinion? I will have to learn cranial when I got to med school, just like everyone else here, and I do plan to judge for myself whether or not it is valid. But when you look into cranialsacral therapy, there seems to be valid evidence against it vs. a few andectodotal cases for it. If there were enough research backing it up, I would definately have a better opinion of it. Regardless, it is irresponsible to overstate any treatment's scope and application, which seems to be the real problem with some of the sketchy practitioners out there, and that is the reason I am against it. I am not saying cranial therapy is completely useless, but if someone is going to make claims for the benefits of a certain procedure, he should make every effort to back it up with science rather than patients' testamonies.
If you believe in faith-based healing, then good for you, but you should respect the fact that many of us dont. I never condemned alternative medicine, as you assumed I did. Alternative medicine is a very broad term, which can apply to both treatments that are valid but less popular as well as utter BS, like the "miracle cure biotape" Kevin Trudeau has been selling, and you have to realize that for every underacknowledged alternative treament that could have great benefit, there are thousands upon thousands of BS theories and scams. The only way to tell the difference is with rigorous scientific testing and, as objectively as possible, accpeting the scrutiny of other scientists.
espbeliever said:no i am not a follower of "faith based" healings as they call it. i do believe in prayer, and Jesus as my Savior, and i believe God can/will fix things as GOD sees fit. in the faith based cult, they see it as they no longer ask God for something, but basically see God as their waiter and they give their orders...
i do understand better what you meant now, sorry for jumping the gun.
i consider myself to be for the most part pretty realistic. if i see something that works and amazes me, i try to learn as much as i can about it. it is some of these odd things that most of western medicine has either forgotten about or will not even talk about for whatever reason. i think that is wrong... but thats just me. i am not going to suggest that a treatment may be the correct course of action for anything unless there is documented evidence in some fashion, yet i would like to learn more about other things that are not documented as i think there is still great potential...
oh well....
ive read some on cranial, some of it seems like it has a possibility of doing good, while probablly most is not so good. but i think for the most part, either way, you have inconclusive evidence. so i think i want to learn more, experience it, etc... thas just me though...
have a great day.
adennis said:I'm not saying that I agree with him.. or that I've read his book.. the only reason that I have a CLUE who this guy is, is that I saw him doing an infomercial on tv when I was visiting the St. Louis area a couple weeks ago..
There is some merit to the natural cure comments though... there are some lesser known theories that the body's pH contributes to its health. You might want to check it out....
If you've had any experience with coping with illness that there is no medicinal cure/treatment for then you'll also know that there is little research done in those fields.. mostly because no pharmaceutical companies will pay for it (because they won't get any gain)...
I won't go into the conspiracy theory aspect of it all... but I think it may have some merit as well...you never know...
beano said:I agree with you 100%. It is easy to forget that western medicine IS the new kid on the block. Just because our training does not always include alternative treatments does not mean we should bash those we have not yet studied for ourselves. I have read a few pages out of the book "Natural cures they don't want you to know about" and it presents some information that seems logical and worthwhile (such as increasing omega-3 fatty acid intake in the diet reduces the risk of cardiovascular disease, scientific literature does back this up). However this guy also presents some information that is misleading and focuses on a "us vs. them" type of reasoning. Big pharmaceutical companies do influence when and what physicians prescribe. I agree...It should be a crime.... Does the Pharmaceutical industry have influential ties with the CDC? Absolutely! I checked for myself. Do pharmaceutial drugs both kill people and save lives? You bet! My point is we should all have open minds despite what our "training" or "program" dictates. As if I need to say it... we should investigate a theory before we draw a conclusion because without doing so we could unknowingly fail to find a cure. Arrogance can kill. he steps down from the soapbox...
-B
Dies Irae said:I would rather trust the greediest most socially irresponsible drug campany than this con-artist. I thumbed through the book too at the local bookstore, and there is nothing he says about alternative medicine that you can't get elsewhere at more reputable sources. His book has a very clear agenda but no significant information on any of these "natural cures" that the FDA does not want us to know about.
http://www.thinkbling.com/detail.php?ASIN=0975599518
kcumbDO said:How do you all feel about Kevin Troudeu and his book "Natural Cures they don't want you to know about?