Here is one of the times where what seems like the most logical scenario is not what happens. I would have thought that creatinine would increase due to decreased GFR, but Ehhhh! Wrong!
According to Best Practice-BMJ:
"Physiological adaptation
Serum creatinine levels increase after kidney donation or after unilateral or partial nephrectomy. After an initial rise, serum creatinine decreases due to hyperfiltration by the remaining nephrons and reaches a new steady state. In the long term, serum creatinine remains at 141 to 159 micromol/L (1.6 to 1.8 mg/dL) in patients who have a normal contralateral kidney. Any sustained rise in serum creatinine above the normal range requires further investigation."
Apparently when the remaining kidney picks up the slack and hypertrophies, it ends up hyperfiltrating. So that eventually there is even less serum creatinine (increased filtered load) than before the nephrectomy.